or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 67 comments are related to an article called:

Villa’s John McGinn

Page 1 of 3

posted on 30/6/19

Hard working and skillfull. Be a decent squad option

posted on 30/6/19

Be a few deals completed tomorrow I reckon.

posted on 30/6/19

Wow is this what Ed means by more exciting signings?!

posted on 30/6/19

Wouldn’t want to be a squad option, even for us or another elite club. Ready to step up apparently.

Could be the next Keano

posted on 30/6/19

Where you from in Brum Pongo?

posted on 30/6/19

The story was reported in the Scottish Sun. He has a very good work rate as the OP said but he isn't anywhere near the quality for us on the ball.

posted on 30/6/19

Following the same path as other signings, which is probably where the rumour came from!!

posted on 30/6/19

Don't know how much truth there is to this. But the guys we're being linked with in CM (thinking about Longstaff too here) seem to be guys who will run and work extremely hard for their team, whilst also having the ability to contribute something in the final third. I'd welcome such a signing

posted on 30/6/19

comment by _Viva_Vida (U6044)
posted 32 seconds ago
The story was reported in the Scottish Sun. He has a very good work rate as the OP said but he isn't anywhere near the quality for us on the ball.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Disagree. He's good on the ball.

posted on 30/6/19

comment by Super Ed (U22147)
posted 1 minute ago
Be a few deals completed tomorrow I reckon.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

By us?

posted on 30/6/19

Solihull RDD, and it’s Bongo with a B.....

Fair enough Vida

posted on 30/6/19

Villa mates think he is perfectly capable on the ball.

posted on 30/6/19

comment by bongopalin (U10119)
posted 1 minute ago
Solihull RDD, and it’s Bongo with a B.....

Fair enough Vida
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Sorry Pongo, but Solihull isnt Brum.

posted on 30/6/19

https://www.msn.com/en-us/sports/premier-league/there-is-no-truth-in-manchester-united-e2-80-99s-move-for-john-mcginn/ar-AADE6sS

To be honest, it would be ridiculous to pay even half that for him. 24, never had top flight experience, would be a squad member, and the rumours came out of nowhere.

posted on 30/6/19

I'm not saying he isn't 'good' or 'capable' on the ball. I'm just saying he isn't of the quality we need if we want to be challenging for the title again.

posted on 30/6/19

People will believe anything.

posted on 30/6/19

Probably bolox as I said.

And wtf would you know RDD? And why pick an argument with me, we have never corresponded on here before.

posted on 30/6/19

comment by bongopalin (U10119)
posted 2 minutes ago
Probably bolox as I said.

And wtf would you know RDD? And why pick an argument with me, we have never corresponded on here before.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

I'm not picking an argument bud. Just bit of banter. My best pal lived on Falcon Lodge and insisted it wasnt Brum.

posted on 30/6/19

£50m

Worth a punt I suppose

posted on 30/6/19

comment by _Viva_Vida (U6044)
posted 10 minutes ago
I'm not saying he isn't 'good' or 'capable' on the ball. I'm just saying he isn't of the quality we need if we want to be challenging for the title again.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

How much have you seen of him ?

posted on 30/6/19

Enough to know he isn't worth half of £50m yet.

posted on 30/6/19

comment by Super Ed (U22147)
posted 2 minutes ago
comment by bongopalin (U10119)
posted 2 minutes ago
Probably bolox as I said.

And wtf would you know RDD? And why pick an argument with me, we have never corresponded on here before.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

I'm not picking an argument bud. Just bit of banter. My best pal lived on Falcon Lodge and insisted it wasnt Brum.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Castle Brom

Falcon Lodge is Sutton / Brum

posted on 30/6/19

comment by CurrentlyInChina (U11181)
posted 1 minute ago
Enough to know he isn't worth half of £50m yet.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
So you think he could be ?

posted on 30/6/19

Do you?

posted on 30/6/19

comment by CurrentlyInChina (U11181)
posted 1 minute ago
Do you?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
No. But I didn't say he isn't "yet"

Page 1 of 3

Sign in if you want to comment