or to join or start a new Discussion

33 Comments
Article Rating 2.14 Stars

How's this fair

On one hand you have Evans who spits first, denies the charges and has yet to issue any form of an apology and on the hand you have Cisse, who reacted to a disgusting act (admittedly with the exact same act), accepted the charges right away and issued a public apology ASAP

The former gets a more lenient punishment than the latter (the fact that they put this down to cisse's past actions is ridiculous as he was already punished for that)

Can't help but feel that had the foreigner been Evans and the Brit been Cisse, the foreigner would've got a more severe punishment than the Brit




posted on 7/3/15

The whole thing is a farce and has been blown out of proportion. Spitting is disgusting and should be punished.

However, it's ridiculous that spitting gets a 6 game ban, yet slapping someone round the face or a potential leg breaker should get a 3 game ban. Half the punishment! Shocking FA yet again.

And any suggestion that Cisse is some kind of Saint for admitting it, is BS. He made a pretty bad tackle, then tried to kick Evans, then spat at him. Should be a 10 game ban given the crazy FA, pull a number out of a hat, rules.

posted on 7/3/15

And still people insist Evans 'spat on the floor'...

Are you nuts? He spat downwards towards where Cisse was, right in front of him. For him to miss Cisse and hit the floor he'd have had to tilt his head left or right and spit to the side of Cisse, as opposed to, ya know, what he clearly did in every video clip of the incident available: looked directly at Cisse and spat in his direction.

Genuinely baffled as to how anyone is seeing anything different. Time to take off the United-tinted specs guys.

That said, it's a very harsh ban for both players

posted on 7/3/15

I think even bans is right in the context of Cisse's behaviour being obviously worse, but he was much more apologetic. And Evans behaviour wasn't as bad but he didn't apologise for it.

the 2 factors nett out evens for me

posted on 7/3/15

The OP's point is valid(apart from the nepotism claim)
Cisse admitted guilt and reason for his action whilst Evan denied it, was found guilty and both got the same punishment

There is no going back now and Evans ban wont be increased.

To all Utd fans regardless of if you think Evans did it or not, surely you have to agree ignoring your obvious bias, that after the FA found him he had to get a longer ban

Its ludicrous that they both got the same punishment, clearly admitting guilt makes absolutely no difference whatsoever, no wonder Evans denied it

PS: and to all comments claiming the OP is turning the incident into a racial thing, the OP never once mentioned race

posted on 7/3/15

It's just racist!!

posted on 7/3/15

I've only just seen the video. I'm amazed he appealed to be honest.

posted on 7/3/15

If you spit at the exact time you are having a fight with another player then obviously people are going to think it's a deliberate attempt to spit at that player.

Spitting can sometimes be an unconscious act, accidental as you shout a word out in anger. Evans incident doesn't look like that though, it looks like a knowing spit.

Either he was aiming for Cisse, or he chose a really weird and silly time to clear his mouth.

If it's the latter then he has been a little silly and a little unlucky, but the moral is don't spit anywhere when you are arguing with another player.

posted on 7/3/15

In court, if you admit to your wrongdoings, you almost always get a reduced sentence or fine, why should it be different in football?

comment by Cloggy (U1250)

posted on 7/3/15

OP muppet

posted on 8/3/15

We see more and more racist articles on this forum. Needs to be cut out.

As for Evans, what he did was clearly deliberate imo. But for him and Cisse to get lengthy bans whilst in the same round of fixtures Alan Hutton viciously and deliberately studs a man in the nuts is just not right imo. For all the talk I've seen here that they'd rather be on the end of a rotten tackle than be spat at, I call BS. There's no doubt about what will leave the longer lasting effect.

On an aside, it was interested to see how all and sundry in the media were suddenly United in calling for the length of bans for spitting to be increased still further. I wonder if it's a coincedence that this collective brain storm came about when a Man United player was involved....

Sign in if you want to comment
RATE THIS ARTICLE
Rate Breakdown
5
0 Votes
4
0 Votes
3
0 Votes
2
0 Votes
1
0 Votes

Average Rating: 2.14 from 7 votes

ARTICLE STATS
Day
Article RankingNot Ranked
Article ViewsNot Available
Average Time(mins)Not Available
Total Time(mins)Not Available
Month
Article RankingNot Ranked
Article ViewsNot Available
Average Time(mins)Not Available
Total Time(mins)Not Available