Ancelotti. Everton have picked up the most points after Liverpool, since he came in.
Jose of course, 5th in the Prem, 5th Round FA Cup, last 16 of the CL.
Currently, it's Ancelotti.
Who will do better in the long-term? I guess we'll see.
No one has taken more points than Everton (other than Liverpool) since Ancelotti came in so it has to be him really. Everton were also in absolute dire form when he came in and amusingly in the bottom three.
Let's look at the facts:
Everton:
Players: £100m players like Richarlison who Barca are after
Stadium: Classic stadium with great atmosphere
Fans: Good positive supportive fanbase
Position: 7th
Overall Ancelotti has had it easy there.
Spurs:
Players: Winks, Dier, Sissoko etc, some of the worst players in the league if not world
Stadium: soulless corporate American football stadium with no atmosphere
Fans: Really awful fans, both individually and collectively.
Position:
6th.
Mourinho working wonders with limited resources.
I just did some analysis in excel as well to decide once and for all who is better by sorting the clubs' positions in the table from highest to lowest using the sort function in excel and it said that 6th is higher than 7th. It's pretty conclusive.
Don't forget that Everton lost to Liverpool reserves under Ancelotti.
This a question that can't be answered yet especially when you look at Evertons next few games.
Evertons fixtures have been a cakewalk since carlo came tbf but can only play what is in front of you
Carlo.
That everton side are abysmal.
Just based on PL it will be Carlo but he did lose in the FA cup to our youth side while Spurs could finish top 4 and maybe even the unthinkable which is to win a cup.
Stadium: soulless corporate American football stadium with no atmosphere
Ancelotti's Everton have faced:
Arsenal(h) (Not sure he was even in charge at this point)
Burnley(h)
NUFC(a)
Man City(a)
BHA (h)
WHU (a)
NUFC (h)
Watford (a)
Palace (h)
so not exactly a testing set of fixture so far under him. Basically 6 bottom half teams, Man City and Arsenal.
Jose's Spurs have faced City Liverpool Chelsea Wolves and Utd in his time (12 league games).
Havent watched EFC under him so cannot comment on how well they appear to be playing. Results are decent - 2 pts per game is solid top 4 form - but it has been largely against the weaker teams.
I might be wrong but were Emery and Silva both dismissed at the same time. Amazing Arsenal didn't appoint Ancelotti. The guy is a serial winner.
comment by Devonshirespur (U6316)
posted 2 minutes ago
Ancelotti's Everton have faced:
Arsenal(h) (Not sure he was even in charge at this point)
Burnley(h)
NUFC(a)
Man City(a)
BHA (h)
WHU (a)
NUFC (h)
Watford (a)
Palace (h)
so not exactly a testing set of fixture so far under him. Basically 6 bottom half teams, Man City and Arsenal.
Jose's Spurs have faced City Liverpool Chelsea Wolves and Utd in his time (12 league games).
Havent watched EFC under him so cannot comment on how well they appear to be playing. Results are decent - 2 pts per game is solid top 4 form - but it has been largely against the weaker teams.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
It's a no brainer. Didn't Ancelotti lose to Liverpool reserves.
Mourinho. Ancelotti lost to Liverpool u18s.
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
comment by Coutinho's Merkin (U22212)
posted 1 minute ago
There have been more Flopinho articles than AnceFloppi articles
Carlo wins
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Flopinho can't even beat Shrewsbury.
A better article or if I could correct myself a better sharticle would be a comparison between Ole and Arteta
Is making an ex club player manager can succeed?
comment by Raptor✡ (U1071)
posted 1 hour, 30 minutes ago
I might be wrong but were Emery and Silva both dismissed at the same time. Amazing Arsenal didn't appoint Ancelotti. The guy is a serial winner.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
He's done well so far, but I still have reservations over his ability to oversee a project on a budget and with a heavily unbalanced squad.
Let's see the impact he will have long-term.
Personally, I didn't want him at Arsenal because I don't believe he's the type of manager who can rebuild a squad from a low point.
Maybe he'll prove me wrong in hindsight, but I'm not exactly raging he didn't come to us.
I didn't think the carlo appointment made sense at the time and I'm still skeptical tbh but he's done well so far
comment by Samir (U2630)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by Raptor✡ (U1071)
posted 1 hour, 30 minutes ago
I might be wrong but were Emery and Silva both dismissed at the same time. Amazing Arsenal didn't appoint Ancelotti. The guy is a serial winner.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
He's done well so far, but I still have reservations over his ability to oversee a project on a budget and with a heavily unbalanced squad.
Let's see the impact he will have long-term.
Personally, I didn't want him at Arsenal because I don't believe he's the type of manager who can rebuild a squad from a low point.
Maybe he'll prove me wrong in hindsight, but I'm not exactly raging he didn't come to us.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Aren't Everton being bankrolled by one of your ex shareholders? There's some dodgy dealings going on at that club.
Mourinho has taken a better squad from 14th to 6th in 3 months.
Ancelotti has taken a worse squad from 18th to 7th in 2 months.
Ancelotti imo. He has taken Everton from a relegation battle and has solidified them and now they look like a decent side. With a few more recruitments in the summer and over the 12/18 months, Everton may become the Leicester of this season imo.
Mourinho hasn't done too badly either imo. Say what you want about style of play and some results, but he's also had good results, e.g. Man City, regardless of the performances. Although he has failed to capitalise on the poor form Chelsea have demonstrated over the last couple of months and hasn't been able to break away from the other inconsistent sides, like United and Wolves, either. I'd reserve judgement until he has been properly backed in the summer. Judge him around Christmas time next year imo.
It’s 50:50 split for me.
You would need to judge at end of season, maybe this time next year to make an honest assessment.
Like Jose, he winds up the RS and they hate him for being a winner who isn’t a good manager
i'd say ancelotti has improved everton more than jose has improved tottenham because jose really hasn't improved you. the loss for city was self inflicted. pep is confused. even though i think mourinio is finished as a top manager it's not fair to asses him without time to bring his own players in. having said that he looked terrible at united, his easy road europa win papered over some really bad managing.
Sign in if you want to comment
Mourinho vs Ancelotti
Page 1 of 4
posted on 10/2/20
Ancelotti. Everton have picked up the most points after Liverpool, since he came in.
posted on 10/2/20
Jose of course, 5th in the Prem, 5th Round FA Cup, last 16 of the CL.
posted on 10/2/20
Carlo
posted on 10/2/20
Currently, it's Ancelotti.
Who will do better in the long-term? I guess we'll see.
posted on 10/2/20
No one has taken more points than Everton (other than Liverpool) since Ancelotti came in so it has to be him really. Everton were also in absolute dire form when he came in and amusingly in the bottom three.
posted on 10/2/20
Let's look at the facts:
Everton:
Players: £100m players like Richarlison who Barca are after
Stadium: Classic stadium with great atmosphere
Fans: Good positive supportive fanbase
Position: 7th
Overall Ancelotti has had it easy there.
Spurs:
Players: Winks, Dier, Sissoko etc, some of the worst players in the league if not world
Stadium: soulless corporate American football stadium with no atmosphere
Fans: Really awful fans, both individually and collectively.
Position:
6th.
Mourinho working wonders with limited resources.
I just did some analysis in excel as well to decide once and for all who is better by sorting the clubs' positions in the table from highest to lowest using the sort function in excel and it said that 6th is higher than 7th. It's pretty conclusive.
posted on 10/2/20
Don't forget that Everton lost to Liverpool reserves under Ancelotti.
This a question that can't be answered yet especially when you look at Evertons next few games.
posted on 10/2/20
Evertons fixtures have been a cakewalk since carlo came tbf but can only play what is in front of you
posted on 10/2/20
Carlo.
That everton side are abysmal.
posted on 10/2/20
Just based on PL it will be Carlo but he did lose in the FA cup to our youth side while Spurs could finish top 4 and maybe even the unthinkable which is to win a cup.
posted on 10/2/20
Stadium: soulless corporate American football stadium with no atmosphere
posted on 10/2/20
Ancelotti's Everton have faced:
Arsenal(h) (Not sure he was even in charge at this point)
Burnley(h)
NUFC(a)
Man City(a)
BHA (h)
WHU (a)
NUFC (h)
Watford (a)
Palace (h)
so not exactly a testing set of fixture so far under him. Basically 6 bottom half teams, Man City and Arsenal.
Jose's Spurs have faced City Liverpool Chelsea Wolves and Utd in his time (12 league games).
Havent watched EFC under him so cannot comment on how well they appear to be playing. Results are decent - 2 pts per game is solid top 4 form - but it has been largely against the weaker teams.
posted on 10/2/20
I might be wrong but were Emery and Silva both dismissed at the same time. Amazing Arsenal didn't appoint Ancelotti. The guy is a serial winner.
posted on 10/2/20
comment by Devonshirespur (U6316)
posted 2 minutes ago
Ancelotti's Everton have faced:
Arsenal(h) (Not sure he was even in charge at this point)
Burnley(h)
NUFC(a)
Man City(a)
BHA (h)
WHU (a)
NUFC (h)
Watford (a)
Palace (h)
so not exactly a testing set of fixture so far under him. Basically 6 bottom half teams, Man City and Arsenal.
Jose's Spurs have faced City Liverpool Chelsea Wolves and Utd in his time (12 league games).
Havent watched EFC under him so cannot comment on how well they appear to be playing. Results are decent - 2 pts per game is solid top 4 form - but it has been largely against the weaker teams.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
It's a no brainer. Didn't Ancelotti lose to Liverpool reserves.
posted on 10/2/20
Mourinho. Ancelotti lost to Liverpool u18s.
posted on 10/2/20
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 10/2/20
comment by Coutinho's Merkin (U22212)
posted 1 minute ago
There have been more Flopinho articles than AnceFloppi articles
Carlo wins
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Flopinho can't even beat Shrewsbury.
posted on 10/2/20
A better article or if I could correct myself a better sharticle would be a comparison between Ole and Arteta
Is making an ex club player manager can succeed?
posted on 10/2/20
comment by Raptor✡ (U1071)
posted 1 hour, 30 minutes ago
I might be wrong but were Emery and Silva both dismissed at the same time. Amazing Arsenal didn't appoint Ancelotti. The guy is a serial winner.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
He's done well so far, but I still have reservations over his ability to oversee a project on a budget and with a heavily unbalanced squad.
Let's see the impact he will have long-term.
Personally, I didn't want him at Arsenal because I don't believe he's the type of manager who can rebuild a squad from a low point.
Maybe he'll prove me wrong in hindsight, but I'm not exactly raging he didn't come to us.
posted on 10/2/20
I didn't think the carlo appointment made sense at the time and I'm still skeptical tbh but he's done well so far
posted on 10/2/20
comment by Samir (U2630)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by Raptor✡ (U1071)
posted 1 hour, 30 minutes ago
I might be wrong but were Emery and Silva both dismissed at the same time. Amazing Arsenal didn't appoint Ancelotti. The guy is a serial winner.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
He's done well so far, but I still have reservations over his ability to oversee a project on a budget and with a heavily unbalanced squad.
Let's see the impact he will have long-term.
Personally, I didn't want him at Arsenal because I don't believe he's the type of manager who can rebuild a squad from a low point.
Maybe he'll prove me wrong in hindsight, but I'm not exactly raging he didn't come to us.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Aren't Everton being bankrolled by one of your ex shareholders? There's some dodgy dealings going on at that club.
posted on 10/2/20
Mourinho has taken a better squad from 14th to 6th in 3 months.
Ancelotti has taken a worse squad from 18th to 7th in 2 months.
posted on 10/2/20
Ancelotti imo. He has taken Everton from a relegation battle and has solidified them and now they look like a decent side. With a few more recruitments in the summer and over the 12/18 months, Everton may become the Leicester of this season imo.
Mourinho hasn't done too badly either imo. Say what you want about style of play and some results, but he's also had good results, e.g. Man City, regardless of the performances. Although he has failed to capitalise on the poor form Chelsea have demonstrated over the last couple of months and hasn't been able to break away from the other inconsistent sides, like United and Wolves, either. I'd reserve judgement until he has been properly backed in the summer. Judge him around Christmas time next year imo.
posted on 10/2/20
It’s 50:50 split for me.
You would need to judge at end of season, maybe this time next year to make an honest assessment.
Like Jose, he winds up the RS and they hate him for being a winner who isn’t a good manager
posted on 10/2/20
i'd say ancelotti has improved everton more than jose has improved tottenham because jose really hasn't improved you. the loss for city was self inflicted. pep is confused. even though i think mourinio is finished as a top manager it's not fair to asses him without time to bring his own players in. having said that he looked terrible at united, his easy road europa win papered over some really bad managing.
Page 1 of 4