or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 521 comments are related to an article called:

Stoke Team - Park Ji.

Page 20 of 21

posted on 1/11/12

Aye go for it why not

posted on 2/11/12

Sanchez + X
=
Ribery + X

comment by kamran (U1022)

posted on 2/11/12

Ribery + Carrick
for
Reus + Veloso + Boateng(DF)

posted on 2/11/12

Ozil NFS

comment by kamran (U1022)

posted on 2/11/12

Ribery + Carrick
for
Reus + Veloso + Boateng
----------------------------------

No thanks, would massively weaken my first team.
------------------
Really?

Ribery>Reus
Carrick<<Veloso

Carrick isn't rated whatsoever and never had a memorable game in his career.

No worries but I really don't think it would be that massive.
Reus is a very good player

posted on 2/11/12

podolski+vidal+sagna = ribery+vidal+rafael

enq

posted on 2/11/12

sorry

pod+vidal+sagna = ribery+song+rafael

enq

comment by Hodgey (U1271)

posted on 3/11/12

Very well done on the Ribery deal. And Carrick.

comment by Hodgey (U1271)

posted on 3/11/12

Ribery + Villa for Silva + Gomez

posted on 3/11/12

No thanks. A minimal gain in keeper for a huge loss on winger is not what i'm after. Especially when keeper isn't really an issue on here.

posted on 3/11/12

ribery ???

posted on 4/11/12

enq

hunt + baines + gustavo/thiago
=
villa + clichy

???

posted on 4/11/12

baines >> clichy
gustavo/thiago >> carrick

comment by Hodgey (U1271)

posted on 4/11/12

posted on 4/11/12

no thanks, song would make my midfield too defensive and munain hasnt been too good this season, and would play sterling ahead of him on form

posted on 4/11/12

Not too interested in Nani, if it was Song then maybe

posted on 4/11/12

nah thats a worse offer to be honest, marin would only be release value

comment by kamran (U1022)

posted on 5/11/12

"Carrick isn't rated whatsoever and never had a memorable game in his career."

Seriously? Haven't you seen all the quotes from other players about how good he is? Can't fill a team with flashy players, need someone who can actually keep the game ticking over. Carrick is better than Veloso, especially in my formation alongside Song.

I rate Reus very highly, but Ribery is better
-------------------------------
I agree with you that you don't need need all flashy players but even with the game ticking over, I don't rate Carrick as high because he hardly influences any game IMO.

I'm interested in Ribery but not sure if you want to sell him?

comment by Guv (U12850)

posted on 5/11/12

No to both enquiries. Sorry. I rate Rami above Sakho.

posted on 5/11/12

Robinho, Yaya and Alba
for
Ribery, Cleverly and clichy

posted on 5/11/12

enq

villa + clichy
=
hunt + baines

posted on 5/11/12

yeah, im forced into these offers now because of injuries, so i have to give a good offer, im out now til very late on so you dont need to answer straight away

posted on 5/11/12

enq

villa + clichy + ribery
=
torres + baines + robben

posted on 5/11/12

enq

villa + nani + Clichy + song
=
torres + robben + baines + gustavo

posted on 5/11/12

or enq

villa + nani + Clichy
=
hunt + robben + baines

Page 20 of 21

Sign in if you want to comment