Greatest Metallica album

The black album is too mainstream. Only those lesser beings that aren't actually true Metallica fans like the black album the most. Don't reply to their comments as they're not quite on our level.

Puppets is the best, no question. I'd argue it's the single greatest metal album of all time.

Justice is a close second. Got a huge soft spot for it. At times I've preferred it to Puppets for the sheer musicianship but I recognise it has weaker points than Puppets which is just grade A from start to finish.

Seen Metallica 4 times now. Fave band. Spent my youth learning every song I could figure out. Every guitar I've ever owned has been an Explorer. Hetfield is the king.

All sh/t

comment by Amanda Hugginkiss (U11574)
posted 56 minutes ago
Puppets is the best, no question. I'd argue it's the single greatest metal album of all time.


----------------------------------------------------------------------
Not even the best thrash album.

Not even the best thrash album released that year.

Reign in blood
Peace Sells

Master of puppets I'm pulling your strings...

I mean...clearly the correct answer is Puppets.

I'm particularly pleased that this article only acknowledges the albums up until they transitioned into 'cringey Dad Rock' status.

comment by THudd : The Special One (U1029)
posted 11 hours, 47 minutes ago
BLACK ALBUM

Where’s Sizzle! This is racist
----------------------------------------------------------------------
sizzle voted black album

Seen them 25 times in 12 countries across 3 decades

comment by Manfrombelmonty (U1705)
posted 9 hours, 36 minutes ago
comment by Amanda Hugginkiss (U11574)
posted 56 minutes ago
Puppets is the best, no question. I'd argue it's the single greatest metal album of all time.


----------------------------------------------------------------------
Not even the best thrash album.

Not even the best thrash album released that year.

Reign in blood
Peace Sells
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Opinions, eh

comment by Irishred (U2539)
posted 51 minutes ago
Seen them 25 times in 12 countries across 3 decades
----------------------------------------------------------------------
bit much.