Comment deleted by Site Moderator
Nothing to discuss really.
Rafa > Rodgers > Hodgson > > > Klopp
Rafa. He won a CL and challenged for the title vs SAF. Very good manager. Newcastle would be in the championship now under most managers.
Why would Rodgers even consider it with Ashley at the helm?
He'll have the same complaints as every other manager under his time there
comment by Bobby Dazzler (U1449)
posted 2 minutes ago
Why would Rodgers even consider it with Ashley at the helm?
He'll have the same complaints as every other manager under his time there
----------------------------------------------------------------------
He'll think he's had the purse strings loosened compared to what Desmond gives him
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
comment by Ace (U18814)
posted 25 seconds ago
Rafa easily, won La Liga, the CL, Europa League etc. All Rodgers has won is a pub league and a new set of dentures.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
And the heart of a tranny.
comment by TTliv87 (U11882)
posted 30 minutes ago
Rafa and its not even close.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
This.
People take the p*ss and call him Pep Rodgers but I do think there is some similarities where both need top players for it to work. Rafa doesn’t need that to get results.
The wee Spanish tubster. Not even a debate.
I have warmed to Rafa in the last few years.
No, I have not warmed to him enough to want him to replace Jose.
comment by kneerash-23 Cara Gold (U6876)
posted 47 minutes ago
comment by TTliv87 (U11882)
posted 30 minutes ago
Rafa and its not even close.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
This.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Yeah not really sure that the question ever needed asking.
Rafa by a country mile. Rodgers talks a good game, Rafa delivers
comment by Vidicschin (U3584)
posted 54 minutes ago
The wee Spanish tubster. Not even a debate.
I have warmed to Rafa in the last few years.
No, I have not warmed to him enough to want him to replace Jose.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I've never disliked Rafa VC.
I've read and heard a lot about what a decent, generous guy he is and some of my friends who have met him have also confirmed this to be the case. Wouldn't want him at United simply because the football wouldn't be great but he's done well at Newcastle on very limited resources.
Rafa is a great manager. Best manager at Newcastle since Chris Houghton, clearly on paper Rafa is better but Houghton was a great loss.
Rafa easily is this even a question?
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
Rafa despite the football we played for large parts being dire.
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
I thought rafa was nuts to go to newcastle day 1. Nobody was ever keeping them up but he got them promoted and kept them up so thats 2 years of his career gone and now he's into year 3 with absolutely no support form ashley.
I know the wheels have come off for rodgers but he would be utterly utterly stupid to leave celtic for newcastle as it would end his career
Since the SPL is absolute pub then you may as well dismiss what Rodgers has achieved up there when comparing the 2, and where does that leave Rodgers? A promotion with Swansea and nearly winning a PL title with Liverpool when they had no Europe and Suarez.
There is no point to this question.
Talking of Rafa, I found this gem from 2011 earlier.
Best youth setup in the country
by Liverpool Til I Die (U7865) 22 June 2011
It is all pointing to a very positive future. This is all a result of Rafa's legacy, and will be harnessed by Kenny. I am convinced that we are at the start of a golden era for the club. A decade of dominance like Man U enjoyed in the 90s. Only this time it will be Rafa's Raggamuffins or Kenny's Kids.
YNWA.
Sign in if you want to comment
Rafa or Rodgers?
Page 1 of 2
posted on 15/10/18
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 15/10/18
Nothing to discuss really.
posted on 15/10/18
Rafa > Rodgers > Hodgson > > > Klopp
posted on 15/10/18
Rafa. He won a CL and challenged for the title vs SAF. Very good manager. Newcastle would be in the championship now under most managers.
posted on 15/10/18
Why would Rodgers even consider it with Ashley at the helm?
He'll have the same complaints as every other manager under his time there
posted on 15/10/18
comment by Bobby Dazzler (U1449)
posted 2 minutes ago
Why would Rodgers even consider it with Ashley at the helm?
He'll have the same complaints as every other manager under his time there
----------------------------------------------------------------------
He'll think he's had the purse strings loosened compared to what Desmond gives him
posted on 15/10/18
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 15/10/18
comment by Ace (U18814)
posted 25 seconds ago
Rafa easily, won La Liga, the CL, Europa League etc. All Rodgers has won is a pub league and a new set of dentures.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
And the heart of a tranny.
posted on 15/10/18
comment by TTliv87 (U11882)
posted 30 minutes ago
Rafa and its not even close.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
This.
posted on 15/10/18
People take the p*ss and call him Pep Rodgers but I do think there is some similarities where both need top players for it to work. Rafa doesn’t need that to get results.
posted on 15/10/18
The wee Spanish tubster. Not even a debate.
I have warmed to Rafa in the last few years.
No, I have not warmed to him enough to want him to replace Jose.
posted on 15/10/18
comment by kneerash-23 Cara Gold (U6876)
posted 47 minutes ago
comment by TTliv87 (U11882)
posted 30 minutes ago
Rafa and its not even close.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
This.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Yeah not really sure that the question ever needed asking.
posted on 15/10/18
Fishing for 5 stars.
posted on 15/10/18
Rafa by a country mile. Rodgers talks a good game, Rafa delivers
posted on 15/10/18
comment by Vidicschin (U3584)
posted 54 minutes ago
The wee Spanish tubster. Not even a debate.
I have warmed to Rafa in the last few years.
No, I have not warmed to him enough to want him to replace Jose.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I've never disliked Rafa VC.
I've read and heard a lot about what a decent, generous guy he is and some of my friends who have met him have also confirmed this to be the case. Wouldn't want him at United simply because the football wouldn't be great but he's done well at Newcastle on very limited resources.
posted on 15/10/18
Rafa is a great manager. Best manager at Newcastle since Chris Houghton, clearly on paper Rafa is better but Houghton was a great loss.
posted on 15/10/18
Rafa easily is this even a question?
posted on 15/10/18
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 15/10/18
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 16/10/18
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 16/10/18
Rafa despite the football we played for large parts being dire.
posted on 16/10/18
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 16/10/18
I thought rafa was nuts to go to newcastle day 1. Nobody was ever keeping them up but he got them promoted and kept them up so thats 2 years of his career gone and now he's into year 3 with absolutely no support form ashley.
I know the wheels have come off for rodgers but he would be utterly utterly stupid to leave celtic for newcastle as it would end his career
posted on 16/10/18
Since the SPL is absolute pub then you may as well dismiss what Rodgers has achieved up there when comparing the 2, and where does that leave Rodgers? A promotion with Swansea and nearly winning a PL title with Liverpool when they had no Europe and Suarez.
There is no point to this question.
posted on 16/10/18
Talking of Rafa, I found this gem from 2011 earlier.
Best youth setup in the country
by Liverpool Til I Die (U7865) 22 June 2011
It is all pointing to a very positive future. This is all a result of Rafa's legacy, and will be harnessed by Kenny. I am convinced that we are at the start of a golden era for the club. A decade of dominance like Man U enjoyed in the 90s. Only this time it will be Rafa's Raggamuffins or Kenny's Kids.
YNWA.
Page 1 of 2