I got told i was a fool and no nothing for suggesting Mane is our best signing as a club since Luis Suarez.
No player has had the pace, directness, work rate or skill to excite this much since IMO. Not even coutinho who while a magician on his day is so frustratingly inconsistent and often marked out of game.
Even at 34 mil i think he's a bargain in these days terms already (mad I know but its how it is
here is my list then... who is better?
Loris Karius £4,700,000
Joël Matip Free
Sadio Mane £34,000,000
Ragnar Klavan £4,200,000
Georginio Wijnaldum £25,000,000
Alex Manninger Free
Marko Grujić £5,100,000
Roberto Firmino £29,000,000
Joe Gomez £3,500,000
Ádám Bogdán Free
Danny Ings Tribunal
James Milner Free
Nathaniel Clyne £12,500,000
Christian Benteke £32,500,000
Emre Can £10,000,000
Rickie Lambert £4,000,000
Adam Lallana £25,000,000
Lazar Marković £20,000,000
Dejan Lovren £20,000,000
Divock Origi £10,000,000
Alberto Moreno £12,000,000
Mario Balotelli £16,000,000
Lawrence Vigouroux
Kevin Stewart
Luis Alberto £6,800,000
Iago Aspas £7,000,000
Kolo Toure Free
Simon Mignolet £10,000,000
Tiago Ilori £7,000,000
Mamadou Sakho £18,000,000
Fabio Borini £10,000,000
Joe Allen £15,000,000
Oussama Assaidi £2,300,000
Samed Yesil £1,000,000
Daniel Sturridge £12,000,000
Philippe Coutinho £8,500,000
Jordan Ibe £500,000
Jordan Henderson £16,000,000
Charlie Adam £7,000,000
Doni Free
Stewart Downing £20,000,000
Sanchez Jose Enrique £6,300,000
Sebastian Coates £7,000,000
Sotirios Kyrgiakos Free
Villyan Bijev Signed
Danny Ward £100,000
Jonjo Shelvey £1,700,000
Milan Jovanović Free
Danny Wilson £2,000,000
Joe Cole Free
Fabio Aureilo Free
Christian Poulson £4,500,000
Brad Jones £2,300,000
Raul Meireles £11,500,000
Paul Konchesky Swap
Suso
Yusuf Mersin £450,000
Luis Suarez £23,000,000
Andrew Carroll £35,000,000
..................................................................................................................................
Just what player has looked half the player mane is. I don't need to judge him over a full season. I paid attention to what occurred at southampton last year. PLayers struggle when the team struggles, suarez was no different. NO PLAYER have given me more hope than this guy since suarez.
Signings between Mane and Suarez.
posted on 30/8/16
comment by moreinjuredthanowen (U9641)
posted 16 minutes ago
comment by Terminator1 (U1863)
posted 10 minutes ago
Op. You're completely missing the point. You were slated for going way over the top and getting too excited over someone who's played two games for us. There's not one Liverpool fan who hasn't been delighted with his start, and hope it continues to the point he does become our best recent signing.
But to state this now is ridiculous, no matter what happens in the future. And stop acting so offended just because everyone disagrees with you....
----------------------------------------------------------------------
not allowed an opinion basically cos you speak for everyonei get you now.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Not at all. You were stating your opinion as if there was no doubt whatsoever, and couldn't be argued with. Of course you're allowed an opinion, but by the same token you can't cry and create a tantrum article when the vast majority disagree with you.
posted on 30/8/16
It's not even that people think the opinion is wrong, simply that people think it's ridiculous to claim it after a handful of games.
For some reason you don't get it.
Another drama queen who wants everyone else to agree how brilliant he is at knowing about football.
posted on 30/8/16
either of you care to answer the question then.. who's better.
I've not disagreed with others who've answered it here but then they didn't throw and insult or 3 either mind.
I've taken your insults and expanded on why I feel the way i feel about the player in question explaining why but that doesn't seem to have mattered either.
posted on 30/8/16
I think Mane is our second world class player along with Coutinho. Can't wait to see how he goes in a red shirt.
posted on 30/8/16
Right now Coutinho, Sturridge, Clyne are all proven better, great value and high quality. I think both Origi and Can will prove to be fantastic signings as well, but too early to call them that at the moment.
Come May Mane might have put himself in or ahead of that pack, we'll see. Unlike all the others he has a massive fee to live up to.
Doesn't change the fact that saying it after a handful of games is facking ridiculous.
posted on 30/8/16
comment by selbstgerechtein (U7048)
posted 2 minutes ago
Right now Coutinho, Sturridge, Clyne are all proven better, great value and high quality. I think both Origi and Can will prove to be fantastic signings as well, but too early to call them that at the moment.
Come May Mane might have put himself in or ahead of that pack, we'll see. Unlike all the others he has a massive fee to live up to.
Doesn't change the fact that saying it after a handful of games is facking ridiculous.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
fine... thats a good opinion.
I might offer that this is Can's third season with us but i would agree that at 22 he is still developing.
My opinion is mane is the only one that's got me excited to come back and watch next game for a very long time. I think he's our best player already and you disagreeing with me is fine as its all opinion.....
but throwing insults at fellow reds? only my friends are allowed do that
posted on 30/8/16
comment by moreinjuredthanowen (U9641)
posted 45 minutes ago
comment by selbstgerechtein (U7048)
posted 2 minutes ago
Right now Coutinho, Sturridge, Clyne are all proven better, great value and high quality. I think both Origi and Can will prove to be fantastic signings as well, but too early to call them that at the moment.
Come May Mane might have put himself in or ahead of that pack, we'll see. Unlike all the others he has a massive fee to live up to.
Doesn't change the fact that saying it after a handful of games is facking ridiculous.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
fine... thats a good opinion.
I might offer that this is Can's third season with us but i would agree that at 22 he is still developing.
My opinion is mane is the only one that's got me excited to come back and watch next game for a very long time. I think he's our best player already and you disagreeing with me is fine as its all opinion.....
but throwing insults at fellow reds? only my friends are allowed do that
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Look, you've gotten excited over his first two league starts for us. No problem with that, I think we all have. But everyone else has tempered that excitement in the knowledge that it's only two games. You simply cannot make an objective decision on the success of a transfer after two games. It is nothing but ridiculous.
If you'd have said that you believe he will prove to be our best/most exciting signing since Suarez, then I'm pretty sure you wouldn't have gotten the same reaction. In fact, I'd wager that many would have agreed with you, myself included.
posted on 30/8/16
My opinion is of course still ridiculous etc
posted on 30/8/16
comment by moreinjuredthanowen (U9641)
posted 46 minutes ago
My opinion is of course still ridiculous etc
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Yes it is, IMO. I've also explained why, constructively. If you're so massively offended by your opinion being called ridiculous, then you seriously need to man up. Or join mumsnet
posted on 30/8/16
comment by Terminator1 (U1863)
posted 12 minutes ago
comment by moreinjuredthanowen (U9641)
posted 46 minutes ago
My opinion is of course still ridiculous etc
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Yes it is, IMO. I've also explained why, constructively. If you're so massively offended by your opinion being called ridiculous, then you seriously need to man up. Or join mumsnet
----------------------------------------------------------------------
What is your username on mumsnet