or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 1531062 comments are related to an article called:

The Haven

Page 43220 of 61243

comment by Obers (U3904)

posted on 23/6/18

VAR is a load of balls

If that goes out for a corner, the ref checks it and gives the pen IMO, yet because play continued no pen??

comment by g7 (U12473)

posted on 23/6/18

VAR checks everything, if they were going to overturn they would have told him on the earpiece and he would have stopped play next time the ball went out of play.

comment by Obers (U3904)

posted on 23/6/18

Play went on for ages g7

I think the ref was embarrassed to go back that far

comment by g7 (U12473)

posted on 23/6/18

He thought it wasn’t a pen. If he wanted to check he could have stopped play and made the motion for the VAR check.

The VAR checks everything throughout the match and if they though it was a “clear and obvious error” they would have told him on the earpiece.

Personally I think it was a pen but the ref didn’t refer it because he thought it wasn’t and the VAR must not have thought it was a clear error so no overturning the decision.

comment by Obers (U3904)

posted on 23/6/18

It was a clear pen

Tug back on the shoulder when striker was ready to shoot + a sliding tackle without getting the ball

comment by Obers (U3904)

posted on 23/6/18

My initial point was the ref would have been more willing to check VAR if the ball went out immediately. Because play carried on for a couple of minutes before play was stopped I think the ref was reluctant to go back to the incident.

Penalty decisions should be decided on circumstance (how long until the ball goes out of play)

comment by Obers (U3904)

posted on 23/6/18

Shouldn't be

comment by g7 (U12473)

posted on 23/6/18

Undoubtedly VAR needs refinement but it is good enough in its current iteration to have given that pen.

Even if the ball had immediately gone out of play I don’t believe the ref would have asked for VAR.
The video assisstants should have told the ref that he had made an error.


Lol Germany

comment by Obers (U3904)

posted on 23/6/18

Don't the VAR officials tell the ref if he has made an error to go and check the tv at the side of the pitch?

I didn't think the ref had to be unsure

comment by g7 (U12473)

posted on 23/6/18

The ref doesn’t have to check the monitor on the side of the pitch, just an option.

comment by g7 (U12473)

posted on 23/6/18

What a goal

posted on 23/6/18

LASweden

posted on 23/6/18


posted on 23/6/18

Alfredo Pedullà @AlfredoPedulla
Rugani, Chelsea now wants to break trought the wall of 35 milllion! And Juve opens

posted on 23/6/18

Let's break the wall.

comment by CSTP (U1453)

posted on 23/6/18

Break the walls dooooown

posted on 24/6/18

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 24/6/18

It's gonna happen before the month ends. I'm predicting this Monday.

posted on 24/6/18

CHELSEA

comment by RtM (U1097)

posted on 24/6/18

Is it Monday yet?

posted on 24/6/18

Lamps bigging up RLC on his article for the BBC. Hope he have a blinder and keep Ali out of the team.

posted on 24/6/18

Sterling starts

posted on 24/6/18

https://dailym.ai/2K7EwB9

posted on 24/6/18

Don’t have a problem with that. I think Rashford is more effective as an impact sub anyhow.

posted on 24/6/18

Not sure if 3 5 2 suits Sterling though

Page 43220 of 61243

Sign in if you want to comment