More upset by the foul given before the second goal than the offside. He was offside and that's that. If it were opinion, then the goal should stand but it's a black and white decision.
comment by Eric_Draven (U20260)
posted 4 minutes ago
More upset by the foul given before the second goal than the offside. He was offside and that's that. If it were opinion, then the goal should stand but it's a black and white decision.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Yeah, I fail to see what Dave could do over that foul, what was he supposed to do, stand aside and allow him past.
Poor decision from the ref, that said we didn't defend it adequately when the free kick came in!
comment by Eric_Draven (U20260)
posted 12 minutes ago
More upset by the foul given before the second goal than the offside. He was offside and that's that. If it were opinion, then the goal should stand but it's a black and white decision.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
The frustration's understandable, but the problem is VAR would be unworkable if it had to analyse and call back every contentious foul or throw-in. That's why it can only be called into action to look at the passage of play in which the goal was scored.
Both instances worked against Chelsea today, but they'll work in your favour another time.
comment by gratedbean (U4885)
posted 1 hour, 46 minutes ago
“Linesmen used to flag offsides like that all the time. ”
======
Yes.
comment by it'sonlyagame (U6426)
posted 24 minutes ago
comment by Eric_Draven (U20260)
posted 12 minutes ago
More upset by the foul given before the second goal than the offside. He was offside and that's that. If it were opinion, then the goal should stand but it's a black and white decision.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
The frustration's understandable, but the problem is VAR would be unworkable if it had to analyse and call back every contentious foul or throw-in. That's why it can only be called into action to look at the passage of play in which the goal was scored.
Both instances worked against Chelsea today, but they'll work in your favour another time.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I'm not complaining. I think the VAR decision is correct but too many fouls are being given when players run into each other - VAR can't and shouldn't be checking these but referees have to get better at spotting these things.
I'm not complaining. I think the VAR decision is correct but too many fouls are being given when players run into each other - VAR can't and shouldn't be checking these but referees have to get better at spotting these things.
---------
No complaints about VAR decisions, but they do appear to pick and chose. However, more disappointed with Oliver’s inconsistencies in this match.
There were high hopes of him to be one of the best referees in the epl. The lack of English referees in the World Cup says a lot about the refereeing standards in this league.
He seems to have gone backwards since last season, which is a shame because he had bright start to his career.
Sign in if you want to comment
Var
Page 2 of 2
posted on 22/9/19
More upset by the foul given before the second goal than the offside. He was offside and that's that. If it were opinion, then the goal should stand but it's a black and white decision.
posted on 22/9/19
comment by Eric_Draven (U20260)
posted 4 minutes ago
More upset by the foul given before the second goal than the offside. He was offside and that's that. If it were opinion, then the goal should stand but it's a black and white decision.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Yeah, I fail to see what Dave could do over that foul, what was he supposed to do, stand aside and allow him past.
Poor decision from the ref, that said we didn't defend it adequately when the free kick came in!
posted on 22/9/19
comment by Eric_Draven (U20260)
posted 12 minutes ago
More upset by the foul given before the second goal than the offside. He was offside and that's that. If it were opinion, then the goal should stand but it's a black and white decision.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
The frustration's understandable, but the problem is VAR would be unworkable if it had to analyse and call back every contentious foul or throw-in. That's why it can only be called into action to look at the passage of play in which the goal was scored.
Both instances worked against Chelsea today, but they'll work in your favour another time.
posted on 22/9/19
comment by gratedbean (U4885)
posted 1 hour, 46 minutes ago
“Linesmen used to flag offsides like that all the time. ”
======
Yes.
posted on 22/9/19
comment by it'sonlyagame (U6426)
posted 24 minutes ago
comment by Eric_Draven (U20260)
posted 12 minutes ago
More upset by the foul given before the second goal than the offside. He was offside and that's that. If it were opinion, then the goal should stand but it's a black and white decision.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
The frustration's understandable, but the problem is VAR would be unworkable if it had to analyse and call back every contentious foul or throw-in. That's why it can only be called into action to look at the passage of play in which the goal was scored.
Both instances worked against Chelsea today, but they'll work in your favour another time.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I'm not complaining. I think the VAR decision is correct but too many fouls are being given when players run into each other - VAR can't and shouldn't be checking these but referees have to get better at spotting these things.
posted on 22/9/19
I'm not complaining. I think the VAR decision is correct but too many fouls are being given when players run into each other - VAR can't and shouldn't be checking these but referees have to get better at spotting these things.
---------
posted on 23/9/19
No complaints about VAR decisions, but they do appear to pick and chose. However, more disappointed with Oliver’s inconsistencies in this match.
There were high hopes of him to be one of the best referees in the epl. The lack of English referees in the World Cup says a lot about the refereeing standards in this league.
He seems to have gone backwards since last season, which is a shame because he had bright start to his career.
Page 2 of 2