Stay or go

Jose go. Pogba is a talented player but needs to be used specifically or he’s crap. Even when used in his preferred position is inconsistent, which some of might be down to the manager. So not fussed if we can cash in on him either.

Would a different manager get more out of the players should be the first question?

It looks from the outside that Jose has demoralised the player but I could be wrong.

With rumours that martial “a good player” also wants out would you say Jose would be more successful getting new player or another manager reinvigorating the squad would be more beneficial in the long run?

scholes just said it about right. Pog will probably be off this summer.

comment by LQ (U6305)
posted 1 hour, 9 minutes ago
Would a different manager get more out of the players should be the first question?

It looks from the outside that Jose has demoralised the player but I could be wrong.

With rumours that martial “a good player” also wants out would you say Jose would be more successful getting new player or another manager reinvigorating the squad would be more beneficial in the long run?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Possibly. The talent is there, the attitude is that of a spoilt superstar, who in reality doesn’t deserve it.

Jose like I imagine a lot of mangers would, has tried to turn him into a proper cm. but he lacks the attributes to do it, awareness, intelligence.,he’s great when given time to pick out oasses, top quality. But he’s never going to be good in that position due to the lack of the aforementioned qualities, and defensive sensiblllity.

True master of that sort if ball playing play dictating midfielder play, can plot ahead a few steps. . Pogba can’t.

Fergie probably had him worked out... can you imagine any of this lot playing for at his peak? De Gea, that’s it.

Herrera would have been an SAF player.