or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 94 comments are related to an article called:

Rashford vs Mbappe

Page 1 of 4

posted on 11/2/19

I think both will score in the game, Robb.

We've given up guilt edge chances in most of these games under Ole. If we do that tomorrow, they will score.

posted on 11/2/19

I've only seen Mbappe about 4 times and each time he was absolutely devastating
Based on those games alone I'd say Rashy has some catching up to do but this season he seems to have picked up the baton again

posted on 11/2/19

Interesting to see how Rashford fares against Thiago Silva who is a very clever and experienced CB.

posted on 11/2/19

Rashford can be very good but I dont think there is a comparison with Mbappe personally. The latter is incredible, a generational talent

comment by Elvis (U7425)

posted on 11/2/19

Two of the best young talents in the world Robb? Rashford is nothing more than a poacher.

posted on 11/2/19

comment by Elvis (U7425)
posted 4 minutes ago
Two of the best young talents in the world Robb? Rashford is nothing more than a poacher.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

He’s come along a long way. Imo learnt a lot from Jose and has become a top player

posted on 11/2/19

I do think there’s a lot of similarities in their style of play, though of course Mbappe is on another level

posted on 11/2/19

Not that I don’t like Rashford who is also a great young talent with high potential

posted on 11/2/19

Rashford is a very good young player, but please stop with these Mbappe comparisons. The latter is on another level.

posted on 11/2/19

Mbappe has 25 goals and 10 assists already this season. Amazing achievements. He is on a different level.

Marcus’s 9 goals and 6 assists is impressing - considering the PL difficulty level in comparison to the French, not to mention Mourinho's approach that slowed down Rashford's goals and assists in comparison to OGS young reign

posted on 11/2/19

comment by Elvis (U7425)
posted 7 minutes ago
Two of the best young talents in the world Robb? Rashford is nothing more than a poacher.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

I agree he's not as good as Mbappe but to say he's just a poacher shows you know nothing about football.

He's a lot more than that. If you can't see his intelligent runs then football is not for you. Shearer talks about his running off the ball and runs in behind and says he's one of the best at it he's seen.

Mbappe is just a phenomenal talent. No shame being inferior to him.

posted on 11/2/19

Nowt against rashford but he won't even be among the top ten players on the pitch tomorrow night ffs

posted on 11/2/19

comment by Cinciwolf--He's only going for another prediction comp double ffs (U11551)
posted 5 seconds ago
Nowt against rashford but he won't even be among the top ten players on the pitch tomorrow night ffs
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Okay then

comment by Elvis (U7425)

posted on 11/2/19

comment by Robb Ferguson (U21234)

posted 2 minutes ago

comment by Elvis (U7425) 
posted 4 minutes ago
Two of the best young talents in the world Robb? Rashford is nothing more than a poacher.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

He’s come along a long way. Imo learnt a lot from Jose and has become a top player
-------

You're a strange one. A few years ago you were saying rashford was the business and had it all. Then when other fans were annoyed at him not getting any time up front you tried to descredit him as nothing more than a finisher/poacher, to defend Jose and Lukaku. Now he is world class again and it's all thanks to Jose.

comment by Elvis (U7425)

posted on 11/2/19

comment by Eric_the_king (SE85) (U21241)

posted 3 minutes ago

comment by Elvis (U7425) 
posted 7 minutes ago
Two of the best young talents in the world Robb? Rashford is nothing more than a poacher.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

I agree he's not as good as Mbappe but to say he's just a poacher shows you know nothing about football. 

He's a lot more than that. If you can't see his intelligent runs then football is not for you. Shearer talks about his running off the ball and runs in behind and says he's one of the best at it he's seen. 

Mbappe is just a phenomenal talent. No shame being inferior to him.
------

Erm.... I was just repeating Robb's own words back to himself.

comment by 8bit (U2653)

posted on 11/2/19

Rashford can be world class but if Mbappe carries on this way he'll be one of the all time greats.

posted on 11/2/19

comment by Elvis (U7425)
posted 56 seconds ago
comment by Robb Ferguson (U21234)

posted 2 minutes ago

comment by Elvis (U7425) 
posted 4 minutes ago
Two of the best young talents in the world Robb? Rashford is nothing more than a poacher.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

He’s come along a long way. Imo learnt a lot from Jose and has become a top player
-------

You're a strange one. A few years ago you were saying rashford was the business and had it all. Then when other fans were annoyed at him not getting any time up front you tried to descredit him as nothing more than a finisher/poacher, to defend Jose and Lukaku. Now he is world class again and it's all thanks to Jose.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

😂

Its bizarre you have it all worked out like that.

Here’s the reality

2016 - I feel he has incredible potential but not sure on his all round ability - hence poacher comment

2017 - I see him play wide and he seems to be good at that as well as finishing and am more than happy for him to play wide and be there while Lukaku is up top.

2019 - He’s back playing central - of which I have no issue with - and though I’m not saying it’s all down to Jose - I feel that playing wide as much as he has has helped make him a player with a lot more to his game.

But don’t let your weird agenda against me cloud your thinking - heaven forbid!

comment by Prem (U7618)

posted on 11/2/19

Rashford is a great talent and, one of the best youngsters at the moment. Really pleased with his progression under the coaching staff and Ole's guidance.

But as much as i rate him, this other kid Mbappe is on another level. He is the one that i fear the most tomorrow night. He is so dangerous and almost unpredictable at times. Such a difficult youngster to mark out of the game in today's modern game. Our defence is going to have to be on 110% focus to keep him quiet.

comment by Elvis (U7425)

posted on 11/2/19

No agenda Robb. You just contradict yourself a lot depending on what discussion you are having.

posted on 11/2/19

I’ve not seen a young player with his intelligence and composure in a forward since Ronaldo Naz. And he was arguably the best teenager to ever play football. That’s the company Mbappe is in at his age right now.

posted on 11/2/19

comment by Elvis (U7425)
posted 2 seconds ago
No agenda Robb. You just contradict yourself a lot depending on what discussion you are having.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

In your opinion. I’ve been very clear about Rashford. You’ll see I compared him to Mbappe years ago

Save your anger for the douchebags - of which there were many - who called him Gashford

posted on 11/2/19

Not that it makes Rash a better player but I doubt many would be surprised if Rash scored a couple of great goals tomorrow and Mbappe did nothing.

comment by Prem (U7618)

posted on 11/2/19

Mbappe is going the right way to being a future Ballon d'or winner. Once the two freaks retire, then Mbappe (if he continues this form and then some) and whoever is his rival will be the next Ron and Messi Ballon d'or hoggers.

posted on 12/2/19

comment by Prem (U7618)
posted 4 minutes ago
Mbappe is going the right way to being a future Ballon d'or winner. Once the two freaks retire, then Mbappe (if he continues this form and then some) and whoever is his rival will be the next Ron and Messi Ballon d'or hoggers.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

There’s no reason why Rash can’t be the other

posted on 12/2/19

I don’t think we’ll see anthing like that. It will likely return to normality where it flicks between a few different players as new top talents come onto the scene.

Page 1 of 4

Sign in if you want to comment