or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 154 comments are related to an article called:

Favourite Director ever?

Page 2 of 7

posted on 19/9/17

for one of my favourite films, City Of God.......Fernando Meirelles

posted on 19/9/17

Spielberg- no one does popcorn movies quite as well.

Stone- great films, platoon is the very best Vietnam, probably war movie period.

People often confuse directors with cinematographers, often when a film 'looks' great- it's the cinematographer that's framed, lit and created those beautiful sshots.

comment by RtM (U1097)

posted on 19/9/17

Stone- great films, platoon is the very best Vietnam, probably war movie period.

Grave of the Fireflies

posted on 19/9/17

comment by Admin1 (U1)
posted 5 minutes ago
Hal Hartley for henry fool and sophia coppola for lost in translation. Both incredibly beautiful films.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Henry Fool is in my top 5 movies ever

Great choice Admin. Parker Posey is a babe

posted on 19/9/17

Platoon was good. Apocalypse Now was great.

posted on 19/9/17

Deer Hunter is the best Vietnam film imo.

posted on 19/9/17

Sure I'll get some stick for this, but mine is David Lynch.

Twin Peaks, Twin Peaks: Fire Walk With Me, Blue Velvet and Mulholland Drive - all superb. Yes, they're weird, even pretentious, and they can be a tough watch. But these films touch strike an emotional chord with me like few others.

So does INLAND EMPIRE but that's the strangest of all. Not sure what's going on for most of it

posted on 19/9/17

comment by Baz tardo (U19119)
posted 4 minutes ago
Spielberg- no one does popcorn movies quite as well.

Stone- great films, platoon is the very best Vietnam, probably war movie period.

People often confuse directors with cinematographers, often when a film 'looks' great- it's the cinematographer that's framed, lit and created those beautiful sshots.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Alt off the time.. yes. The likes of Nolan and Kubrick are control freaks though... They are/were very hands on with the DoP

Speaking of DoPs... Roger deakins is top of his game... Sicario was stunning

posted on 19/9/17

comment by Life is short. Make the most of it. (U9094)
posted 2 minutes ago
Deer Hunter is the best Vietnam film imo.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Tigerland is the most underrated

posted on 19/9/17

Don't think I've seen that Robb.

posted on 19/9/17

comment by Life is short. Make the most of it. (U9094)
posted 47 seconds ago
Don't think I've seen that Robb.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Highly recommended. Colin Farrells breakout role and Joel Schumachers comeback film

posted on 19/9/17

Talking of war films, it got me thinking of M*A*S*H*. People talk about what they think is the best to series/drama they have watched. That is right up there for me. Not been anything else quite like it. The balance of humour and drama was excellent. And the theme tune was dark and appropriate.

posted on 19/9/17

comment by Ji Sung Park's Cousin - 2017 joy squids (U2958)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by Baz tardo (U19119)
posted 4 minutes ago
Spielberg- no one does popcorn movies quite as well.

Stone- great films, platoon is the very best Vietnam, probably war movie period.

People often confuse directors with cinematographers, often when a film 'looks' great- it's the cinematographer that's framed, lit and created those beautiful sshots.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Alt off the time.. yes. The likes of Nolan and Kubrick are control freaks though... They are/were very hands on with the DoP

Speaking of DoPs... Roger deakins is top of his game... Sicario was stunning
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Deakins is great, impressive back catalog. Sicario was a film I wasn't expecting much but turned out to be brilliant.

Apocalypse bow as best war film, hmm it's close to platoon, just I think could identify the stereotypes of the soldiers better, which is s bizarre reason, but it certainly worked well. AN is a little bit too out there, still superb.

comment by Admin1 (U1)

posted on 19/9/17

platoon is the very best Vietnam
----------------------
I met the star of that back in the later 1990s, during the filming of, the American, in dublin.

posted on 19/9/17

1. Tarantino
2. Scorcese
3. Nolan
4. Spielberg
5. Ridley Scott.

posted on 19/9/17

comment by Life is short. Make the most of it. (U9094)
posted 12 minutes ago
Platoon was good. Apocalypse Now was great.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

I admire Apocalypse Now but it doesn't grip me. I don't know why.

Full Metal Jacket, on the other hand...

posted on 19/9/17

comment by Robb Lukaku 🎬⚽️⭐️ (U21234)
posted 8 minutes ago
comment by Life is short. Make the most of it. (U9094)
posted 2 minutes ago
Deer Hunter is the best Vietnam film imo.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Tigerland is the most underrated
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Deer hunter is overated. The directors star went really high after, then he went insane on his next film, one of the biggest flops ever, went incredibly overbudget, ridiculously so. Some of the reasons were building a whole town as the setting, and the director insisting that they waited for days, weeks, halting filming, until he had the perfect skyline for s shot. Madness. I don't think he made another film after that.

posted on 19/9/17

comment by Life is short. Make the most of it. (U9094)
posted 33 seconds ago
Talking of war films, it got me thinking of M*A*S*H*. People talk about what they think is the best to series/drama they have watched. That is right up there for me. Not been anything else quite like it. The balance of humour and drama was excellent. And the theme tune was dark and appropriate.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

posted on 19/9/17

Full Metal Jacket. Forgot about that. Great film. Hamburger Hill was another that I enjoyed, but not as good as the others. Still put Deer Hunter top of the tree.

posted on 19/9/17

Platoon is great. Not just a war movie. A struggle for one mans soul between two warring ideals

posted on 19/9/17

On a De Palma rant, I must recommend Casulaties of War

posted on 19/9/17

I was wrong he did make other films, but that post see hunter movie bankrupted the studio itcwas so over budget. Heavens gate I think it was called.

posted on 19/9/17

Andrei Tarkovsky
Yasujirō Ozu
Akira Kurosawa
Víctor Erice
Krzysztof Kieślowski
Wim Wenders
Werner Herzog
David Lynch
Philip Ridley
Ken Loach
Bill Forsyth
Nicolas Winding Refn
Felix Van Groeningen ( The Broken Circle Breakdown is a modern masterpiece)
Jim Jarmusch
Jacques Audiard
Federico Fellini
Hitchcock
Cronenburg
John Carpenter

Off the top of my head.

posted on 19/9/17

comment by Life is short. Make the most of it. (U9094)
posted 2 minutes ago
Full Metal Jacket. Forgot about that. Great film. Hamburger Hill was another that I enjoyed, but not as good as the others. Still put Deer Hunter top of the tree.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Full metal jacket and apocalypse now just don't quite grip me as much as platoon, there's something a little wierd about AN that even though brilliant detracts it for me. Probably the best looking war film though, looks great in places.

posted on 19/9/17

R.Scott,very good visualist but not a good storyteller.

Page 2 of 7

Sign in if you want to comment