or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 66 comments are related to an article called:

Player Comparisons (Who Is Better)

Page 1 of 3

posted on 10/3/12

Ronaldo or Messi - Messi
Kompany or Pique - Defensively Kompany
Hart or Neuer - Neuer
Rooney or Van Persie - Tough one - RVP
Fabregas or Sneidjer - Fabregas now
Silva or Ozil - Ozil
Di Maria or Mata - Di Maria
Yaya Toure or Schweinsteigher (Box-box midfielders) - Schweinsteiger
Cole or Evra - Evra
Richards or Ramos - Ramos
Balotelli or Benzema - Balotelli
Aguero or Higuain - Aguero
Dzeko or Gomez - Gomez
Suarez or Lavezzi - Lavezzi
Ibrahimovic or Cavani - Ibra
Adebayor or Ba - Ba
Torres or Heskey (lbs) - Torres
Sturridge or Welbeck - Welbeck
Llorente or Huntelaar - Llorente
Robben or Bale - Robben
Nani or Gervinho - Nani
Young or Pedro - Pedro by far
Oxlade-Chamberlain or Neymar - Neymar
Sczenzney or De Gea - Tough one - De Gea
Jones or Varane - Varane

posted on 10/3/12

Messi.
Kompany.
Hart.
Van Persie.
Fabregas.
Silva.
Mata.
Schweinstiger.
Cole.
Ramos.
Balotelli.
Aguero.
Gomez.
Lavezzi.
Cavani.
Demba Ba.
Torres.
Sturridge.
Llorente.
Robben.
Nani.
Pedro.
Neymar.
Szceszney.
Varane.

posted on 10/3/12

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

comment by Tomkins (U1116)

posted on 10/3/12

Exactly the same as didierjoey but evra over cole

posted on 10/3/12

and uncle tom cobbley and all.......

posted on 10/3/12

Ronaldo or Messi - Messi
Kompany or Pique - Kompany
Hart or Neuer - Neuer
Rooney or Van Persie - Van Persie
Fabregas or Sneidjer - Fabregas
Silva or Ozil - Silva
Di Maria or Mata - Di Maria
Yaya Toure or Schweinsteigher - Yaya
Cole or Evra - Evra
Richards or Ramos - Ramos
Balotelli or Benzema - Balotelli is more talented but Benzema is more effective
Aguero or Higuain - Aguero
Dzeko or Gomez - about the same
Suarez or Lavezzi - about the same
Ibrahimovic or Cavani - Ibra
Adebayor or Ba - Abebayor
Torres or Heskey (lbs) - Torres
Sturridge or Welbeck - Sturridge
Llorente or Huntelaar - Huntelaar
Robben or Bale - Robben
Nani or Gervinho - Nani
Young or Pedro - Pedro
Oxlade-Chamberlain or Neymar - Neymar
Sczenzney or De Gea - Szczesny
Jones or Varane - Varane

posted on 10/3/12

Ronaldo or Messi - Messi
Kompany or Pique - Pique
Hart or Neuer - Neuer
Rooney or Van Persie - Rooney's the better player, Rvp's the better striker
Fabregas or Sneidjer - Fab
Silva or Ozil - Silva
Di Maria or Mata - Di Maria
Yaya Toure or Schweinsteigher (Box-box midfielders) - Yaya
Cole or Evra - Both in decline but Evra can still attack
Richards or Ramos - Ramos
Balotelli or Benzema
Aguero or Higuain - Aguero
Dzeko or Gomez - Gomez
Suarez or Lavezzi - Lavezzi obviously
Ibrahimovic or Cavani - Ibra
Adebayor or Ba - Ade
Torres or Heskey (lbs) - Torres
Sturridge or Welbeck - Welbeck just
Llorente or Huntelaar - Llorente
Robben or Bale - Robben
Nani or Gervinho - Wtf? Nani
Young or Pedro - Draw
Oxlade-Chamberlain or Neymar - Are you serious? Ox against one of the biggest talents in the world?
Sczenzney or De Gea - Draw. Both are incredible
Jones or Varane - Haven't seen Varane play so can't say


Good article though for the most part

posted on 10/3/12

Oh missed Balotelli

posted on 10/3/12

Ronaldo or Messi - Messi
Kompany or Pique - Kompany
Hart or Neuer - Hart
Rooney or Van Persie - Draw
Fabregas or Sneidjer - Fabregas
Silva or Ozil - Silva
Di Maria or Mata - Di Maria
Yaya Toure or Schweinsteiger - Draw
Cole or Evra - Evra
Richards or Ramos - Ramos
Balotelli or Benzema - Benzema
Aguero or Higuain - Higuain
Dzeko or Gomez - Gomez
Suarez or Lavezzi - Lavezzi
Ibrahimovic or Cavani - Cavani
Adebayor or Ba - Ba
Torres or Heskey (lbs) - Heskey
Sturridge or Welbeck - Welbeck
Llorente or Huntelaar - Llorente
Robben or Bale - Bale
Nani or Gervinho - Nani
Young or Pedro - Pedro
Oxlade-Chamberlain or Neymar - Neymar
Sczenzney or De Gea - Draw
Jones or Varane - Varane

posted on 10/3/12

"Young or Pedro - Draw"
==

you can't be serious?

posted on 10/3/12

This thread was going so nicely until you arrived Kamran. Some people just can't handle their drink.

posted on 10/3/12

posted on 10/3/12

Now say sorry.

posted on 10/3/12

"Young or Pedro - Draw"
==

you can't be serious?
-------------------------------------
Most people will say Pedro because he's Spanish and plays for the best team in the world and seem to think Young is rubbish because he's English, he plays for Utd (a team that many hate) but the reality is despite the above, Young is a pretty good player. Was Villa's best and is a quality asset for Utd and England. A lot of people will just say Pedro having possibly seen him play 3/4 times in their lives

posted on 10/3/12

"Most people will say Pedro because he's Spanish and plays for the best team in the world and seem to think Young is rubbish because he's English, he plays for Utd (a team that many hate) but the reality is despite the above, Young is a pretty good player. Was Villa's best and is a quality asset for Utd and England. A lot of people will just say Pedro having possibly seen him play 3/4 times in their lives"
===

Most people will say Pedro because he's easily the best player - not because he's Spanish or because he plays for Barcelona. He's one of the most clinical forwards in the world.

Young is a decent player, not great, decent. Pedro is world class.

posted on 10/3/12

Dzeko or Gomez

more like rvp and gomez

btw gomez is better

posted on 10/3/12

Pedro is world class.
-------------------------------------
I disagree .

posted on 10/3/12

"I disagree ."
===

This slightly less funny than your previous opinion, but still hilarious.

posted on 10/3/12

Besides it's comparing a winger to a forward. Pedro may be the better 'forward', but as a footballer is he really world class?

posted on 10/3/12

"Besides it's comparing a winger to a forward. Pedro may be the better 'forward', but as a footballer is he really world class?"
===

Yeah I can agree with you on this one. You can't really compare an inside-forward to an out and out winger.

And yeah, I think he's world class. He hasn't been great this season as he's been plagued by injuries but I'm sure he'll be back to his best soon. You can't play for the best team in history and not be world class.

comment by Tomkins (U1116)

posted on 10/3/12

Pedro isnt world class. Very good player though

posted on 10/3/12

You can't play for the best team in history and not be world class.
-------------------------------
Valdez? Abidal?

comment by Tomkins (U1116)

posted on 10/3/12

Adriano, muniesa

posted on 10/3/12

Anyway Kamran it's about opinion

posted on 10/3/12

"Valdez? Abidal?"
===

Valdez is probably the only starter for them who isn't world class but they play him because he's ability on the ball is amazing.

I meant all of their starts are world class btw, they obviously have squad players who aren't world class.

Abidal is world class imo.

Page 1 of 3

Sign in if you want to comment