merson claimed rooney was better than messi, along with phil thompson, in that infamous rant on sky sports news

Garth Crooks is the greatest. What an oracle of knowledge. Didn't he create his team of the week and put Neymar in central midfield?

I liked Andy Gray too. Cant understand why fans hated him. He's was a Scouse loving tw * t or a Pro Manc b * astard depending on the game that was being played.

I like Souness and G Neville. Lee Dixon is good too.

Wasn't merson the one got overexcited at every rooney touch when we played man united last season

Jamie Redknapp is the worst..

Merson is meant to be a Chelsea fan isn't he? Probably explains his soft spot, even with his Arsenal connection.

Petrescu yeah he is a Chelsea fan. Mers is funny with his pronounciation of names

I don't think you should pick a favourite pundit on the basis he is nice about your team. It is possible to rate a pundit even if he is critical of your club as long as it makes some sort of sense even if you disagree with it. I don't even mind a bit of bias. I loved Mike Summerbee when he was doing the derby where Rooney scored the winner with an overhead kick.

Nev clearly the best, souness decent.
Crooks is a plank.
Jason cundy is the worst, complete idiot.

I liked Andy Gray too. Cant understand why fans hated him. He's was a Scouse loving tw * t or a Pro Manc b * astard depending on the game that was being played.
----------------------------

Maybe but I never watched many of their games solely to notice this.

All I know is that when Chelsea were on and we were the topic of the day, he would give us enormous praise for our footballing strengths which made me proud. Any criticisms he gave were by imo justified.

Skysports is just not the same without him in the gantry.

Earl, whats wrong with Cundy, He's Chels fru and fru.

I was being a bit harsh on cundy there, but he is one of those pundits who shows no objectivity whatsoever, he's so pro chelsea it clouds his judgement, it makes him look desperate at times.

He rips into us on chelsea tv

Fat Ron Loving the new name haha I hated typing out LEVY

Earl yeah he does get overexcited doesnt he. Bless him.

Gary Nevilles the best imo

Nevilles jizum moment after the Torres goal was commentating gold !. One of the best reactions from a football pundit ever, especially if you are a Chelsea fan .

1. Neville
2. Dixon
3. Souness

Garth Crooks

At least in Cundy's case there is a sort of honest bias, much like you get with soccer saturday guys.
Crooks on the other hand presents himself as a neutral but is so pro-spurs and anti-chelsea and arsenal its sickening.

Actually don't mind when pundit's are blatantly biased (i.e. Cundy, Wilkins, Thompson), they're fans just like us after all.
It's when they try and hide it that gets on my (.)(.)s

As for favourite Top 3:
1. Merson
2. Neville
3. Souness

neville
gray was great

Merson, Redknapps, Souness

sky scored a massive win signing Neville

like Ray Wilkins too - unsure if he's still with Sky though

no-neck Crooks want's binning though

Gray is still sorely missed.
Neville is class too.