or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 23 comments are related to an article called:

So who should captain the team

Page 1 of 1

posted on 18/2/19

Kasper for Player / Manager and Captain

posted on 18/2/19

I think it should be Ghezzal personally.

For his leadership qualities on and off the pitch, and the way he unites players, manager and fans alike.

comment by Jobyfox (U4183)

posted on 18/2/19

I would've said Andy King, but he's gone.

For similar rationale as Mersey: I'd go for Ian

posted on 18/2/19

For similar rationale as Mersey: I'd go for
James.

posted on 18/2/19

Is kasper not vice captain?

posted on 18/2/19

Mendy for me - he'll be in the starting lineup regardless.

posted on 18/2/19

Vardy, a) to prove that Claude was genuinely looking at alternatives last time and b) to make sure we start with someone who might be able to put the ball in the net.

posted on 18/2/19

I have often seen managers just give it to the best player at the club.

So, maybe with this in mind we should hand it to Daniel Amartey!

comment by Jobyfox (U4183)

posted on 18/2/19

comment by Merseysidefox (U4842)
posted 10 minutes ago
I have often seen managers just give it to the best player at the club.

So, maybe with this in mind we should hand it to Daniel Amartey!
----------------------------------------------------------------------

You should stop taking the p now Mersey. You know very well on that criteria you’d only have eyes for Mendy or Demarai Gray.

posted on 18/2/19

Give it big Hazza, seems a good captain in the making.

posted on 18/2/19

Going off what everyone else had said, I reckon Slimani should get it while he can't anything at the moment

posted on 18/2/19

* can't influence

posted on 19/2/19

What a surprise no debate but some good jokes.
Does the comments from his father have any effect on his position of team captain.
I hope Puel does not avoid the situation by recalling Morgan

posted on 19/2/19

You want to punish Kasper for the actions of another man?

Harsh.

Shall we blame WWII on him as well?

The reality is, Kasper should be having internal conversations to discuss his situation. If he’s committed to the team and the cause, he should continue and have a quiet word with his dad.

If he’s unhappy about the manager and the current situation and is looking to leave, then Ward should come in and we facilitate his exit.

However, despite your views Nev I’ve never heard anything other than Kasper being a good influence and a respected player. So he should probably continue.

Maguire can have the band in the summer as an incentive to stay!

posted on 19/2/19

Schmeichel should be club captain, Maguire first team captain.Morgan is sadly finished in first team.
Always thought Magure would captain England one day.

comment by Jobyfox (U4183)

posted on 19/2/19

comment by thorneyfox (U5061)
posted 41 minutes ago
“Schmeichel should be club captain, Maguire first team captain.”
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Agree

And Vardy should be Prime Minister

posted on 19/2/19

Mersey its not just another man FFS its his dad pushing the views of his son.

posted on 19/2/19

Maguire, oh and let him take the pennos ahead of Madds too! Lol

comment by Jobyfox (U4183)

posted on 19/2/19

Nev,

I guess there is a broader discussion that we need to consider here.

There has been talk of evolving the team and phasing out the stars of 2015/16. It’s a similar job to the one Peter Taylor had to do post O’Neill. Taylor changed formation and phased out O’Neill’s players. We got relegated and went into administration.

In Puel’s case the only players left from 15/16 who feature regularly are Schmeichel, Vardy and Albrighton. Well there’s Morgan as well, but he’s a slightly different case as age would probably necessitate his phasing out anyway.

So, if Vardy, Schmeichel et al are being disruptive then who do we back? Them or Puel.

If we back Puel then are we sure that he’s the manager we want here next season? Are we going to back him in the transfer market with funds for more players - particularly a striker? Do we go whole hog with Puel? Are we sure we won’t do another Taylor?

Or

Do we sack him now and back someone else?

If he takes the captaincy of Schmeichel and starts leaving out Vardy then it might start the end game. If we start winning he’s achieved something quite impressive. If we continue to lose I feel it will hasten his demise and the axe will fall quite quickly.

Ultimately it’s only performances on the pitch and winning games that will persuade the masses to side with Puel over the players. He needs to start doing that - and soon.

posted on 19/2/19

Yep, as Joby states. Big decisions require results now, otherwise they look like suicide.

posted on 19/2/19

This run of games is critical for Claude's future. We've done really well against three of the best sides in the division, albeit we've only picked up a single point from those games. It looks like we have some progress.

However we now have a number of games against the 'lesser' sides in the division, starting with two at home to Palace and Brighton, both teams involved in the relegation battle. We need to have better performances and results in such matches if Puel is to prosper.

posted on 20/2/19

comment by Nevsaysagoal2city (U5194)
posted 1 day, 2 hours ago
Mersey its not just another man FFS its his dad pushing the views of his son.


----------------------------------------------------------------------
Interesting insight Nev.... where is the comment from PS that "these are the views of Kasper, but obviously he cannot say it so he has asked me to drop CP in it even further?"

As far as I am concerned these are the views of an ex player and he is entitled to say what he thinks without it having a bearing on our players/team.

Are you saying that every time Mrs Vardy tweets something negative etc. that Jamie should be punished by being dropped to the reserves?
In a media led world there are comments flying around from everybody about everybody, thats just how it is......

As far as I am concerned Kasper should be club captain (the way he handled himself after the tragic events earlier in the season tell you all you need to know about him as an ambassador for our club) and let Harry be the Team Captain on the pitch.
Both vocal and obvious leaders, and people who the rest of the young team will look up to and listen to.

UTF

posted on 20/2/19

Mersey look what Nigel did to Albrighton after his mrs got involved.

Page 1 of 1

Sign in if you want to comment