or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 1462 comments are related to an article called:

Liverpool - LSTD league season 5

Page 29 of 59

posted on 3/12/12

Pastore been out of form for 2 years now like you have said to me before so I;d prefer Dzagoev and Coloccini entering his 30's now and Bonnuci arguably been the best CB in Italy this season, or defo been best for Juventus.

posted on 3/12/12

You're not losing Dzagoev your losing a players who's not rate at all

Pastore poor because he doesn't get freedom at PSG, give him that and he's a player who will win you games

Bonucci hasn't been their best, Barzagli has easily. You're gaining twice it's a better deal than you'll get elsewhere tbh to improve you attack, Pastore is a class player

posted on 3/12/12

Sorry not Dzagoev

Barzagli hasn't!! Bonucci has!! Watch Juventus so many times, pretty much every week, Bonucci has been the best...

posted on 3/12/12

I do not like or want Coloccini, he isn't that good and only going to get worse now.

I'd rather have Menez than Pastore atm so why not just sign him?

posted on 3/12/12

Well I don't like Coloccini either way, age is a number yes, but the older he gets, the more injuries occur. If it was something like this, I'd consider it:

Coloccini + Pastore
=
Benatia + Prince

posted on 3/12/12

What would you pick?

Mandanda
Lich Bonucci Dominguez Criscito
Essien Sahin
Menez Dzagoev Turan
Llorente

Or

Mandanda
Juanfran Coloccini Dominguez Criscito
Essien Sahin
Dzagoev Pastore Afellay
Llorente

posted on 3/12/12

Menez > Dzagoev
Dzagoev >= Pastore (poor season)
Turan > Afellay

Whilst

As you say:

Colocinni > Bonucci
Juanfran > Lichstiener

So I lose out there on some parts of my team, which is what I am looking at now...

posted on 3/12/12

I just don' want to sell Bonucci or get Colocinni so I need something else really...

Menez > Dzagoev on RW...

Turan is better than Afellay I can tell you that for nothing

posted on 3/12/12

I'm happy with RB atm, but take the RB part out and I'd need Gaitan in there, if I got Yarmolenko? Would we be able to get somewhere do you think?

posted on 3/12/12

But I need a LW, not a RB

posted on 3/12/12

But I don't want to improve a position that is strong already when there are other places to improve.

Any chance of a loan with recall on Gaitan?

posted on 3/12/12

I'd prefer Gaitan perm but I'll have a think about it...

posted on 3/12/12

Thro in that RB improvement, and I'll still consider

Any chance of getting Gaitan throughout season if I had a replacement?

posted on 3/12/12

Suppose so. Just a word of warning, Afellay belongs to Arsenal so it would be Rooney's decision whether or not to recall him.

What kind of replacement would you be looking at? I'd really rather have him perm but if it has to be loan for now then it's ok. First choice yes please.

I'm still considering however, just depends, what sort of deal would you want for Gaitan if we used him seperately?

posted on 3/12/12

What if I got Menez? Would we be able to permenantely deal then?

Could do something like

Gaitan + X
=
Afellay (Loan) + Menez

X doesn't have to be a great player, can be someone you could loan out to me or something, or Clasie if you wish?

posted on 3/12/12

So do you think maybe from the above we might be able to see something?

posted on 3/12/12

Just give me a minute please, got something to do, won't be a second. 3 improvements for 1 loss though...

According to you though, technically, Collocini would make it 4 improvements for 0 losses as you seem to rate him higher than Bonucci

posted on 3/12/12

Yeah go on then

3 improvements for 1 loss, hard to turn down, even though it was Bonucci I lost.

How do you rate Rami anyway?

Also, another thing, I've heard your going to University so congratulations on that note, but, what would happen to the league if you are busy at Uni?

posted on 3/12/12

I will do, hoping to keep hold of him for the season really...

Ah ok then, I'm just concerned really as I want tis league to continue as my team has now kicked into action after a nice helping hand from you lot yesterday.

posted on 4/12/12

Thought i couldnt sell him?

posted on 4/12/12

What for Bonucci using Skrtel

posted on 4/12/12

Rate him very highly and knocked back some very good offers, buut try if you must loll

posted on 4/12/12

Dont really need Bonucci as Nastasic impressing more every game

Would need an am of some sort

posted on 4/12/12

Bonucci + Clasie + Lich
=
Skrtel + Cabaye + VDW

Enq.

posted on 4/12/12

Yeah sorry, i rate him very highly

Page 29 of 59

Sign in if you want to comment