Below top 6 don't have good players
Pogba was the worst of Juventus midfielders
Pirlo was there to do the Domkey work
Stretty, you sir are a clown. A very funny one. Congratulations.
And now he is having a go at Beckhams ability and Giggs form in 99
Forget very funny Stretty, you are hilarious, or extremely stupid. Priceless
Below top 6 most of their players are chit.
Who was Pogba better than?
It's ok you didn't watch the juve team where pirlo actually put a shift in.
You're struggling here champ 😂😂😂😂😂😂
comment by Reddevilsdouble - confident of a top 4 finish (U12215)
posted 3 minutes ago
And now he is having a go at Beckhams ability and Giggs form in 99
Forget very funny Stretty, you are hilarious, or extremely stupid. Priceless
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Beckham was the least talented of the four hands down.
And Giggs did have worst form of the four (he was still very good) but struggled with injuries and the other 3 were better. That's a fact.
You're clearly an idiot, and did not watch us in 99 it's ok to say so.
Also learn how to interpret what is being said correctly rather than what you want to be said.
Also another sign of a grade A imbecile.
Stretty, you need to take your own advice mate.
You said below top 6 don't have good players. Now that has changed to most of their players are chit.
You said Pogba was the worst of the Juventus midfield and Beckham or Giggs were the worst of the 99 United midfield. This is like saying my Ferrari is my worst car.
And you said Prilo did the donkey work. This has now changed to he put a shift in.
As I said, you are hilarious or very stupid.
Stretty, you need to take your own advice mate.
You said below top 6 don't have good players. Now that has changed to most of their players are chit.
--------
Southahampton use to have le tissier he was good, most of there players were crap it's a generelaisation you moron. You literally named defour and bony in your list of good players. I cried laughing
You said Pogba was the worst of the Juventus midfield
-----
He was
and Beckham or Giggs were the worst of the 99 United midfield.
-----
They were. They were still very good and it was perhaps beckham best season but he was still the worst player based on ability of the four. It's nothing to be ashamed of.
This is like saying my Ferrari is my worst car.
-----
Yes it is. But you asked the question and I asked it. Who was I suppose to say was the worst in that scenario?
And you said Prilo did the donkey work then changed it to putting a shift in.
-----
Same thing. It's like saying carrick never does any defensive work. Pirlo did plenty. This allowed Pogba to be free. And he still wasn't that good when having virtually no defensive responsibility.
You clearly don't know what you're talking about.
Back to the op
The dab man dosent deserve to be in that list
That is unless Robb and Rdd get back from the future after their kiss at the enchantment under the sea dance bringing with them proof of pogbas legendary utd exploits
Stretty summing up Beckham -
"He could cross and pass and was ok at free kicks"
Priceless
So does carrick and did Scholes just do the donkey work for us ?
comment by Reddevilsdouble - confident of a top 4 finish (U12215)
posted 3 minutes ago
Stretty summing up Beckham -
"He could cross and pass and was ok at free kicks"
Priceless
----------------------------------------------------------------------
"
"He cannot kick with his left foot, he cannot head a ball, he cannot tackle and he doesn't score many goals. Apart from that he's all right."
George best on David beckham.
RDD. How many people have answered your original question with the same three players you have chosen. As I read it the vast majority went for Robbo, Keane and Scholes, even Robb your supporter didn't think Pogba belonged there yet.
Why do you think so many fans who have seen them both play arrived at that conclusion?
After all it's not that Scholes was a great from long ago like Duncan or George, he was recent and fresh in everybodies mind.
comment by BlaBla (U11635)
posted 1 hour ago
Back to the op
The dab man dosent deserve to be in that list
That is unless Robb and Rdd get back from the future after their kiss at the enchantment under the sea dance bringing with them proof of pogbas legendary utd exploits
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Nice Back to the Future reference
this whole "at age 23" thing....
at age 23 Robbo was still at West Brom and only just broken into the England team
at age 23 Keane had only played a season at United
If you want to throw the appearances, goals and trophies won etc in then would you argue that Pogba is better than both of them too?
If you did you either need slapped or saw neither of them play.
Pogba is still potential... until he fulfils it or otherwise its a daft/pointless argument... I hope he does, I think he will go on to be one of the best MF around... I'm still not sure he'll reach quite the other 3's level tho
I'll gladly adjust my view in 10 years time tho
52 - many will have picked that 3 because they think they have to picked the best 3 players rather than the best midfield unit (like you did)
Many will have done so because they think it's the right thing to do and can't go against the crowd
Some cannot leave out a legend
Some will have done so out of nostalgia, just like they would no doubt pick Best over Ronaldo or Charlton over Rooney.
Shugs - so despite what he has achieved at 23 you don't think Pogba can be considered the equal of a 23 year old Robson or Keane ?
What was it not their potential that saw us sign Robson and Keane?
Shugs - so despite what he has achieved at 23 you don't think Pogba can be considered the equal of a 23 year old Robson or Keane ?
What was it not their potential that saw us sign Robson and Keane?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
No i don't think so...
And with both when we signed them they were a lot closer to the finished article than Pogba currently is.
Keanes a different type of player, his drive and determination, ability to dominate a midfield
Robbo could do everything Pogba can (passing, shooting, driving from midfield) ... And better... And could match Keanes ability to mix it and lead
I hope Pogba develops into a leader, someone who can grab a game by the scruff... But he hasn't shown that yet...
I rate him, think he cops more flak than he should on here... Outrageous passing ability at times... But we're still talking potential... IMO the likes of Robbo and Keane were further on in their development as players, despite having less medals
And how exactly do you qualify that they were further along at 23?
Let's not forget, by 23 Pogba had been signed by United (twice) and Juventus, voted World Cup young player of the tournament, key in Juventus reaching a champs league final, runner up at the Euros as well as winning 3 titles and cups.
comment by Reddevilsdouble - confident of a top 4 finish (U12215)
posted 8 minutes ago
And how exactly do you qualify that they were further along at 23?
Let's not forget, by 23 Pogba had been signed by United (twice) and Juventus, voted World Cup young player of the tournament, key in Juventus reaching a champs league final, runner up at the Euros as well as winning 3 titles and cups.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I'm old enough to have watched them at that age... I doubt you are
I've already said... By 23 they were leaders, dominating games... Nobody was talking about "potential" really... Pogbas not there yet
He didn't play that well at the euros tbh, had a decent world cup but Messi was voted player of the tournament in Brazil and was poor for most of it... Not going to knock his juventus achievements
It seems you're in one of your arguing for the sake of it moods... Wont accept anything other than Pogbas the bestest haha
Not at all. Just interested in how you qualify your statement.
Neither were the finished article at 23 but both had huge potential, and it was no surprise they both went on to captain United.
Whist apogee may not captain United, he has that same potential those 2 did.
comment by Shugs (U14253)
posted 15 minutes ago
comment by Reddevilsdouble - confident of a top 4 finish (U12215)
posted 8 minutes ago
And how exactly do you qualify that they were further along at 23?
Let's not forget, by 23 Pogba had been signed by United (twice) and Juventus, voted World Cup young player of the tournament, key in Juventus reaching a champs league final, runner up at the Euros as well as winning 3 titles and cups.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I'm old enough to have watched them at that age... I doubt you are
I've already said... By 23 they were leaders, dominating games... Nobody was talking about "potential" really... Pogbas not there yet
He didn't play that well at the euros tbh, had a decent world cup but Messi was voted player of the tournament in Brazil and was poor for most of it... Not going to knock his juventus achievements
It seems you're in one of your arguing for the sake of it moods... Wont accept anything other than Pogbas the bestest haha
----------------------------------------------------------------------
BS. Complete BS. At 23 none of them were better than Pogba is currently. Pogba is already a world class player. They weren't when they were his age.
comment by Cesc + Costa - The Spanish Duo (U21341)
posted 4 minutes ago
comment by Shugs (U14253)
posted 15 minutes ago
comment by Reddevilsdouble - confident of a top 4 finish (U12215)
posted 8 minutes ago
And how exactly do you qualify that they were further along at 23?
Let's not forget, by 23 Pogba had been signed by United (twice) and Juventus, voted World Cup young player of the tournament, key in Juventus reaching a champs league final, runner up at the Euros as well as winning 3 titles and cups.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I'm old enough to have watched them at that age... I doubt you are
I've already said... By 23 they were leaders, dominating games... Nobody was talking about "potential" really... Pogbas not there yet
He didn't play that well at the euros tbh, had a decent world cup but Messi was voted player of the tournament in Brazil and was poor for most of it... Not going to knock his juventus achievements
It seems you're in one of your arguing for the sake of it moods... Wont accept anything other than Pogbas the bestest haha
----------------------------------------------------------------------
BS. Complete BS. At 23 none of them were better than Pogba is currently. Pogba is already a world class player. They weren't when they were his age.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Pogba is by no stretch a world class players.
World class players do it week in week out.
comment by Cesc + Costa - The Spanish Duo (U21341)
posted 7 minutes ago
comment by Shugs (U14253)
posted 15 minutes ago
comment by Reddevilsdouble - confident of a top 4 finish (U12215)
posted 8 minutes ago
And how exactly do you qualify that they were further along at 23?
Let's not forget, by 23 Pogba had been signed by United (twice) and Juventus, voted World Cup young player of the tournament, key in Juventus reaching a champs league final, runner up at the Euros as well as winning 3 titles and cups.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I'm old enough to have watched them at that age... I doubt you are
I've already said... By 23 they were leaders, dominating games... Nobody was talking about "potential" really... Pogbas not there yet
He didn't play that well at the euros tbh, had a decent world cup but Messi was voted player of the tournament in Brazil and was poor for most of it... Not going to knock his juventus achievements
It seems you're in one of your arguing for the sake of it moods... Wont accept anything other than Pogbas the bestest haha
----------------------------------------------------------------------
BS. Complete BS. At 23 none of them were better than Pogba is currently. Pogba is already a world class player. They weren't when they were his age.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Wahl? I'd say sober up.... But you're only a wum anyway
Pogba was doing it week in week out at Juventus.
Serie A is not the premier league and thus far has not shown any sort of consistency.
Maybe it has to do with the fact his teammates are the likes of Fellaini and lingard...
Yeah carrick, ibra, martial, Herrera, milki and mata are dreadful players to play with.
Stupid comment.
Sign in if you want to comment
If you had to
Page 6 of 9
6 | 7 | 8 | 9
posted on 22/1/17
Below top 6 don't have good players
Pogba was the worst of Juventus midfielders
Pirlo was there to do the Domkey work
Stretty, you sir are a clown. A very funny one. Congratulations.
posted on 22/1/17
And now he is having a go at Beckhams ability and Giggs form in 99
Forget very funny Stretty, you are hilarious, or extremely stupid. Priceless
posted on 22/1/17
Below top 6 most of their players are chit.
Who was Pogba better than?
It's ok you didn't watch the juve team where pirlo actually put a shift in.
You're struggling here champ 😂😂😂😂😂😂
posted on 22/1/17
comment by Reddevilsdouble - confident of a top 4 finish (U12215)
posted 3 minutes ago
And now he is having a go at Beckhams ability and Giggs form in 99
Forget very funny Stretty, you are hilarious, or extremely stupid. Priceless
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Beckham was the least talented of the four hands down.
And Giggs did have worst form of the four (he was still very good) but struggled with injuries and the other 3 were better. That's a fact.
You're clearly an idiot, and did not watch us in 99 it's ok to say so.
Also learn how to interpret what is being said correctly rather than what you want to be said.
Also another sign of a grade A imbecile.
posted on 22/1/17
Stretty, you need to take your own advice mate.
You said below top 6 don't have good players. Now that has changed to most of their players are chit.
You said Pogba was the worst of the Juventus midfield and Beckham or Giggs were the worst of the 99 United midfield. This is like saying my Ferrari is my worst car.
And you said Prilo did the donkey work. This has now changed to he put a shift in.
As I said, you are hilarious or very stupid.
posted on 22/1/17
Stretty, you need to take your own advice mate.
You said below top 6 don't have good players. Now that has changed to most of their players are chit.
--------
Southahampton use to have le tissier he was good, most of there players were crap it's a generelaisation you moron. You literally named defour and bony in your list of good players. I cried laughing
You said Pogba was the worst of the Juventus midfield
-----
He was
and Beckham or Giggs were the worst of the 99 United midfield.
-----
They were. They were still very good and it was perhaps beckham best season but he was still the worst player based on ability of the four. It's nothing to be ashamed of.
This is like saying my Ferrari is my worst car.
-----
Yes it is. But you asked the question and I asked it. Who was I suppose to say was the worst in that scenario?
And you said Prilo did the donkey work then changed it to putting a shift in.
-----
Same thing. It's like saying carrick never does any defensive work. Pirlo did plenty. This allowed Pogba to be free. And he still wasn't that good when having virtually no defensive responsibility.
You clearly don't know what you're talking about.
posted on 22/1/17
Back to the op
The dab man dosent deserve to be in that list
That is unless Robb and Rdd get back from the future after their kiss at the enchantment under the sea dance bringing with them proof of pogbas legendary utd exploits
posted on 22/1/17
Stretty summing up Beckham -
"He could cross and pass and was ok at free kicks"
Priceless
posted on 22/1/17
So does carrick and did Scholes just do the donkey work for us ?
posted on 22/1/17
comment by Reddevilsdouble - confident of a top 4 finish (U12215)
posted 3 minutes ago
Stretty summing up Beckham -
"He could cross and pass and was ok at free kicks"
Priceless
----------------------------------------------------------------------
"
"He cannot kick with his left foot, he cannot head a ball, he cannot tackle and he doesn't score many goals. Apart from that he's all right."
George best on David beckham.
posted on 22/1/17
RDD. How many people have answered your original question with the same three players you have chosen. As I read it the vast majority went for Robbo, Keane and Scholes, even Robb your supporter didn't think Pogba belonged there yet.
Why do you think so many fans who have seen them both play arrived at that conclusion?
After all it's not that Scholes was a great from long ago like Duncan or George, he was recent and fresh in everybodies mind.
posted on 22/1/17
comment by BlaBla (U11635)
posted 1 hour ago
Back to the op
The dab man dosent deserve to be in that list
That is unless Robb and Rdd get back from the future after their kiss at the enchantment under the sea dance bringing with them proof of pogbas legendary utd exploits
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Nice Back to the Future reference
posted on 22/1/17
this whole "at age 23" thing....
at age 23 Robbo was still at West Brom and only just broken into the England team
at age 23 Keane had only played a season at United
If you want to throw the appearances, goals and trophies won etc in then would you argue that Pogba is better than both of them too?
If you did you either need slapped or saw neither of them play.
Pogba is still potential... until he fulfils it or otherwise its a daft/pointless argument... I hope he does, I think he will go on to be one of the best MF around... I'm still not sure he'll reach quite the other 3's level tho
I'll gladly adjust my view in 10 years time tho
posted on 22/1/17
52 - many will have picked that 3 because they think they have to picked the best 3 players rather than the best midfield unit (like you did)
Many will have done so because they think it's the right thing to do and can't go against the crowd
Some cannot leave out a legend
Some will have done so out of nostalgia, just like they would no doubt pick Best over Ronaldo or Charlton over Rooney.
Shugs - so despite what he has achieved at 23 you don't think Pogba can be considered the equal of a 23 year old Robson or Keane ?
What was it not their potential that saw us sign Robson and Keane?
posted on 22/1/17
Shugs - so despite what he has achieved at 23 you don't think Pogba can be considered the equal of a 23 year old Robson or Keane ?
What was it not their potential that saw us sign Robson and Keane?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
No i don't think so...
And with both when we signed them they were a lot closer to the finished article than Pogba currently is.
Keanes a different type of player, his drive and determination, ability to dominate a midfield
Robbo could do everything Pogba can (passing, shooting, driving from midfield) ... And better... And could match Keanes ability to mix it and lead
I hope Pogba develops into a leader, someone who can grab a game by the scruff... But he hasn't shown that yet...
I rate him, think he cops more flak than he should on here... Outrageous passing ability at times... But we're still talking potential... IMO the likes of Robbo and Keane were further on in their development as players, despite having less medals
posted on 22/1/17
And how exactly do you qualify that they were further along at 23?
Let's not forget, by 23 Pogba had been signed by United (twice) and Juventus, voted World Cup young player of the tournament, key in Juventus reaching a champs league final, runner up at the Euros as well as winning 3 titles and cups.
posted on 22/1/17
comment by Reddevilsdouble - confident of a top 4 finish (U12215)
posted 8 minutes ago
And how exactly do you qualify that they were further along at 23?
Let's not forget, by 23 Pogba had been signed by United (twice) and Juventus, voted World Cup young player of the tournament, key in Juventus reaching a champs league final, runner up at the Euros as well as winning 3 titles and cups.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I'm old enough to have watched them at that age... I doubt you are
I've already said... By 23 they were leaders, dominating games... Nobody was talking about "potential" really... Pogbas not there yet
He didn't play that well at the euros tbh, had a decent world cup but Messi was voted player of the tournament in Brazil and was poor for most of it... Not going to knock his juventus achievements
It seems you're in one of your arguing for the sake of it moods... Wont accept anything other than Pogbas the bestest haha
posted on 22/1/17
Not at all. Just interested in how you qualify your statement.
Neither were the finished article at 23 but both had huge potential, and it was no surprise they both went on to captain United.
Whist apogee may not captain United, he has that same potential those 2 did.
posted on 22/1/17
comment by Shugs (U14253)
posted 15 minutes ago
comment by Reddevilsdouble - confident of a top 4 finish (U12215)
posted 8 minutes ago
And how exactly do you qualify that they were further along at 23?
Let's not forget, by 23 Pogba had been signed by United (twice) and Juventus, voted World Cup young player of the tournament, key in Juventus reaching a champs league final, runner up at the Euros as well as winning 3 titles and cups.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I'm old enough to have watched them at that age... I doubt you are
I've already said... By 23 they were leaders, dominating games... Nobody was talking about "potential" really... Pogbas not there yet
He didn't play that well at the euros tbh, had a decent world cup but Messi was voted player of the tournament in Brazil and was poor for most of it... Not going to knock his juventus achievements
It seems you're in one of your arguing for the sake of it moods... Wont accept anything other than Pogbas the bestest haha
----------------------------------------------------------------------
BS. Complete BS. At 23 none of them were better than Pogba is currently. Pogba is already a world class player. They weren't when they were his age.
posted on 22/1/17
comment by Cesc + Costa - The Spanish Duo (U21341)
posted 4 minutes ago
comment by Shugs (U14253)
posted 15 minutes ago
comment by Reddevilsdouble - confident of a top 4 finish (U12215)
posted 8 minutes ago
And how exactly do you qualify that they were further along at 23?
Let's not forget, by 23 Pogba had been signed by United (twice) and Juventus, voted World Cup young player of the tournament, key in Juventus reaching a champs league final, runner up at the Euros as well as winning 3 titles and cups.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I'm old enough to have watched them at that age... I doubt you are
I've already said... By 23 they were leaders, dominating games... Nobody was talking about "potential" really... Pogbas not there yet
He didn't play that well at the euros tbh, had a decent world cup but Messi was voted player of the tournament in Brazil and was poor for most of it... Not going to knock his juventus achievements
It seems you're in one of your arguing for the sake of it moods... Wont accept anything other than Pogbas the bestest haha
----------------------------------------------------------------------
BS. Complete BS. At 23 none of them were better than Pogba is currently. Pogba is already a world class player. They weren't when they were his age.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Pogba is by no stretch a world class players.
World class players do it week in week out.
posted on 22/1/17
comment by Cesc + Costa - The Spanish Duo (U21341)
posted 7 minutes ago
comment by Shugs (U14253)
posted 15 minutes ago
comment by Reddevilsdouble - confident of a top 4 finish (U12215)
posted 8 minutes ago
And how exactly do you qualify that they were further along at 23?
Let's not forget, by 23 Pogba had been signed by United (twice) and Juventus, voted World Cup young player of the tournament, key in Juventus reaching a champs league final, runner up at the Euros as well as winning 3 titles and cups.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I'm old enough to have watched them at that age... I doubt you are
I've already said... By 23 they were leaders, dominating games... Nobody was talking about "potential" really... Pogbas not there yet
He didn't play that well at the euros tbh, had a decent world cup but Messi was voted player of the tournament in Brazil and was poor for most of it... Not going to knock his juventus achievements
It seems you're in one of your arguing for the sake of it moods... Wont accept anything other than Pogbas the bestest haha
----------------------------------------------------------------------
BS. Complete BS. At 23 none of them were better than Pogba is currently. Pogba is already a world class player. They weren't when they were his age.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Wahl? I'd say sober up.... But you're only a wum anyway
posted on 22/1/17
Pogba was doing it week in week out at Juventus.
posted on 22/1/17
Serie A is not the premier league and thus far has not shown any sort of consistency.
posted on 22/1/17
Maybe it has to do with the fact his teammates are the likes of Fellaini and lingard...
posted on 22/1/17
Yeah carrick, ibra, martial, Herrera, milki and mata are dreadful players to play with.
Stupid comment.
Page 6 of 9
6 | 7 | 8 | 9