or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 52 comments are related to an article called:

Marco Silva

Page 1 of 3

posted on 7/6/25

I`d rather Silva than Frank or Areola, Frank has Danish Pulis vibes and Areola is flavour of the month.

Silva has experience in the CL and has worked wonders at Fulham

posted on 7/6/25

How much would Silva cost?

posted on 7/6/25

It'll be Frank - some dodgy Portuguese rag not changing that

posted on 7/6/25

comment by ●Billy The Spur● LEVY OUT- ENIC OUT! (U3924)
posted 2 minutes ago
I`d rather Silva than Frank or Areola, Frank has Danish Pulis vibes and Areola is flavour of the month.

Silva has experience in the CL and has worked wonders at Fulham
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Disagree.

Silva I have major doubts whereas I can see Frank actually doing better for us.

Silva seems a bit of a mercenary (jumped ship to Everton from Watford).

Silva is meh for me.

Typical penny pinching.

WTAF is wrong with our chairman like he is controlling a championshio team or something.

Has the mentality of one and is a complete and utter loser!!!

comment by Hengy (U9129)

posted on 7/6/25

Frank and silva are both okay mid table managers. Nothing to get excited about and not a club that in the champions league should be looking at

posted on 7/6/25

Frank I get but not silva please

Rather kept Ange

He has already failed at a smaller bigger club than us ….his level is Fulham and he should stay there

I feel Frank has another level but hasn’t been tested yet so it’s the unknown which is okay with me

Silva has already failed at a higher level

posted on 7/6/25

comment by palmers_spur (U8896)
posted 23 minutes ago
How much would Silva cost?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
30 pieces

posted on 7/6/25

If it’s silva, this club is an utter disgrace.

posted on 7/6/25

He'd be lucky to last the season

posted on 7/6/25

I don`t get the love for Frank, what has he done to be more suitable for the job than Silva for example

posted on 7/6/25

LOL

posted on 7/6/25

comment by ●Billy The Spur● LEVY OUT- ENIC OUT! (U3924)
posted 1 minute ago
I don`t get the love for Frank, what has he done to be more suitable for the job than Silva for example
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Nothing

posted on 7/6/25

It had better not be Silva. We definitely should protest against it if it is. Absolute joke appointment.

posted on 7/6/25

I would liken what Frank has done to what Howe did at Bournemouth.

Took a tiny club into the Prem and kept them there.

When you look at how promoted clubs are struggling to stay up these days it's pretty impressive

Would favour him over Silva who has a patchy track record although I will concede he is currently doing very well at Fulham.

What Levy should remember is that we have cl footie, a magnificent stadium and training facilities and the no trophy monkey is off our back. We are a very attractive proposition for an ambitious manager looking to step up.

So choose carefully!!

posted on 7/6/25

comment by Blackpolespur (U9242)
posted 35 minutes ago
Frank I get but not silva please

Rather kept Ange

He has already failed at a smaller bigger club than us ….his level is Fulham and he should stay there

I feel Frank has another level but hasn’t been tested yet so it’s the unknown which is okay with me

Silva has already failed at a higher level
----------------------------------------------------------------------


Exactly my feelings too.

comment by Hengy (U9129)

posted on 7/6/25

If we sacked Ange this time last year how many would’ve wanted Frank then?

Just coming off a season of finishing 16th with a minus 9 GD.

Lost in the 3rd round of both cups.

posted on 7/6/25

Has anyone talked to Frank?

posted on 7/6/25

comment by ●Billy The Spur● LEVY OUT- ENIC OUT! (U3924)
posted 14 minutes ago
I don`t get the love for Frank, what has he done to be more suitable for the job than Silva for example
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Simplest way for me to sum it up is that Silva's team play fancy football but are light weight.

Frank's team have a grittier approach and can mix it up. Better tactically for me.

Upon reading that again Silva is perfect for our club under this current ownership.

Light weight.


Welcome Marco Silva 😂😂🤦🏽

posted on 7/6/25

comment by Baz tard - ineos your face (U19119)
posted 4 minutes ago
Has anyone talked to Frank?
----------------------------------------------------------------------

??


https://www.talktofrank.com/

posted on 7/6/25

comment by Hengy - The Game Is About League Position (U9129)
posted 4 minutes ago
If we sacked Ange this time last year how many would’ve wanted Frank then?

Just coming off a season of finishing 16th with a minus 9 GD.

Lost in the 3rd round of both cups.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Don't really get this point

He'd be hired based on the good season he's just had, not the bad season he once had

Same as Ange was sacked based on the bad league season he's just had, not the (overall) good one he had before

I agree he'd be an uninspiring appointment but I don't think this is the strongest reason why

posted on 7/6/25

If we're going by historical achievements then Silva has more trophies than any of the other candidates, and Iraola's career pre-Bournemouth is lousy.

And yet Iraola would be top of my list, while Silva would be bottom

comment by Hengy (U9129)

posted on 7/6/25

comment by Amanda Hugginkiss (U11574)
posted 21 seconds ago
comment by Hengy - The Game Is About League Position (U9129)
posted 4 minutes ago
If we sacked Ange this time last year how many would’ve wanted Frank then?

Just coming off a season of finishing 16th with a minus 9 GD.

Lost in the 3rd round of both cups.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Don't really get this point

He'd be hired based on the good season he's just had, not the bad season he once had

Same as Ange was sacked based on the bad league season he's just had, not the (overall) good one he had before

I agree he'd be an uninspiring appointment but I don't think this is the strongest reason why
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I don’t really get this point of view surely if 12 months ago he wasn’t good enough for then why a year later after finishing a 10th while going out the fa cup
In the 3rd round again.

Is that where we want to be as a club?

comment by Hengy (U9129)

posted on 7/6/25

comment by Amanda Hugginkiss (U11574)
posted 1 minute ago
If we're going by historical achievements then Silva has more trophies than any of the other candidates, and Iraola's career pre-Bournemouth is lousy.

And yet Iraola would be top of my list, while Silva would be bottom
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Iraola is a younger up and coming manger who plays modern football. Frank is in his 50s that doesn’t have a distinct way of playing.

Will we be okay with Frank sure he’ll get us top 8 probably as would’ve Ange imo but that isn’t where we should be aiming for.

posted on 7/6/25

Because if Iraola clearly wasn't good enough when he got sacked after failing to win a game in Cyprus for two months, why is he good enough now

Managers improve their methods over time and sometimes a club fits better

posted on 7/6/25

comment by Hengy - The Game Is About League Position (U9129)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by Amanda Hugginkiss (U11574)
posted 1 minute ago
If we're going by historical achievements then Silva has more trophies than any of the other candidates, and Iraola's career pre-Bournemouth is lousy.

And yet Iraola would be top of my list, while Silva would be bottom
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Iraola is a younger up and coming manger who plays modern football. Frank is in his 50s that doesn’t have a distinct way of playing.

Will we be okay with Frank sure he’ll get us top 8 probably as would’ve Ange imo but that isn’t where we should be aiming for.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Totally agree with this for what it's worth

Page 1 of 3

Sign in if you want to comment