or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 62 comments are related to an article called:

Combined 1 & 2 Test XI

Page 1 of 3

posted on 9/5/12

1. A Cook (England)
2. H Amla (South Africa)
3. J Trott (South Africa)
4. K Pietersen (South Africa)
5. J Kallis (South Africa)
6. AB de Villiers (South Africa)
7. M Prior (South Africa)
8. S Broad (England)
9. G Swann (England)
10. D Steyn (South Africa)
11. J Anderson (England)

posted on 9/5/12

Philander? Or is the jury still out on him?

posted on 9/5/12

I see what you did there Duncan, very clever!

I forgot about Philander Kash, he does look awesome! Who would he replace though?

posted on 9/5/12

Smith v Strauss = Smith
Petersen v Cook = Cook
Amla v Trott = Trott
Kallis v Pietersen = Kallis
De Villiers v Bell = De Villiers
Rudolph v Bopara = Rudolph
Boucher v Prior = Boucher
Philander v Bresnan = Philander
Steyn v Broad = Steyn
Tahir v Swann = Swann
Morkel v Anderson = Anderson

7-4.

posted on 9/5/12

Boucher v Prior = Boucher

--------

Have I actually just written this? Prior obviously better. 6-5 it is.

posted on 9/5/12

Boucher v Prior = Boucher

posted on 9/5/12

See above.

posted on 9/5/12

Philander v Bresnan = Philander

Really? Admittedly the boy looks great but he hasn't been properly tested where as Bresnan has proved that he can do it against the best & he's a good batsman too.

posted on 9/5/12

Amla v Trott = Trott This is a little debatable.

@ DSB, you walked right into it mate.

posted on 9/5/12

Amla v Trott = Trott This is a little debatable.

No Duncan, you walked right into mate... The reason i put the the countries next to the name is because i was waiting for someone to "WUM". Admittedly, i though it would be Neon

posted on 9/5/12

Bresnan wins EVERY single time he plays test match cricket and Philander gets the nod over him?

My score - 0:11

posted on 9/5/12

I agree.

Bresnan > Philander for me but the lad looks a great prospect

posted on 9/5/12

Are there any combined teams that can top that one?

comment by Serial (U2125)

posted on 9/5/12

Amla isnt an opening bat for a start....

1) Smith
2) Cook
3) Amla
4) Trott
5) Kallis
6) De Villiers
7) Prior
8) Broad
9) Swann
10) Steyn
11) Anderson

Honourable mentions would be KP and Morkel. Kallis is only in the side due to his bowling, although the more I think about it, the more I'm leaning towards KP...

posted on 9/5/12

Amla isnt an opening bat for a start....

He is in my team

posted on 9/5/12

Comment deleted by Article Creator

posted on 9/5/12

@ Serial

You've got to include Kalis, he's great at batting, bowling & fielding!!

posted on 9/5/12

Deleting comments doesn't make sense, does it?

comment by Serial (U2125)

posted on 9/5/12

His batting is in decline. He'll get no runs in England when we play one another.

comment by Serial (U2125)

posted on 9/5/12

Outside the top 2 teams, who else would actually get into a world 11?

I can't think of anyone that warrants it to be honest...

posted on 9/5/12

I will start the world XI

Tim Bresnan, and now you fellas can put in the rest

posted on 9/5/12

Sorry for going bit off-topic,

Would you happy to see this match finish in 3-days rather than in 5-days and ended up in draw?

comment by Serial (U2125)

posted on 9/5/12

1) David Warner
2) Will Jeffries
3) Ricky Ponting
4) Robin Uthappa
5) James Franklin
6) Umar Akmal
7) Nathan Hauritz
8) Nathan Lyon
9) Will Beer
10) Michael Kasprowitz
11) Kieron Pollard (For his bowling)

I challenge anyone to find a better world 11 than that

posted on 9/5/12

If you combine India's batting with England's bowling you have one he'll of a team.

Sehwag
Cook
Trott
Tendulkar
Kohli
Dhoni (W)
Prior
Broad
Swann
Zaheer
Anderson

posted on 9/5/12

When did this become the world XI serial?

I agree that, that is a top side Sandro but I think the Eng - SA team still wins it.

Mafia boy

Page 1 of 3

Sign in if you want to comment