Robbo is a good player but he's no Kieran Tierney
KT is not for sale, though so all is good
comment by Stevethebhoy (U17159)
posted 1 minute ago
Robbo is a good player but he's no Kieran Tierney
KT is not for sale, though so all is good
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Seen a bit of kt, and he looks a prospect indeed. Suspect you won't be holding onto him for too long...
He could go either way. It depends on how Liverpool develop him and game time. I don't think he's a bad signing, especially at the price in this market.
He'll be better than Moreno who is a massive disappointment. I thought he'd be better at Shaw but he's useless in England. Better to ship him back to Spain. The English game isn't for him.
The most surprising thing is how well Milner has done at LB. Never rated him as a CM or on the wings but he's impressed me there.
comment by KLS (U1695)
posted 15 hours, 32 minutes ago
comment by Eric_the_king (SE85) (U21241)
posted 3 minutes ago
He'd be a very typical Liverpool signing. Decent enough player but not shopping at the top table there are you?
Surely you should be competing for better players than that.
---------------------------
Same could be said for lindelof!
Is he better than the leftbacks we have at the minute?
Yes!
Will we lose money on him at £8m?
No!
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Lindelof is a starter for Sweden and just won a few titles with Benfica's and played in Europe. So no its nothing like it actually. Hahaha.
Not sure how good he is but I'd rather we were spending £8m on a full back than £50m.
I don't think full backs have ever made or broken a team.
The full backs are never the most important players. They are support roles and you want solid professionals who are consistent. A Danny Alves/Marcelo would be nice but there's not many of them about.
Hopefully Robertson will be more Bjornebye than Moreno.
comment by Eric_the_king (SE85) (U21241)
posted 20 minutes ago
comment by KLS (U1695)
posted 15 hours, 32 minutes ago
comment by Eric_the_king (SE85) (U21241)
posted 3 minutes ago
He'd be a very typical Liverpool signing. Decent enough player but not shopping at the top table there are you?
Surely you should be competing for better players than that.
---------------------------
Same could be said for lindelof!
Is he better than the leftbacks we have at the minute?
Yes!
Will we lose money on him at £8m?
No!
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Lindelof is a starter for Sweden and just won a few titles with Benfica's and played in Europe. So no its nothing like it actually. Hahaha.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
* awaiting joke of a league argument.
Having read some of the posts above, let's see if I've got this right, especially from our friends from other clubs.
The more you spend on a player, the better he will be. Conversely, the less you spend, the poorer they are.
Right, got it.
Pogba.
JimmyTheRed
No, you haven't got it right at all
Put money aside
Robertson is an average player
Pogba is a very good player
Analog watched Hull every week.
Oh. What's his FIFA rating?
No idea
I must be unaware of this new idea that you have to watch a player play every single week in order to form an opinion
I take it you have no opinion of any non Liverpool player?
comment by Analog (U17200)
posted 15 minutes ago
No, you haven't got it right at all
Put money aside
Robertson is an average player
Pogba is a very good player
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Pogba also went for 10 times the price.
Robertson is no worse than any lb currently playing in the prem.
10x the price because he's 10x the player
And no, Robertson is not the joint best LB in the PL ffs
Come on Robbing, you didn't tell me that the FIFA rating is supposed to kick in on how much we should spend on a player!
Right, that puts a whole different shine on the gig, doesn't it.
Robertson must be rubbish then, not even worth the £8M we are supposed to be spending on him.
Still Pogba
JimmyTheRed
comment by Analog (U17200)
posted 3 minutes ago
10x the price because he's 10x the player
And no, Robertson is not the joint best LB in the PL ffs
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Well who's a better lb? Shaw, better defensively, not as good as Robertson going forward., Bertrand? No better really.,
Rose is miles better, end of debate
comment by Analog (U17200)
posted 13 seconds ago
Rose is miles better, end of debate
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Going forward definately, not so hot defensivley.
comment by Eric_the_king (SE85) (U21241)
posted 5 hours, 7 minutes ago
comment by KLS (U1695)
posted 15 hours, 32 minutes ago
comment by Eric_the_king (SE85) (U21241)
posted 3 minutes ago
He'd be a very typical Liverpool signing. Decent enough player but not shopping at the top table there are you?
Surely you should be competing for better players than that.
---------------------------
Same could be said for lindelof!
Is he better than the leftbacks we have at the minute?
Yes!
Will we lose money on him at £8m?
No!
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Lindelof is a starter for Sweden and just won a few titles with Benfica's and played in Europe. So no its nothing like it actually. Hahaha.
---------------------------
Sweden are world beaters are they?
Won stuff with Benfica, so did Lazar Markovic!
No Robertson is not better than Rose defensively. Just cos he's linked with you doesn't mean you need to make stuff up
comment by Analog (U17200)
posted 17 seconds ago
No Robertson is not better than Rose defensively. Just cos he's linked with you doesn't mean you need to make stuff up
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I'm a Utd fan, so I don't care. But he is better than rose as a defender. Think he's a pretty decent left back.
comment by Analog (U17200)
posted 1 minute ago
No Robertson is not better than Rose defensively. Just cos he's linked with you doesn't mean you need to make stuff up
-----------
He's a Utd fan you nob!
Makes your opinion even worse. Walker absolutely bullied him in our 5-0 win over them last season. Thinking Rose is a worse defender is a boring stereotype
comment by Analog (U17200)
posted 28 seconds ago
Makes your opinion even worse. Walker absolutely bullied him in our 5-0 win over them last season. Thinking Rose is a worse defender is a boring stereotype
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I like rose, great attacker. But he's not a good defender.
comment by Analog (U17200)
posted 40 seconds ago
Makes your opinion even worse. Walker absolutely bullied him in our 5-0 win over them last season. Thinking Rose is a worse defender is a boring stereotype
------------------------
And Mane bossed you're entire defence at Anfield but let's judge players on one game!
Sign in if you want to comment
Robertson, any good?
Page 2 of 8
6 | 7 | 8
posted on 15/7/17
Robbo is a good player but he's no Kieran Tierney
KT is not for sale, though so all is good
posted on 15/7/17
comment by Stevethebhoy (U17159)
posted 1 minute ago
Robbo is a good player but he's no Kieran Tierney
KT is not for sale, though so all is good
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Seen a bit of kt, and he looks a prospect indeed. Suspect you won't be holding onto him for too long...
posted on 16/7/17
He could go either way. It depends on how Liverpool develop him and game time. I don't think he's a bad signing, especially at the price in this market.
He'll be better than Moreno who is a massive disappointment. I thought he'd be better at Shaw but he's useless in England. Better to ship him back to Spain. The English game isn't for him.
The most surprising thing is how well Milner has done at LB. Never rated him as a CM or on the wings but he's impressed me there.
posted on 16/7/17
comment by KLS (U1695)
posted 15 hours, 32 minutes ago
comment by Eric_the_king (SE85) (U21241)
posted 3 minutes ago
He'd be a very typical Liverpool signing. Decent enough player but not shopping at the top table there are you?
Surely you should be competing for better players than that.
---------------------------
Same could be said for lindelof!
Is he better than the leftbacks we have at the minute?
Yes!
Will we lose money on him at £8m?
No!
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Lindelof is a starter for Sweden and just won a few titles with Benfica's and played in Europe. So no its nothing like it actually. Hahaha.
posted on 16/7/17
Not sure how good he is but I'd rather we were spending £8m on a full back than £50m.
I don't think full backs have ever made or broken a team.
The full backs are never the most important players. They are support roles and you want solid professionals who are consistent. A Danny Alves/Marcelo would be nice but there's not many of them about.
Hopefully Robertson will be more Bjornebye than Moreno.
posted on 16/7/17
comment by Eric_the_king (SE85) (U21241)
posted 20 minutes ago
comment by KLS (U1695)
posted 15 hours, 32 minutes ago
comment by Eric_the_king (SE85) (U21241)
posted 3 minutes ago
He'd be a very typical Liverpool signing. Decent enough player but not shopping at the top table there are you?
Surely you should be competing for better players than that.
---------------------------
Same could be said for lindelof!
Is he better than the leftbacks we have at the minute?
Yes!
Will we lose money on him at £8m?
No!
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Lindelof is a starter for Sweden and just won a few titles with Benfica's and played in Europe. So no its nothing like it actually. Hahaha.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
* awaiting joke of a league argument.
posted on 16/7/17
Having read some of the posts above, let's see if I've got this right, especially from our friends from other clubs.
The more you spend on a player, the better he will be. Conversely, the less you spend, the poorer they are.
Right, got it.
Pogba.
JimmyTheRed
posted on 16/7/17
No, you haven't got it right at all
Put money aside
Robertson is an average player
Pogba is a very good player
posted on 16/7/17
Analog watched Hull every week.
posted on 16/7/17
Don't think I did
posted on 16/7/17
Oh. What's his FIFA rating?
posted on 16/7/17
No idea
I must be unaware of this new idea that you have to watch a player play every single week in order to form an opinion
I take it you have no opinion of any non Liverpool player?
posted on 16/7/17
comment by Analog (U17200)
posted 15 minutes ago
No, you haven't got it right at all
Put money aside
Robertson is an average player
Pogba is a very good player
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Pogba also went for 10 times the price.
Robertson is no worse than any lb currently playing in the prem.
posted on 16/7/17
10x the price because he's 10x the player
And no, Robertson is not the joint best LB in the PL ffs
posted on 16/7/17
Come on Robbing, you didn't tell me that the FIFA rating is supposed to kick in on how much we should spend on a player!
Right, that puts a whole different shine on the gig, doesn't it.
Robertson must be rubbish then, not even worth the £8M we are supposed to be spending on him.
Still Pogba
JimmyTheRed
posted on 16/7/17
comment by Analog (U17200)
posted 3 minutes ago
10x the price because he's 10x the player
And no, Robertson is not the joint best LB in the PL ffs
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Well who's a better lb? Shaw, better defensively, not as good as Robertson going forward., Bertrand? No better really.,
posted on 16/7/17
Rose is miles better, end of debate
posted on 16/7/17
comment by Analog (U17200)
posted 13 seconds ago
Rose is miles better, end of debate
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Going forward definately, not so hot defensivley.
posted on 16/7/17
comment by Eric_the_king (SE85) (U21241)
posted 5 hours, 7 minutes ago
comment by KLS (U1695)
posted 15 hours, 32 minutes ago
comment by Eric_the_king (SE85) (U21241)
posted 3 minutes ago
He'd be a very typical Liverpool signing. Decent enough player but not shopping at the top table there are you?
Surely you should be competing for better players than that.
---------------------------
Same could be said for lindelof!
Is he better than the leftbacks we have at the minute?
Yes!
Will we lose money on him at £8m?
No!
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Lindelof is a starter for Sweden and just won a few titles with Benfica's and played in Europe. So no its nothing like it actually. Hahaha.
---------------------------
Sweden are world beaters are they?
Won stuff with Benfica, so did Lazar Markovic!
posted on 16/7/17
No Robertson is not better than Rose defensively. Just cos he's linked with you doesn't mean you need to make stuff up
posted on 16/7/17
comment by Analog (U17200)
posted 17 seconds ago
No Robertson is not better than Rose defensively. Just cos he's linked with you doesn't mean you need to make stuff up
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I'm a Utd fan, so I don't care. But he is better than rose as a defender. Think he's a pretty decent left back.
posted on 16/7/17
comment by Analog (U17200)
posted 1 minute ago
No Robertson is not better than Rose defensively. Just cos he's linked with you doesn't mean you need to make stuff up
-----------
He's a Utd fan you nob!
posted on 16/7/17
Makes your opinion even worse. Walker absolutely bullied him in our 5-0 win over them last season. Thinking Rose is a worse defender is a boring stereotype
posted on 16/7/17
comment by Analog (U17200)
posted 28 seconds ago
Makes your opinion even worse. Walker absolutely bullied him in our 5-0 win over them last season. Thinking Rose is a worse defender is a boring stereotype
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I like rose, great attacker. But he's not a good defender.
posted on 16/7/17
comment by Analog (U17200)
posted 40 seconds ago
Makes your opinion even worse. Walker absolutely bullied him in our 5-0 win over them last season. Thinking Rose is a worse defender is a boring stereotype
------------------------
And Mane bossed you're entire defence at Anfield but let's judge players on one game!
Page 2 of 8
6 | 7 | 8