I have it now anyway so it doesn't matter

That's good

Q.

Sandro is a Brazilian International but holds both Brazilian and Portuguese passports (dual nationality) hence I presume I can class as "Homegrown"?

Well, I guess I'll let you off on that one.

http://www.transfermarkt.co.uk/en/sandro/profil/spieler_74590.html

In foreign offers will a player we use as a part exchange count as their TM value?

Juan,

Yes it will, good question

so whats the point of releasing players then?

so whats the point of releasing players then?
---


I assume because you'll only be allowed one player as px per transfer or something? But even then you're still better off transferring in the long run.

Unless there was a minimum of £15m value for an exchanged player?

hmmmm was that made clear before releases? I wouldn't have released some of those players in that case.

Nay mind, I live and learn

Well, If you want to release crappy players. Also, you are only allowed to inClude 2 players in each foreign offer.

Orn we can make it the players in the deal have half the value in the offers

Or as juan said, min of 15m player to be transferrerd and only 1 player to be transferrerd?

I'm talking in the main about Guarin + Fernando.

I released them at half value, but had I realised I could use their full value for player exchanges in foreigns believe me I wouldn't have released.

If it stated it in the rules then that's my misfortune, so I strongly suggest you confirm a rule befor foreigns open

it would have been a lot easier to just have offers involving straight cash, then theres no time wasted between managers checking their players tm values and offers being beaten by tiny amounts like 25k

Guarin + Fernando.- so in theory I could have traded these 2 for a player worth 25M?

i also wouldnt have released a good few of my players if it was made clear that player exchanges were allowed

Welshy, seeing as - have both you can take them both back, but I need GMW to come ond discuss whether we should use full/half value or have a limit

I would suggest a rule along the lines of one player per offer, and that player has to have a minimum value of something. If we make that min value higher than anyone in the releases no one will lose out.

Tranquil, so your saying that no pe should be allowed? Who else agrees?

I personally agree with juan

Tranquil, so your saying that no pe should be allowed? Who else agrees?
--------
i just think it would be easier, especially as we get further into the season, as tm doesnt update the values of every player at the same time, they do it over the course of weeks, which will disadvantage some managers over others

Tranquil, I mentioned it in a comment to park a few pages back. However, as I don't have access to the rules page, I couldn't put it in there.

My last comment was regarding your comment of not making that rule clear

I'd create a new rules page. Copy and paste what's in the other. Just update and add to it.