Who would you pick

Mane
Son
.
Sterling
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Rashford

Son is the man on form right now so I would say him.

Mane and Sterling are not having the best of seasons but probably ahead of Son overall.

Rashford is in the tier below all of them and needs more consistency to get to where they are or have been.

Comment Deleted by Site Moderator

Comment Deleted by Site Moderator

Fit and on form if we were in a CL final tomorrow;

Mane
Son
Sterling
Rashford

Rashford being 5 years younger than Son and Mane gives him some room to improve yet, as I'm not sure they were at his level at the same age. No reason his maturity/decision making won't improve with the rest of his game.

Sterling has grown to be so productive in that city side, yes they make a lot of chances but the fact he seems to score so many tap ins/goals from inside the 6 yard box is down to his ability to find space so well, almost like a strikers instincts. He's worse when he has lots of time to think what to do.

Mane is one of the worlds best wingers at the moment no question so he's top for me.

Son is fantastic too, and obviously works perfectly with Kane, not sure he's really a winger thought like the other 3 he seems more of a support striker.

comment by Don Draper's dandruff (U20155)
posted 56 minutes ago
comment by morespurs (U15748)
posted 4 minutes ago

Mane, because he is awkard customer and genuinely a tread in his day.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
unless he's very tyred
----------------------------------------------------------------------

comment by Ace (U22467)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by Spurtle (U1608)
posted 1 minute ago
Son is the man on form right now so I would say him.

Mane and Sterling are not having the best of seasons but probably ahead of Son overall.

Rashford is in the tier below all of them and needs more consistency to get to where they are or have been.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Not a chance Sterling is a better player than Son.

Sterling has good moments but he’s a bit of a tap in merchant for a team that has been playing it round the oppo with ease. I see him for England & City time and again get into great positions with the ball only to be too indecisive in his decision making, overplay it and waste the opportunity. He’s decent when he plays on instinct but is not a clinical or intelligent player. He is certainly nowhere near as clinical as Son and can only dream of having Sons shooting and finishing ability with both feet - Son in that City team the last three years would’ve torn it up massively.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
He isn't this season but Sterling has been in world class form for longer than Son has in my opinion, that's why I'd have him ahead. Look at their stats the past few years:

Sterling:

17/18 - 18 goals in 33, 11 assists
18/19 - 17 in 34, 10 assists
19/20 - 20 in 33, 1 assist

Son:

17/18 - 12 in 37, 6 assists
18/19 - 12 in 31, 6 assists
19/20 - 11 in 30, 10 assists

Sterling's are better than Son's. I know he plays in a better team also but he has turned into a key player for City and a game changer since the 17/18 season. It's only the last year and a halfish that Son has transitioned from top class to world class. If he keeps maintaining his current levels then he'll be up there and go beyond Sterling.

Mane
Son

Sterling

Rashford

Mane - fast as anything and very physical. A right back's nightmare. Does miss some sitters but clinical down the years. Favourite

Sterling - strong as well and looks to be getting better and better. Tricky in tight spaces and great at keeping the ball close to him. Still to reach his peak years.

Son - 3rd because of his defensive play and physicality. Sometimes he is easy to push off the ball and not strong enough when trying to win it back. One of best in one v one situations. Unlucky yday. At 28 he is in the peak of his career. Class.

Rashford - Sometimes too fast for his own good but has the potential to be a beast and the youngest of the four. Will only get better and better.

comment by MKspur ツ - The Fountain of Knowledge (U9129)
posted 5 hours, 21 minutes ago
Mane is the best
Son is my favourite
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Son is the best
Son is my favourite