Our best player in Premier League history?

The reason why the PL is such a good time-frame is because it isn't an easy answer.

Had the question been 'best Spurs player of all time' then the list would always involve Greaves, Blanchflower, Jennings & Hoddle. A little more dull.

NotSoMagicJuande

If we are are going to talk about Spurs greatest ever players
----------------------------------------------------------------------

We are not though Sandy, the OP was about best spurs players since the Premiership. It's a perfectly valid period of time / topic of discussion.

Your rant is a bit misplaced here.





It is hardly a rant to say any chat about Spurs best ever players must include more than just the premiership era. Three-quarters of Spurs history was before the prem even began. Nonsense to pigeon hole football into such a short timescale.

Anyway, you lot seem to have wiped any football prior to the prem out of your lives. So will leave you lot to discuss football history 1990s to present time.

comment by sandy brown (U20258)
posted 21 seconds ago

Nonsense to pigeon hole football into such a short timescale.

----------------------------------------------------------------------

But that's the point, the person who started this discussion chose that period.

Not great form to come on and tell people they're wrong for discussing something that they want to discuss. By all means start another 'best ever player' article and I'm sure it would be a corker

Not having a go

Fack me! This guy is a drooling ret.ard.

comment by NotSoMagicJuande (U1913)
posted 11 seconds ago
comment by sandy brown (U20258)
posted 21 seconds ago

Nonsense to pigeon hole football into such a short timescale.

----------------------------------------------------------------------

But that's the point, the person who started this discussion chose that period.

Not great form to come on and tell people they're wrong for discussing something that they want to discuss. By all means start another 'best ever player' article and I'm sure it would be a corker

Not having a go
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Well said. 👏🏾

Sheriff

Talking of re.tards, and you pop up, 24/7 on the Spurs board talking bollllllox.

NotSoMagicJuande

Not great form to come on and tell people they're wrong for discussing something that they want to discuss.



Not having a go mate, it is a forum where posters can discuss what they like. Just curious to know why though a best ever Spurs player should be pigeon-holed into just the Prem era. No offence meant.

comment by sandy brown (U20258)
posted 20 minutes ago
NotSoMagicJuande

Not great form to come on and tell people they're wrong for discussing something that they want to discuss.



Not having a go mate, it is a forum where posters can discuss what they like. Just curious to know why though a best ever Spurs player should be pigeon-holed into just the Prem era. No offence meant.

----------------------------------------------------------------------
But the article isn't about Spurs best ever player Sandy. A large chunk of fans on here, probably the majority, would be unable to make an informed decision on our best ever player, which is why it's easier to discuss he PL era.

comment by sandy brown (U20258)
posted 18 minutes ago
NotSoMagicJuande

Not great form to come on and tell people they're wrong for discussing something that they want to discuss.



Not having a go mate, it is a forum where posters can discuss what they like. Just curious to know why though a best ever Spurs player should be pigeon-holed into just the Prem era. No offence meant.

----------------------------------------------------------------------

I know and don't worry I'm not that sensitive!

Suppose the Prem era is an easily identifiable and recognised period of football. People quite quickly know what that covers.

Also, and probably the main reason, it's likely to be the period that most people on here know about cos of their age. I'm 32 the premier league was what I mostly grew up with.

I get that older posters have knowledge of more than this!

Rumour has is the best ever player was a lad called Bernie flowers who played in the 1887 side

You familiar with him sandy?