or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 37 comments are related to an article called:

Are City and us

Page 2 of 2

comment by Superb (U6486)

posted on 8/5/19

It's quite bold to say that Liverpool will dominate the League for years to come when you haven't won the title in 30 years. Also Liverpool haven't even won a trophy since 2006.

Obviously you're looking good right now but I'd wait until you actually win something before making a prediction or statement like this.

Things change all the time in football and these days the changes happen even faster.

Back in the early 00's everyone thought that both Utd and Arsenal would go on to dominate for many years but that's not what happened. Certainly not in Arsenal's case.

In the late 80's it looked like Liverpool would go on to dominate the 90's but again that isn't what happened.

Fast forward a couple of years from now and I'm sure the picture will have changed again as it always does.

comment by LEE1PEN (U6707)

posted on 8/5/19

Too many variable to say that. Most important is we both keep our managers. Secondly that we both continue to have a backroom staff that can identify players early to get them used to playing in a squad system. Thirdly the Fa, Fifa et al don't bring in regulations that make it impossible to compete with the likes of RM in European competitions. Far to many variable IMO to sustain the comment.

posted on 8/5/19

Back in the early 00's everyone thought that both Utd and Arsenal would go on to dominate for many years but that's not what happened. Certainly not in Arsenal's case.
----------
That is what happened though. From 98 to 2005 Arsenal and United dominated.
Took a couple of major changes to end the domination (Chelsea's windfall and the Emirates Stadium).

comment by Superb (U6486)

posted on 8/5/19

comment by D'Jeezus Mackaroni (U1137)
posted 9 minutes ago
Back in the early 00's everyone thought that both Utd and Arsenal would go on to dominate for many years but that's not what happened. Certainly not in Arsenal's case.
----------
That is what happened though. From 98 to 2005 Arsenal and United dominated.
Took a couple of major changes to end the domination (Chelsea's windfall and the Emirates Stadium).
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Why are you going back to the late 90's when I said the early 00's ??

In the early 00's everyone thought that the Utd and Arsenal domination of the league would last for many more years. It didn't. Arsenal won their last title in 2004 and since Fergie retired in 2013 Utd haven't been a top PL side apart from one second place finish.

posted on 8/5/19

I think it needs to be put in context, last season Liverpool finished way behind City's points total and not many would have predicted then that they would go neck and neck with City this time around but the overall improvement is pretty phenomenal.
There is nothing to say that another team won't do the same next season, Spurs would probably be the best placed to step up, although a good outside bet would be Wolves if they can keep the same team and a couple of good signings, a top 4 challenge could be on although a back door entry into the Europa could be damagjng

posted on 8/5/19

comment by There'sOnlyOneReds (U1721)
posted 1 hour, 43 minutes ago
If we can improve on Sturridge, Origi etc on the bench, I don't see why we can't be better than this season.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
origi? really? his goals have won you lots of points.
did one just woosh over my head.

posted on 8/5/19

So much depends on how long Pep and Klopp stay around. Also who else turns up on the managerial merry go round.
For whay it's worth (nowt probably ) I think Pep will go in two or three years but that Klopp is in for the long haul.
Two great managers, but not the only ones, we could, fingers crossed, get a good DoF, a good manager and challenge after two years, but who knows.

posted on 8/5/19

Also fans are funny. Lots have been getting at Pool thinking they had lost the league and CL; Now one match later asking if they are going to dominate for years to come.

comment by Busby (U19985)

posted on 8/5/19

I bet Utd and Chelsea fans said this after we consistently made PL titles and CL finals.

Football works on cycles. Enjoy the here and now

posted on 8/5/19

comment by Busby (U19985)
posted 2 hours, 47 minutes ago
I bet Utd and Chelsea fans said this after we consistently made PL titles and CL finals.

Football works on cycles. Enjoy the here and now
----------------------------------------------------------------------
First the cycles before (united and shankly/paisley Liverpool) went on for a bloody long time. Second just because that's what happened before doesn't mean it's what will happen in future, the game and the money in the game have changed beyond recognition.

comment by Benched (U7195)

posted on 8/5/19

I will say you have to be favourites for the league next year.

City need to find a way to replace Silva, Kompany and Fernandinho in the summer. Aguero and De Bruyne are injury prone and they still haven't sorted out the LB position yet.

---------------------------Alisson------------------------------
TAA-----------Gomez-------------VVD----------Robertson

is the best defence in Europe on paper. For a team known for its devastating attack that is impressive.

A top midfielder and proper centre forward your team will be complete. Hanging on to Mane is key, can have days where he cant hit a barn door but consistently looks dangerous whereas Salah can be anyonymous.

comment by LEE1PEN (U6707)

posted on 8/5/19

comment by Benched (U7195)
posted 3 minutes ago
I will say you have to be favourites for the league next year.

City need to find a way to replace Silva, Kompany and Fernandinho in the summer. Aguero and De Bruyne are injury prone and they still haven't sorted out the LB position yet.

---------------------------Alisson------------------------------
TAA-----------Gomez-------------VVD----------Robertson

is the best defence in Europe on paper. For a team known for its devastating attack that is impressive.

A top midfielder and proper centre forward your team will be complete. Hanging on to Mane is key, can have days where he cant hit a barn door but consistently looks dangerous whereas Salah can be anyonymous.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
And yet we both have the same goals conceded this year in 22. I would personally take Ederson, Walker and LaPorte before Alisson, TAA and Gomez plus Zinchenko is filling in nicely as a wingback/midfielder in the system we play and would put him on a par with Robertosn. But then again its always about personal choice and bias tbf. Both clubs have bl00dy good defenders.

Page 2 of 2

Sign in if you want to comment