Of course we should try and keep him but with Jose in charge, he will leave.
Such a shame. Great talent and would have loved to have seen him get more minutes.

I think we have a 1 year option on him too don't we? However I can't blame the fella for not wanting to commit further. He's clearly a talented player but he's a proper footballer so he'd better joining a team that wants to play football.

We need to be more cut throat with shipping people out. Additionally, ff he isn't playing then I don't blame him for not wanting to sign a contract.

To be honest I've never really seen what other people seem to see in him.

Decent player with decent technical ability. I havent watched much of him in the youth teams admittedly, but he's never really stood out to me.

I would agree though that he looks to have more about him than McT. In terms of talent at least.

comment by Eric_the_king (SE85) (U21241)
posted 7 minutes ago
I think we have a 1 year option on him too don't we? However I can't blame the fella for not wanting to commit further. He's clearly a talented player but he's a proper footballer so he'd better joining a team that wants to play football.


----------------------------------------------------------------------

Apparently the 1 year option isn't something the club can unilaterally exercise as per norm.

It's a mutual clause, which Pereira is unlikely to agree to currently.

It's a mutual clause, which Pereira is unlikely to agree to currently.
-----------
well that's a bit useless then

I think we should see how Rooney is preforming now he's made it back into the international scene. He must be pulling up trees in America and he'd do well in CM for us. If he's still doing nothing for England then maybe we can get Scholes back to stunt more young players.

Can't blame him. He wants to play games... It's the reason he went on loan the past couple of seasons

He's made the Brazil squad... He won't stay in it by sitting in the stand

If a fully fit £50m Fred is going to be behind a half fit Groot and a dismally poor Matic, then a young player has no chance

DDG, Martial and Pereira all refusing to sign

Matic, Lukaku and Fellaini are the future... Along with Young and Valencia new contract... Nothing to be concerned about

comment by Shugs (U14253)
posted 1 minute ago
Can't blame him. He wants to play games... It's the reason he went on loan the past couple of seasons

He's made the Brazil squad... He won't stay in it by sitting in the stand

If a fully fit £50m Fred is going to be behind a half fit Groot and a dismally poor Matic, then a young player has no chance

DDG, Martial and Pereira all refusing to sign

Matic, Lukaku and Fellaini are the future... Along with Young and Valencia new contract... Nothing to be concerned about
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Its fine. They're underperforming and we make enough money to keep buying players that don't work out. Let them go and keep Mourinho, he's the only one that can't be replaced.

comment by iNaythan (U6122)
posted 8 seconds ago
comment by Shugs (U14253)
posted 1 minute ago
Can't blame him. He wants to play games... It's the reason he went on loan the past couple of seasons

He's made the Brazil squad... He won't stay in it by sitting in the stand

If a fully fit £50m Fred is going to be behind a half fit Groot and a dismally poor Matic, then a young player has no chance

DDG, Martial and Pereira all refusing to sign

Matic, Lukaku and Fellaini are the future... Along with Young and Valencia new contract... Nothing to be concerned about
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Its fine. They're underperforming and we make enough money to keep buying players that don't work out. Let them go and keep Mourinho, he's the only one that can't be replaced.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

The rebuilding job he could leave behind him is frightening

comment by Shugs (U14253)
posted 22 seconds ago
comment by iNaythan (U6122)
posted 8 seconds ago
comment by Shugs (U14253)
posted 1 minute ago
Can't blame him. He wants to play games... It's the reason he went on loan the past couple of seasons

He's made the Brazil squad... He won't stay in it by sitting in the stand

If a fully fit £50m Fred is going to be behind a half fit Groot and a dismally poor Matic, then a young player has no chance

DDG, Martial and Pereira all refusing to sign

Matic, Lukaku and Fellaini are the future... Along with Young and Valencia new contract... Nothing to be concerned about
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Its fine. They're underperforming and we make enough money to keep buying players that don't work out. Let them go and keep Mourinho, he's the only one that can't be replaced.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

The rebuilding job he could leave behind him is frightening


----------------------------------------------------------------------
Did you not read what I said? He's going nowhere. Isn't he on a 5 year contract?

comment by Shugs (U14253)
posted 7 minutes ago
DDG, Martial and Pereira all refusing to sign

Matic, Lukaku and Fellaini are the future... Along with Young and Valencia new contract... Nothing to be concerned about
----------------------------------------------------------------------
So basically all opposition fans (and Robb's) idea's on how they want United to look will play out?

Surprised they offered him one to be fair!

comment by Cantona 7 (U11258)
posted 4 minutes ago
Surprised they offered him one to be fair!
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Why not? Noones ever seen him play. He could be amazing.

This is a case of a technical player being over rated.

Sure he had a handful of good appearances in Spain, but he's yet to show anything like being a top player. However if Pogba is out, id like to see him given the chance whilst he is here.

comment by Busby (U19985)
posted 2 hours, 58 minutes ago
This is a case of a technical player being over rated.

Sure he had a handful of good appearances in Spain, but he's yet to show anything like being a top player. However if Pogba is out, id like to see him given the chance whilst he is here.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Whose overrating him?

All we are asking for us something different to this big, immobile midfielder with very little technical ability like what we've had for donkeys. He is a young lad who is very good on the ball just needs a run of games which he has never had at United. The fact McTominay is in front of him means he isn't even close to the team. He needs to leave for his own good unfortunately.

Can't blame him. He wants to play games... It's the reason he went on loan the past couple of seasons

He's made the Brazil squad... He won't stay in it by sitting in the stand

If a fully fit £50m Fred is going to be behind a half fit Groot and a dismally poor Matic, then a young player has no chance

DDG, Martial and Pereira all refusing to sign

Matic, Lukaku and Fellaini are the future... Along with Young and Valencia new contract... Nothing to be concerned about
..........................................................................
and this is exactly why we need to get rid of the fookwit of a manager we have!

comment by Shugs (U14253)
posted 6 hours, 22 minutes ago
Can't blame him. He wants to play games... It's the reason he went on loan the past couple of seasons

He's made the Brazil squad... He won't stay in it by sitting in the stand

If a fully fit £50m Fred is going to be behind a half fit Groot and a dismally poor Matic, then a young player has no chance

DDG, Martial and Pereira all refusing to sign

Matic, Lukaku and Fellaini are the future... Along with Young and Valencia new contract... Nothing to be concerned about
----------------------------------------------------------------------

And this is the reason why Jose should be sacked. No player worth his salt will want to sign with us with him as manager. Only greedy deluded players like Sanchez. Real young talent will look at his track record and run away. We must get rid and start building some confidence in the players of our future. It would suck to lose de gea

Spot on Tomatoes.

The longer Jose stays the worse it will get.