I like Forshaw, think he gets bad press.. having said that if selling Forshaw means we keep Kalvin - do it
Forshaw has great posture, that’s about it.
comment by Jonty (U4614)
posted 16 minutes ago
Forshaw has great posture, that’s about it.
-------
yes he does doesn't he? - I'll notice that every time I see him now haha
I think foreshaw is a decent footballer, but not sure he fits in with how we play. He’s an out and out central midfielder for me and bielsa likes to play a defensive midfielder (Phillips more suited) and a more forward guy who links/interchanges with the 10 and makes runs behind the defence (Klich more suited).
Despite that and injury concerns I’d still rather keep him, but if bielsa thinks shaks is now ready as a better alternative, then so be it. Personally, if foreshaw goes, I’d like to see DM cover brought in.
I would imagine he is one of our top earners and we may get a fee for him.given his injury record and generally flattering to deceive and with up and coming viable alternatives like Shackleton I would say sell.if it comes down to a sale like this to fund a player Bielsa wants then do it.
Good player, good pro and a good player for the squad. We need to add players not sell them.
He’s an ok player but limited on some fronts.
Offers little attacking play - can’t shoot, doesn’t take set pieces, and can’t remember too many great attacking balls. He’s not a true defensive midfielder neither.
At 4.5m he’s been a poor signing given his injury record. Anything above £2m would surprise me
Shaun M
We need better players, not just more players.
Getting rid gives us a better chance of landing improvements which are needed.
Like the bloke. Think he's a worker. But would not be fussed if we sold him, if we add decent replacement(s)
and as Spanish says, we keep KP.
I'll drive him to Fulham myself.
comment by Wish we had Saiz (U21886)
posted 15 minutes ago
I'll drive him to Fulham myself.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
He says thanks for the offer, but he’d rather take a cab
As long as he gets there!
comment by Promotion 2018 (U6611)
posted 2 hours, 12 minutes ago
Shaun M
We need better players, not just more players.
Getting rid gives us a better chance of landing improvements which are needed.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Do we trust Orta to sign better players? I don't. I'd happily sell Forshaw if we got 2 better players than him in, but will we? We've got players like DeBock, Grot, Okane to move on before the likes of Forshaw
comment by milkyboy (U12731)
posted 28 minutes ago
comment by Wish we had Saiz (U21886)
posted 15 minutes ago
I'll drive him to Fulham myself.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
He says thanks for the offer, but he’d rather take a cab
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I suspect he'd rather walk there .....
Forshaw is a good squad player, just not a player I can sit here and think of anything he did last season where I went wow.
If he's the means of raising some cash, then i'd prefer him than Kalvin to go.
But we need an improved replacement, unless they're eyeing one of the U23s to be an understudy to KP?
Gives ball away
Slow
Slows down pace at wrong times
Sideways pass merchant
Not what we need.
comment by VOF - are we there yet? (U17124)
posted 1 hour, 1 minute ago
comment by milkyboy (U12731)
posted 28 minutes ago
comment by Wish we had Saiz (U21886)
posted 15 minutes ago
I'll drive him to Fulham myself.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
He says thanks for the offer, but he’d rather take a cab
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I suspect he'd rather walk there .....
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Bare foot over broken glass
If a club was going to pay 5million for him, yes accept it.
But geniunely don't get the over the top criticism of him. He's a good player that made 2 mistakes last season
Bast, its the internetty, anybody can say anything they want even though they know they cant do any better!..
Great being able to rip into people that ain't allowed to defend themselves, even better when the people calling them out ain't exactly sure who they support!..
Blimey, life is sometimes to simple for some!.
I could try saying Best!..
Like I said, to simple for some!.
Shaun, I don’t trust anyone to sign better players but that doesn’t mean we shouldn’t try.
Keeping players that aren’t good enough is a very poor policy especially if they are wanted elsewhere.
"Keeping players that aren’t good enough is a very poor policy especially if they are wanted elsewhere."
If they ain't good enough for us why should others want them?..
comment by LufcGermany (U6066)
posted 34 minutes ago
"Keeping players that aren’t good enough is a very poor policy especially if they are wanted elsewhere."
If they ain't good enough for us why should others want them?..
----------------------------------------------------------------------
because we're better. c'mon germany.
How are we a selling club when we get 37k fans at home games 19 times a season? Wtf will happen to us if crowds dropped back down to 25k?
"because we're better. c'mon germany."!.
And there's me thinking everybody is better than everyone else around here!.
Sign in if you want to comment
Sell Forshaw
Page 1 of 2
posted on 21/6/19
I like Forshaw, think he gets bad press.. having said that if selling Forshaw means we keep Kalvin - do it
posted on 21/6/19
Forshaw has great posture, that’s about it.
posted on 21/6/19
comment by Jonty (U4614)
posted 16 minutes ago
Forshaw has great posture, that’s about it.
-------
yes he does doesn't he? - I'll notice that every time I see him now haha
posted on 21/6/19
I think foreshaw is a decent footballer, but not sure he fits in with how we play. He’s an out and out central midfielder for me and bielsa likes to play a defensive midfielder (Phillips more suited) and a more forward guy who links/interchanges with the 10 and makes runs behind the defence (Klich more suited).
Despite that and injury concerns I’d still rather keep him, but if bielsa thinks shaks is now ready as a better alternative, then so be it. Personally, if foreshaw goes, I’d like to see DM cover brought in.
posted on 21/6/19
I would imagine he is one of our top earners and we may get a fee for him.given his injury record and generally flattering to deceive and with up and coming viable alternatives like Shackleton I would say sell.if it comes down to a sale like this to fund a player Bielsa wants then do it.
posted on 21/6/19
Good player, good pro and a good player for the squad. We need to add players not sell them.
posted on 21/6/19
He’s an ok player but limited on some fronts.
Offers little attacking play - can’t shoot, doesn’t take set pieces, and can’t remember too many great attacking balls. He’s not a true defensive midfielder neither.
At 4.5m he’s been a poor signing given his injury record. Anything above £2m would surprise me
posted on 21/6/19
Shaun M
We need better players, not just more players.
Getting rid gives us a better chance of landing improvements which are needed.
posted on 21/6/19
Like the bloke. Think he's a worker. But would not be fussed if we sold him, if we add decent replacement(s)
and as Spanish says, we keep KP.
posted on 21/6/19
I'll drive him to Fulham myself.
posted on 21/6/19
comment by Wish we had Saiz (U21886)
posted 15 minutes ago
I'll drive him to Fulham myself.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
He says thanks for the offer, but he’d rather take a cab
posted on 21/6/19
As long as he gets there!
posted on 21/6/19
comment by Promotion 2018 (U6611)
posted 2 hours, 12 minutes ago
Shaun M
We need better players, not just more players.
Getting rid gives us a better chance of landing improvements which are needed.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Do we trust Orta to sign better players? I don't. I'd happily sell Forshaw if we got 2 better players than him in, but will we? We've got players like DeBock, Grot, Okane to move on before the likes of Forshaw
posted on 21/6/19
comment by milkyboy (U12731)
posted 28 minutes ago
comment by Wish we had Saiz (U21886)
posted 15 minutes ago
I'll drive him to Fulham myself.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
He says thanks for the offer, but he’d rather take a cab
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I suspect he'd rather walk there .....
posted on 21/6/19
Forshaw is a good squad player, just not a player I can sit here and think of anything he did last season where I went wow.
If he's the means of raising some cash, then i'd prefer him than Kalvin to go.
But we need an improved replacement, unless they're eyeing one of the U23s to be an understudy to KP?
posted on 21/6/19
Gives ball away
Slow
Slows down pace at wrong times
Sideways pass merchant
Not what we need.
posted on 21/6/19
comment by VOF - are we there yet? (U17124)
posted 1 hour, 1 minute ago
comment by milkyboy (U12731)
posted 28 minutes ago
comment by Wish we had Saiz (U21886)
posted 15 minutes ago
I'll drive him to Fulham myself.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
He says thanks for the offer, but he’d rather take a cab
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I suspect he'd rather walk there .....
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Bare foot over broken glass
posted on 21/6/19
If a club was going to pay 5million for him, yes accept it.
But geniunely don't get the over the top criticism of him. He's a good player that made 2 mistakes last season
posted on 21/6/19
Bast, its the internetty, anybody can say anything they want even though they know they cant do any better!..
Great being able to rip into people that ain't allowed to defend themselves, even better when the people calling them out ain't exactly sure who they support!..
Blimey, life is sometimes to simple for some!.
posted on 21/6/19
I could try saying Best!..
Like I said, to simple for some!.
posted on 21/6/19
Shaun, I don’t trust anyone to sign better players but that doesn’t mean we shouldn’t try.
Keeping players that aren’t good enough is a very poor policy especially if they are wanted elsewhere.
posted on 21/6/19
"Keeping players that aren’t good enough is a very poor policy especially if they are wanted elsewhere."
If they ain't good enough for us why should others want them?..
posted on 21/6/19
comment by LufcGermany (U6066)
posted 34 minutes ago
"Keeping players that aren’t good enough is a very poor policy especially if they are wanted elsewhere."
If they ain't good enough for us why should others want them?..
----------------------------------------------------------------------
because we're better. c'mon germany.
posted on 21/6/19
How are we a selling club when we get 37k fans at home games 19 times a season? Wtf will happen to us if crowds dropped back down to 25k?
posted on 21/6/19
"because we're better. c'mon germany."!.
And there's me thinking everybody is better than everyone else around here!.
Page 1 of 2