Comment deleted by Site Moderator
He's been good a lot more than 5 times. These non United fans who don't watch us week in week out do make silly assumptions
It's a bit stupid only having 'hit' and 'miss' options. Too black and white to show any real insight.
If anyone can argue that Pogba has been a hit, then I am afraid you know sweet all about football. Zlatan has been a hit. Now you compare that to Pogba.
comment by scholayScholes (U13961)
posted 22 seconds ago
If anyone can argue that Pogba has been a hit, then I am afraid you know sweet all about football. Zlatan has been a hit. Now you compare that to Pogba.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Has Pogba made us a better team? Personally I think he has. He has his flaws but he offers a spark in midfield that we haven't really had since Scholes left (not comparing the two by the way) and the one season Anderson was good.
I respect the opinion of people who think he's a miss but to say a player who's played 4 times and hasn't exactly come cheap either is a hit is ridiculous.
Jesus did more in his few games than Pogba has
comment by kneerash-23 Cara Gold (U6876)
posted 1 minute ago
Jesus did more in his few games than Pogba has
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
comment by Tip Me Into A Skip (U3245)
posted 2 minutes ago
Pogba has 4 goals and 3 assists in 28 starts
Jesus has 3 goals and 1 assist in 3 starts
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I forgot goalscoring is both their main jobs
comment by The Process (U20671)
posted 7 minutes ago
comment by scholayScholes (U13961)
posted 22 seconds ago
If anyone can argue that Pogba has been a hit, then I am afraid you know sweet all about football. Zlatan has been a hit. Now you compare that to Pogba.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Has Pogba made us a better team? Personally I think he has. He has his flaws but he offers a spark in midfield that we haven't really had since Scholes left (not comparing the two by the way) and the one season Anderson was good.
I respect the opinion of people who think he's a miss but to say a player who's played 4 times and hasn't exactly come cheap either is a hit is ridiculous.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Yes he has contributed to this team improving. On the whole, he has been disappointing this season. I cannot remember one big game wherein I felt Pogba bossed the game. You can say whatever you want about ignoring the price, he has been bullied and outplayed in most of our big games.
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
comment by scholayScholes (U13961)
posted 2 minutes ago
comment by The Process (U20671)
posted 7 minutes ago
comment by scholayScholes (U13961)
posted 22 seconds ago
If anyone can argue that Pogba has been a hit, then I am afraid you know sweet all about football. Zlatan has been a hit. Now you compare that to Pogba.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Has Pogba made us a better team? Personally I think he has. He has his flaws but he offers a spark in midfield that we haven't really had since Scholes left (not comparing the two by the way) and the one season Anderson was good.
I respect the opinion of people who think he's a miss but to say a player who's played 4 times and hasn't exactly come cheap either is a hit is ridiculous.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Yes he has contributed to this team improving. On the whole, he has been disappointing this season. I cannot remember one big game wherein I felt Pogba bossed the game. You can say whatever you want about ignoring the price, he has been bullied and outplayed in most of our big games.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Yes I agree he has been underwhelming at times but he has been very good a nice number of times too. Needs to improve in big away games though
comment by Tip Me Into A Skip (U3245)
posted 33 minutes ago
Pogba cost £89m and has been decent like 5 times
of course he is a miss
.........................
Hard to argue with that really.
Has Pogba made us a better team?
....................
Not by much. And you can't say it is down to Pogba.
Bailly, Zlatan and Herrera have all been superior and contributed more.
Pogba hasn't made you any better really, you're basically the same side as last season with the odd bit more flair but very little difference.
League postion, goals scored, and overall style of play are all very similar.
His criteria isn't consistent at all.
But even a fullseason at a club is not really a good time to judge as all of us have seen players come to our clubs and not be good in their first year and then go on to be very good.
Even more so for players who come from another league.
Except Pogba, he's a flop cause bantz
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
comment by meltonblue (U10617)
posted 3 minutes ago
His criteria isn't consistent at all.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Yep....
Mkhi gets in for showing enough to progress next season... But that luxury isn't afforded to Pogba, even though he has had more good games than Mkhi.
If we have to use the hit/miss system... both are a miss based on this season and both have potential to be a hit, next season.
comment by kneerash-23 Cara Gold (U6876)
posted 10 minutes ago
Pogba hasn't made you any better really, you're basically the same side as last season with the odd bit more flair but very little difference.
League postion, goals scored, and overall style of play are all very similar.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
You obviously don't watch United much if you believe that.
comment by kneerash-23 Cara Gold (U6876)
posted 42 minutes ago
Jesus did more in his few games than Pogba has
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I watch plenty of united and I do believe it, while I've exaggerated the level of difference you are doin gth exact same thing, you make it out like united are a totallydifferent team with Pogba, (your over exxageration) while I say you're basically the same team.
Reality is yes you play better football but not really any staggering difference, and this isn't just my opinion I know a load of united fans who feel the same, yes some better games, more chances created but many fans I know still feel you are slow in posession, play it back and sideways more than you need to and crucially (and I've seen this happen numerous times) you don't break quickly and when the bal lgoes wide it stops allowing the opposition to get back into position, this was also the same under LVG.
So a happy medium between us is where united really are.
Like if you were so much better you wouldn't be 5th
comment by rossobianchi #EquipaLulaDaAlegria (U17054)
posted 4 minutes ago
comment by kneerash-23 Cara Gold (U6876)
posted 42 minutes ago
Jesus did more in his few games than Pogba has
----------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------
He had a huge impact in them games though, I would argue he did more to improve the City side than Pogba has united, happy to hear a counter argument.
Pogba hasn't been a hit or a miss. Why is it all of a sudden CMs need to bang in over 20 goals a season to be a hit?
comment by kneerash-23 Cara Gold (U6876)
posted 6 minutes ago
comment by rossobianchi #EquipaLulaDaAlegria (U17054)
posted 4 minutes ago
comment by kneerash-23 Cara Gold (U6876)
posted 42 minutes ago
Jesus did more in his few games than Pogba has
----------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------
He had a huge impact in them games though, I would argue he did more to improve the City side than Pogba has united, happy to hear a counter argument.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
He's scored a few tap ins. Yes they all count but you see this with a lot of young players initially when they break into the team. Look at Rashford who 4 in his first 2 and has scored 14 in 50 plus games since.
Jesus's all round game wasn't that impressive when I saw him. He may develop into a great player but City are by no means better off with him over Aguero at this moment in time.
Sign in if you want to comment
City/United signings rated
Page 1 of 3
posted on 26/4/17
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 26/4/17
He's been good a lot more than 5 times. These non United fans who don't watch us week in week out do make silly assumptions
posted on 26/4/17
It's a bit stupid only having 'hit' and 'miss' options. Too black and white to show any real insight.
posted on 26/4/17
If anyone can argue that Pogba has been a hit, then I am afraid you know sweet all about football. Zlatan has been a hit. Now you compare that to Pogba.
posted on 26/4/17
comment by scholayScholes (U13961)
posted 22 seconds ago
If anyone can argue that Pogba has been a hit, then I am afraid you know sweet all about football. Zlatan has been a hit. Now you compare that to Pogba.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Has Pogba made us a better team? Personally I think he has. He has his flaws but he offers a spark in midfield that we haven't really had since Scholes left (not comparing the two by the way) and the one season Anderson was good.
I respect the opinion of people who think he's a miss but to say a player who's played 4 times and hasn't exactly come cheap either is a hit is ridiculous.
posted on 26/4/17
Jesus did more in his few games than Pogba has
posted on 26/4/17
comment by kneerash-23 Cara Gold (U6876)
posted 1 minute ago
Jesus did more in his few games than Pogba has
----------------------------------------------------------------------
posted on 26/4/17
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 26/4/17
comment by Tip Me Into A Skip (U3245)
posted 2 minutes ago
Pogba has 4 goals and 3 assists in 28 starts
Jesus has 3 goals and 1 assist in 3 starts
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I forgot goalscoring is both their main jobs
posted on 26/4/17
comment by The Process (U20671)
posted 7 minutes ago
comment by scholayScholes (U13961)
posted 22 seconds ago
If anyone can argue that Pogba has been a hit, then I am afraid you know sweet all about football. Zlatan has been a hit. Now you compare that to Pogba.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Has Pogba made us a better team? Personally I think he has. He has his flaws but he offers a spark in midfield that we haven't really had since Scholes left (not comparing the two by the way) and the one season Anderson was good.
I respect the opinion of people who think he's a miss but to say a player who's played 4 times and hasn't exactly come cheap either is a hit is ridiculous.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Yes he has contributed to this team improving. On the whole, he has been disappointing this season. I cannot remember one big game wherein I felt Pogba bossed the game. You can say whatever you want about ignoring the price, he has been bullied and outplayed in most of our big games.
posted on 26/4/17
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 26/4/17
comment by scholayScholes (U13961)
posted 2 minutes ago
comment by The Process (U20671)
posted 7 minutes ago
comment by scholayScholes (U13961)
posted 22 seconds ago
If anyone can argue that Pogba has been a hit, then I am afraid you know sweet all about football. Zlatan has been a hit. Now you compare that to Pogba.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Has Pogba made us a better team? Personally I think he has. He has his flaws but he offers a spark in midfield that we haven't really had since Scholes left (not comparing the two by the way) and the one season Anderson was good.
I respect the opinion of people who think he's a miss but to say a player who's played 4 times and hasn't exactly come cheap either is a hit is ridiculous.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Yes he has contributed to this team improving. On the whole, he has been disappointing this season. I cannot remember one big game wherein I felt Pogba bossed the game. You can say whatever you want about ignoring the price, he has been bullied and outplayed in most of our big games.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Yes I agree he has been underwhelming at times but he has been very good a nice number of times too. Needs to improve in big away games though
posted on 26/4/17
comment by Tip Me Into A Skip (U3245)
posted 33 minutes ago
Pogba cost £89m and has been decent like 5 times
of course he is a miss
.........................
Hard to argue with that really.
posted on 26/4/17
Has Pogba made us a better team?
....................
Not by much. And you can't say it is down to Pogba.
Bailly, Zlatan and Herrera have all been superior and contributed more.
posted on 26/4/17
Pogba hasn't made you any better really, you're basically the same side as last season with the odd bit more flair but very little difference.
League postion, goals scored, and overall style of play are all very similar.
posted on 26/4/17
His criteria isn't consistent at all.
posted on 26/4/17
But even a fullseason at a club is not really a good time to judge as all of us have seen players come to our clubs and not be good in their first year and then go on to be very good.
Even more so for players who come from another league.
Except Pogba, he's a flop cause bantz
posted on 26/4/17
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 26/4/17
comment by meltonblue (U10617)
posted 3 minutes ago
His criteria isn't consistent at all.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Yep....
Mkhi gets in for showing enough to progress next season... But that luxury isn't afforded to Pogba, even though he has had more good games than Mkhi.
If we have to use the hit/miss system... both are a miss based on this season and both have potential to be a hit, next season.
posted on 26/4/17
comment by kneerash-23 Cara Gold (U6876)
posted 10 minutes ago
Pogba hasn't made you any better really, you're basically the same side as last season with the odd bit more flair but very little difference.
League postion, goals scored, and overall style of play are all very similar.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
You obviously don't watch United much if you believe that.
posted on 26/4/17
comment by kneerash-23 Cara Gold (U6876)
posted 42 minutes ago
Jesus did more in his few games than Pogba has
----------------------------------------------------------------------
posted on 26/4/17
I watch plenty of united and I do believe it, while I've exaggerated the level of difference you are doin gth exact same thing, you make it out like united are a totallydifferent team with Pogba, (your over exxageration) while I say you're basically the same team.
Reality is yes you play better football but not really any staggering difference, and this isn't just my opinion I know a load of united fans who feel the same, yes some better games, more chances created but many fans I know still feel you are slow in posession, play it back and sideways more than you need to and crucially (and I've seen this happen numerous times) you don't break quickly and when the bal lgoes wide it stops allowing the opposition to get back into position, this was also the same under LVG.
So a happy medium between us is where united really are.
Like if you were so much better you wouldn't be 5th
posted on 26/4/17
comment by rossobianchi #EquipaLulaDaAlegria (U17054)
posted 4 minutes ago
comment by kneerash-23 Cara Gold (U6876)
posted 42 minutes ago
Jesus did more in his few games than Pogba has
----------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------
He had a huge impact in them games though, I would argue he did more to improve the City side than Pogba has united, happy to hear a counter argument.
posted on 26/4/17
Pogba hasn't been a hit or a miss. Why is it all of a sudden CMs need to bang in over 20 goals a season to be a hit?
posted on 26/4/17
comment by kneerash-23 Cara Gold (U6876)
posted 6 minutes ago
comment by rossobianchi #EquipaLulaDaAlegria (U17054)
posted 4 minutes ago
comment by kneerash-23 Cara Gold (U6876)
posted 42 minutes ago
Jesus did more in his few games than Pogba has
----------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------
He had a huge impact in them games though, I would argue he did more to improve the City side than Pogba has united, happy to hear a counter argument.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
He's scored a few tap ins. Yes they all count but you see this with a lot of young players initially when they break into the team. Look at Rashford who 4 in his first 2 and has scored 14 in 50 plus games since.
Jesus's all round game wasn't that impressive when I saw him. He may develop into a great player but City are by no means better off with him over Aguero at this moment in time.
Page 1 of 3