Lindengard - 6: Couldn't do anything about the goal and apart from that didn't have much to do. What he did have to do, he did it well enough.
Rafael - 5: Attacking wise he was excellent, defensively he was awful. Got destroyed by Pilkington.
Ferdinand - 6: Not much to say about him.
Smalling - 6: Same as Ferdinand.
Valencia - 2: What a donkey. Head down, run down wing, smash the ball as hard as I can at the first man. Must have had about 20 crosses yesterday and not one half decent.
Giggs - 1: This guys legacy (the reason I started supporting United) is being ruined by his god awful performances in centre midfield. It's not his fault. Cleverly, Anderson, Fletcher, Scholes on the bench and a 39 year old winger is starting ahead of them in their position. Anderson and Cleverly should be insulted.
Carrick - 1.5: The sooner people wake up and smell the bacon surrounding this absolute nothing of a player the better. Literally anybody can stand in acres of space, get the ball and pass it to another player in acres of space, then something decent and get no where near completing the pass.
Young - 1: The less said about this clown the better. Sell Nani and keep this cretin? No thanks. Shocking, shocking performance yesterday.
Hernandez - 3: Tried hard but he's just not a starter. His link up play is no where near good enough to be a starter but his movement and speed is an absolute asset against tiring defenders and that's why he should always be a sub.
Van Persie - 3: No matter how good you are, with service like yesterday what is he supposed to do.
Fergie - 0: Giggs in the starting line up and then not taken off. Awful subs and the rest. Absolutely love this guy but what does he see in Giggs and Carrick? BUY A CENTRE MIDFIELDER.
Rant over and jog on Rob for your expected reply of, "oooo you're a bad fan for slating your own players." They deserve it after that rubbish.
My ratings
posted on 18/11/12
Jalisco
posted on 18/11/12
There you go again rating peoples fan credentials. Who put you in your charge of that? Also calling somebody a kid over the internet really is pretty cliche.
posted on 18/11/12
Fan credentials?
There is a basic minimum standard for being a supporter.
That is - compare your team to other teams. Realise your team has been extraordinarily successful over the past few decades and that a couple of losses here or there isn't the end of the world and if your manager has been responsible for a lot of those successes give him the benefit of the doubt and let him manage the team.
If you don't reach that minimum standard than you are nothing but a spoilt plastic fan who will most probably be a City or Chelsea fan in a couple of years and we really won't miss you.
If you do reach that standard and want to give the great man the benefit of the doubt then fair enough, I have no problem with you.
posted on 18/11/12
Again where do you pluck these determinants of a fan from? You're just cementing what everybody thinks about you that you're an obnoxious, know it all that some how thinks his opinion is gospel. It's not the case bro.
posted on 18/11/12
Well, no. I'm pretty sure that if you asked everyone on here to read that minimum standard paragraph you'd probably find that 99% of people agreed with it.
Tell me, should Sir Alex be given the benefit of the doubt and if not, why not?
posted on 18/11/12
Comment Deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 18/11/12
I'd say it was only 24% but hey ho.
He's immune from people asking him to resign. Did I say you ever said that?
The guy is a legend and still has 'it'.
Just yesterday Chelsea and Everton lost. Do you think their supporters are asking their managers to resign and giving their players and managers ratings of zero and ones?
You're not the worst person on here but I think your ratings system is ridiculous and very overdramatic.
posted on 18/11/12
He is immune and I never said otherwise so I don't know why you're bringing that up with me. I'd never want him to resign. I also find your rating system completely under dramatic and equally ridiculous, however something tell me you're deadly serious when you do you ratings and i'm more trying to prove a point. Again, look at you providing your opinion on whether or not i'm the worst person on here as if some what valid. And I take it you're one of the best people on here?
posted on 18/11/12
I'm just a guy with an opinion. But a more forgiving guy than you apparently.
You give all these low ratings to players but give Sir Alex zero.
I don't see how you can give all these players such low ratings and then give the manager zero.
Surely one has to be the cause of the other?
posted on 18/11/12
The players playing terrible is physical, sometimes you just have an off game etc, however Fergie playing Giggs (AGAIN) in a midfield two with Carrick is plain rettarded and something that the whole world can see and has provided poor results yet Fergie sticks to it.