I have never seen a game were one team suffered these many poor decisions from a referee. Newcastle are right to be upset. Both red cards were wrong. Shelvey tried a kick at Lansbury, who kicked Shelvey first, but he missed him. Lansbury held his face as if the kick hit his face. So the resulted penalty was wrong. The second red card and penalty incident was a complete joke. Lansbury lost control and fell down. Newcastle were wrongly denied a goal and penalty. Forest fist goal was a handball. I could go on and on.
Lansbury an ex Arsenal player was a disgrace for his antics. He kicked Shelvey first, who tried a kick back but missed Lansbury who then held his face as if he lost a leg. For the second penalty Lansbury lost control and dived. Lansbury and the referee should be suspended.
I'd love to see Jokic back, if Pinillos is going to be out for a while again, we should definitely try and sign him next month.
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
Good analysis Rev.
Even though Shelvey and Rafa left ages ago Liverpool are still the victims.
If I'd have been reffing even if he hadn't kicked out at Henri I'd have sent him off for being a kn0b, and a poor man's Robbie Savage
comment by LAMCAM. Henderson's tackle and side foot. (U18537)
posted 3 hours, 50 minutes ago
I have never seen a game were one team suffered these many poor decisions from a referee. Newcastle are right to be upset. Both red cards were wrong. Shelvey tried a kick at Lansbury, who kicked Shelvey first, but he missed him. Lansbury held his face as if the kick hit his face. So the resulted penalty was wrong. The second red card and penalty incident was a complete joke. Lansbury lost control and fell down. Newcastle were wrongly denied a goal and penalty. Forest fist goal was a handball. I could go on and on.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I've only seen the Sky replay, but I don't get the stuff about Lans holding his face. As Shelvey falls on top of him, Lansbury does appear to raise his foot, but after Shelvey lands he clearly swings a boot and catches Lansbury in the balls, which is what he looks to be clutching afterwards.
Sure, overreaction (and maybe provocation) from Lans, but a clear penalty and red card. After the number of times we've been penalised for far less (Vaughan's red against Brum last season for foot up!), it's a refreshing change to see refs giving decisions our way.
And second red, Dummet gets caught the wrong side and ploughs into the back of Lansbury, who's entitled to stop and get the ball under control. Two-handed push in the back is a clear penalty again. And sod the 'rules have changed' argument, Lam was sent off recently for losing possession 40 yards out and pulling the man back (who went down at least as easily and theatrically as Lans did).
This weekend has proven one thing, the Championship is anyone's guess. Reading got found out, so too did Brum, Derby are over Pearson, Norwich thrash Brentford... and Newcastle are the mardiest club in Britain.
A scouser on a Forest thread?!
We're going places....buckle up!!
comment by Morninchile (U18154)
posted 1 day, 10 hours ago
A scouser on a Forest thread?!
We're going places....buckle up!!
----------------------------------------------------------------------
😝
Newcastle have successfully appealed both red cards - I guarantee you now that if it was two Forest players, they'd have had their bans extended. %&*%
I don't see how the first red can be overturned when it was given by the linesman? who was level with the incident. The camera was following the ball so there isn't any footage of how it all kicked off, or is there?
After some of the pretty terrible decisions given against us and upheld by the FA I'm cheesed off by this.
Pretty dumb, but at least we got 3 points and the FA can't take those away. Or can they?
If that isn't biased, I don't know what is?! What does that say to the linesman who was brave enough to react to what he saw and grab the ref'a attention?
I get the feeling that the volume and veracity of the Geordie's moaning had a bearing on the FA's decision...
Sign in if you want to comment
Forest v Newcastle - Match Thread
Page 15 of 15
11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15
posted on 3/12/16
I have never seen a game were one team suffered these many poor decisions from a referee. Newcastle are right to be upset. Both red cards were wrong. Shelvey tried a kick at Lansbury, who kicked Shelvey first, but he missed him. Lansbury held his face as if the kick hit his face. So the resulted penalty was wrong. The second red card and penalty incident was a complete joke. Lansbury lost control and fell down. Newcastle were wrongly denied a goal and penalty. Forest fist goal was a handball. I could go on and on.
posted on 3/12/16
Lansbury an ex Arsenal player was a disgrace for his antics. He kicked Shelvey first, who tried a kick back but missed Lansbury who then held his face as if he lost a leg. For the second penalty Lansbury lost control and dived. Lansbury and the referee should be suspended.
posted on 3/12/16
I'd love to see Jokic back, if Pinillos is going to be out for a while again, we should definitely try and sign him next month.
posted on 3/12/16
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 3/12/16
Good analysis Rev.
Even though Shelvey and Rafa left ages ago Liverpool are still the victims.
If I'd have been reffing even if he hadn't kicked out at Henri I'd have sent him off for being a kn0b, and a poor man's Robbie Savage
posted on 3/12/16
comment by LAMCAM. Henderson's tackle and side foot. (U18537)
posted 3 hours, 50 minutes ago
I have never seen a game were one team suffered these many poor decisions from a referee. Newcastle are right to be upset. Both red cards were wrong. Shelvey tried a kick at Lansbury, who kicked Shelvey first, but he missed him. Lansbury held his face as if the kick hit his face. So the resulted penalty was wrong. The second red card and penalty incident was a complete joke. Lansbury lost control and fell down. Newcastle were wrongly denied a goal and penalty. Forest fist goal was a handball. I could go on and on.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I've only seen the Sky replay, but I don't get the stuff about Lans holding his face. As Shelvey falls on top of him, Lansbury does appear to raise his foot, but after Shelvey lands he clearly swings a boot and catches Lansbury in the balls, which is what he looks to be clutching afterwards.
Sure, overreaction (and maybe provocation) from Lans, but a clear penalty and red card. After the number of times we've been penalised for far less (Vaughan's red against Brum last season for foot up!), it's a refreshing change to see refs giving decisions our way.
And second red, Dummet gets caught the wrong side and ploughs into the back of Lansbury, who's entitled to stop and get the ball under control. Two-handed push in the back is a clear penalty again. And sod the 'rules have changed' argument, Lam was sent off recently for losing possession 40 yards out and pulling the man back (who went down at least as easily and theatrically as Lans did).
posted on 3/12/16
This weekend has proven one thing, the Championship is anyone's guess. Reading got found out, so too did Brum, Derby are over Pearson, Norwich thrash Brentford... and Newcastle are the mardiest club in Britain.
posted on 4/12/16
A scouser on a Forest thread?!
We're going places....buckle up!!
posted on 5/12/16
comment by Morninchile (U18154)
posted 1 day, 10 hours ago
A scouser on a Forest thread?!
We're going places....buckle up!!
----------------------------------------------------------------------
😝
posted on 6/12/16
Newcastle have successfully appealed both red cards - I guarantee you now that if it was two Forest players, they'd have had their bans extended. %&*%
posted on 6/12/16
I don't see how the first red can be overturned when it was given by the linesman? who was level with the incident. The camera was following the ball so there isn't any footage of how it all kicked off, or is there?
After some of the pretty terrible decisions given against us and upheld by the FA I'm cheesed off by this.
posted on 6/12/16
Pretty dumb, but at least we got 3 points and the FA can't take those away. Or can they?
posted on 7/12/16
If that isn't biased, I don't know what is?! What does that say to the linesman who was brave enough to react to what he saw and grab the ref'a attention?
posted on 7/12/16
I get the feeling that the volume and veracity of the Geordie's moaning had a bearing on the FA's decision...
Page 15 of 15
11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15