Recently watched these films while in Isolation and couldn’t help more the similarities.
So....I made a versus video to see which is better.
https://youtu.be/oyjSrWEFgnQ
What do you all think?
Dunkirk vs 1917
posted on 10/4/20
comment by Blue in the face (U22288)
posted 10 seconds ago
Meh, it was like a Hallmark movie for the most part. Had a couple of well directed intense moments on the battlefield, but I want more from a director like Gibson.
p
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Fair enough, horses for courses, I see inglorious mentioned a lot, as a good film, but it’s typical Tarantino mindless waffle for the sake of it. Dislikable characters, (made me want the Germans to win ffs!) but has some decent tense scenes. I might give it a rewatch to see if it grows on me, but I really hate tarrantino’s mindless try-to-hard-but-goes-nowhere filler dialogue. I suppose atleast inglorious has less of that than most of his movies, hateful 8 for example was sheer boredom.
posted on 10/4/20
comment by Blue in the face (U22288)
posted 31 minutes ago
Meh, it was like a Hallmark movie for the most part. Had a couple of well directed intense moments on the battlefield, but I want more from a director like Gibson.
p
----------------------------------------------------------------------
It was fantastic. Character driven. True story. Intense. Great film imo.
posted on 10/4/20
I would take platoon over Dunkirk if I’m honest, brilliant film.
posted on 10/4/20
Comment Deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 10/4/20
Comment Deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 10/4/20
Comment Deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 10/4/20
comment by Blue in the face (U22288)
posted 31 minutes ago
comment by Ole-Dirty-Baztard (U19119)
posted 1 hour, 40 minutes ago
comment by Blue in the face (U22288)
posted 10 seconds ago
Meh, it was like a Hallmark movie for the most part. Had a couple of well directed intense moments on the battlefield, but I want more from a director like Gibson.
p
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Fair enough, horses for courses, I see inglorious mentioned a lot, as a good film, but it’s typical Tarantino mindless waffle for the sake of it. Dislikable characters, (made me want the Germans to win ffs!) but has some decent tense scenes. I might give it a rewatch to see if it grows on me, but I really hate tarrantino’s mindless try-to-hard-but-goes-nowhere filler dialogue. I suppose atleast inglorious has less of that than most of his movies, hateful 8 for example was sheer boredom.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Respectfully disagreeI consider Tarantino’s work to be near flawless.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Fair enough, I consider it to be very flawed and overindulgent. Each to their own.
posted on 10/4/20
Comment Deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 11/4/20
Both are boring as fck !
1917 is pretty fcking dreadful
Too often the main character is a complete douche
posted on 11/4/20
Whats happening here then?!
Both boring as fck .. Dreadful?!!! man, you a hard guy to please...