This makes interesting reading, it is the new valuations worked out by CIES Football Observatory.
http://www.football-observatory.com/IMG/sites/b5wp/2018/239/en/
Some very contentious valuations which should make for interesting comments all round!
For instance Lukaku is valued at £164m
Player Valuations Across Europe
posted on 9/11/18
Ederson is the better of the two imo. Plus Allison although playing in the W.C has only started two of their last four. Debatable.
posted on 9/11/18
comment by TobyJanKaneobi (U15068)
posted 32 seconds ago
Ederson is the better of the two imo. Plus Allison although playing in the W.C has only started two of their last four. Debatable.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Well no it's not debatable. Alisson is Brazil's number one. Ederson has two caps?
posted on 9/11/18
Alisson was nominated for Balon D'or. Ederson wasn't. Alisson is Brazil's first choice. Just because you believe Ederson is better, whilst his peers, including his international manager doesn't, doesn't make him number 2.
posted on 9/11/18
I have watched the two more than enough to form an opinion on whom is the better of the two. And I ain’t just talking about this season. Mark my words Ederson is the better.. time will show that!
posted on 9/11/18
comment by TobyJanKaneobi (U15068)
posted 24 minutes ago
I have watched the two more than enough to form an opinion on whom is the better of the two. And I ain’t just talking about this season. Mark my words Ederson is the better.. time will show that!
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I have no issue with you thinking he's better. It's about opinions and both are top keepers so there is no clear choice. My issue is only with you saying Alisson is Brazil's number 2 which is false.
posted on 9/11/18
That is exactly it, it’s all about opinion football. But for you to ridicule mine on the basis of who has started more games is nonsense. Let’s remember this is the same Brazilian manager’s judgement your basing as a barometer. A manager that insisted on playing Paulinho in Brazil’s starting 11. He probably isn’t even in the top 10 Brazilian MFs.
posted on 9/11/18
For instance Lukaku is valued at £164m
-----------
Dier 90m
posted on 9/11/18
Wijnaldum, bellerin, TAA
posted on 9/11/18
comment by TobyJanKaneobi (U15068)
posted 45 minutes ago
That is exactly it, it’s all about opinion football. But for you to ridicule mine on the basis of who has started more games is nonsense. Let’s remember this is the same Brazilian manager’s judgement your basing as a barometer. A manager that insisted on playing Paulinho in Brazil’s starting 11. He probably isn’t even in the top 10 Brazilian MFs.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I'm not ridiculing your opinion. I simply pointed out your statement about Alisson being Brazil's number two was incorrect.
posted on 9/11/18
On Paulinho, I disagree. Yes he was crap for Spurs but he's a good player. Actually if you look at Brazil's midfield options they're pretty light.