Dunkirk vs 1917

comment by Blue in the face (U22288)
posted 10 seconds ago
Meh, it was like a Hallmark movie for the most part. Had a couple of well directed intense moments on the battlefield, but I want more from a director like Gibson.

p
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Fair enough, horses for courses, I see inglorious mentioned a lot, as a good film, but it’s typical Tarantino mindless waffle for the sake of it. Dislikable characters, (made me want the Germans to win ffs!) but has some decent tense scenes. I might give it a rewatch to see if it grows on me, but I really hate tarrantino’s mindless try-to-hard-but-goes-nowhere filler dialogue. I suppose atleast inglorious has less of that than most of his movies, hateful 8 for example was sheer boredom.

comment by Blue in the face (U22288)
posted 31 minutes ago
Meh, it was like a Hallmark movie for the most part. Had a couple of well directed intense moments on the battlefield, but I want more from a director like Gibson.

p
----------------------------------------------------------------------
It was fantastic. Character driven. True story. Intense. Great film imo.

I would take platoon over Dunkirk if I’m honest, brilliant film.

Comment Deleted by Site Moderator

Comment Deleted by Site Moderator

Comment Deleted by Site Moderator

comment by Blue in the face (U22288)
posted 31 minutes ago
comment by Ole-Dirty-Baztard (U19119)
posted 1 hour, 40 minutes ago
comment by Blue in the face (U22288)
posted 10 seconds ago
Meh, it was like a Hallmark movie for the most part. Had a couple of well directed intense moments on the battlefield, but I want more from a director like Gibson.

p
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Fair enough, horses for courses, I see inglorious mentioned a lot, as a good film, but it’s typical Tarantino mindless waffle for the sake of it. Dislikable characters, (made me want the Germans to win ffs!) but has some decent tense scenes. I might give it a rewatch to see if it grows on me, but I really hate tarrantino’s mindless try-to-hard-but-goes-nowhere filler dialogue. I suppose atleast inglorious has less of that than most of his movies, hateful 8 for example was sheer boredom.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Respectfully disagreeI consider Tarantino’s work to be near flawless.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Fair enough, I consider it to be very flawed and overindulgent. Each to their own.

Comment Deleted by Site Moderator

Both are boring as fck !

1917 is pretty fcking dreadful

Too often the main character is a complete douche

Whats happening here then?!
Both boring as fck .. Dreadful?!!! man, you a hard guy to please...