or to join or start a new Discussion

66 Comments
Article Rating 3.67 Stars

Player Comparisons (Who Is Better)

Okay, so for those that do not know I used to create this article yearly where I'd place 2 players who I feel are on the same wavelength together and ask for your choice on who is better. That was on the old 606 so may experience a new reaction from you guys but this article used to rack up nearly 100, interestingly.

Moving on.. with a year gone past a lot has changed in football and players I compared last year have gone into different directions e.g 'Modric or Silva' 'Yaya Toure or Essien' 'Kompany or Ivanovic' 'Iniesta or Snidjer' which resulted in split opinions before but now, yes big things have changed since. So now 2012 edition. I will be going off this years form btw
Just write the name of your choice. Enjoy and Decide

The obvious first.
Ronaldo or Messi
Kompany or Pique
Hart or Neuer
Rooney or Van Persie
Fabregas or Sneidjer
Silva or Ozil
Di Maria or Mata
Yaya Toure or Schweinsteigher (Box-box midfielders)
Cole or Evra
Richards or Ramos
Balotelli or Benzema
Aguero or Higuain
Dzeko or Gomez
Suarez or Lavezzi
Ibrahimovic or Cavani
Adebayor or Ba
Torres or Heskey (lbs)
Sturridge or Welbeck
Llorente or Huntelaar
Robben or Bale
Nani or Gervinho
Young or Pedro
Oxlade-Chamberlain or Neymar
Sczenzney or De Gea
Jones or Varane

Fire away, some you disagree with but just answer with honesty please
Any I forgot will be in part 2 (Stay Tuned)
Also discovered I can't include many other teams to post this too like the old 606

posted on 11/3/12

"That tells me I do not need to take a debate with yourself seriously"
===

Elaborate.

posted on 11/3/12

Suarez or Lavezzi - Lavezzi
__________________________

Change that too a draw. My dislike for Suarez clouded my judgement there.

posted on 11/3/12

Don't understand the people who think Ade is better than Ba. Ba is a much better player.

comment by baz83 (U9225)

posted on 11/3/12

Ronaldo or Messi - Messi
Kompany or Pique - Kompany
Hart or Neuer - Close call; Neuer
Rooney or Van Persie - For his all round play; Rooney
Fabregas or Sneidjer - Sneijder
Silva or Ozil - Silva
Di Maria or Mata - Di Maria
Yaya Toure or Schweinsteigher (Box-box midfielders) -Toure
Cole or Evra - Both are past their best; Evra
Richards or Ramos - Ramos
Balotelli or Benzema - Benzema
Aguero or Higuain - Higuain
Dzeko or Gomez - Gomez
Suarez or Lavezzi - Lavezzi
Ibrahimovic or Cavani - Cavani
Adebayor or Ba - Ba
Torres or Heskey (lbs) - Neither, but if I must; Torres
Sturridge or Welbeck - Sturridge
Llorente or Huntelaar - Llorente
Robben or Bale - Bale
Nani or Gervinho - Nani
Young or Pedro - Pedro
Oxlade-Chamberlain or Neymar - Hope you're joking; Neymar by a country mile
Sczenzney or De Gea - Sczenzney
Jones or Varane - Jones

posted on 12/3/12

Neymar needs to come to Europe sooner rather than later to get to that 'Superstar Status' if you ask me

posted on 12/3/12

at anyone who put..

Sneijder being better than Fabregas.
Rooney being better than RVP.
Sneijder being better than Fabregas.
Toure being better than Shsweinsteiger.
Hart being better than Neuer.
Cole being better than Evra.
Ramos being better than Richards.
Young being better than Pedro.
Or Szcccncnenny ahead of De Gea

posted on 12/3/12

Ronaldo or Messi - Messi
Kompany or Pique - Kompany
Hart or Neuer - Neuer
Rooney or Van Persie - Rooney
Fabregas or Sneidjer - Fabregas
Silva or Ozil - Ozil
Di Maria or Mata - Mata
Yaya Toure or Schweinsteigher - Schweinsteiger
Cole or Evra - Evra
Richards or Ramos - Ramos
Balotelli or Benzema - Balotelli
Aguero or Higuain -Aguero
Dzeko or Gomez - Dzeko
Suarez or Lavezzi - Suarez
Ibrahimovic or Cavani - Cavani
Adebayor or Ba - Ba
Torres or Heskey (lbs) - Torres
Sturridge or Welbeck - Sturridge
Llorente or Huntelaar - Llorente
Robben or Bale - Robben
Nani or Gervinho - Nani
Young or Pedro - Pedro
Oxlade-Chamberlain or Neymar - Neymar
Sczenzney or De Gea - Szczesny
Jones or Varane - Varane

posted on 12/3/12

Ronaldo or Messi - Messi
Kompany or Pique - Kompany
Hart or Neuer - Neuer
Rooney or Van Persie - RvP
Fabregas or Sneidjer - Fabregas
Silva or Ozil - Silva
Di Maria or Mata - Mata
Yaya Toure or Schweinsteigher - Schweinsteiger
Cole or Evra - Cole
Richards or Ramos - Ramos
Balotelli or Benzema - Benzema
Aguero or Higuain -Aguero
Dzeko or Gomez - Gomez
Suarez or Lavezzi - Lavezzi
Ibrahimovic or Cavani - Ibrahimovic
Adebayor or Ba - Ba
Torres or Heskey (lbs) - Torres
Sturridge or Welbeck - Sturridge
Llorente or Huntelaar - Llorente
Robben or Bale - Robben
Nani or Gervinho - Nani
Young or Pedro - Pedro
Oxlade-Chamberlain or Neymar - Neymar
Sczenzney or De Gea - Szczesny
Jones or Varane - Varane

posted on 12/3/12

I believe Rooney is better than RVP but Robin is just having one of THOSE special seasons. (Arsenal Fan)

posted on 12/3/12

Results have now been posted

Sign in if you want to comment
RATE THIS ARTICLE
Rate Breakdown
5
0 Votes
4
0 Votes
3
0 Votes
2
0 Votes
1
0 Votes

Average Rating: 3.67 from 4 votes

ARTICLE STATS
Day
Article RankingNot Ranked
Article ViewsNot Available
Average Time(mins)Not Available
Total Time(mins)Not Available
Month
Article RankingNot Ranked
Article ViewsNot Available
Average Time(mins)Not Available
Total Time(mins)Not Available