or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 28 comments are related to an article called:

Make a fair accessment

Page 1 of 2

posted on 24/12/13

I get the criticism of Giroud, but no way can you say anyone else would have done better with the first chance that you listed - it was hardly a case of Cahill just being faster than Giroud, he was infront of him and no other striker would have got there.

Also, an in form/motivated Bendtner is an extremely rare thing. Not to mention his fitness being up to standard. Against Hull he did alright, but he was not sharp and his link up play was poor.

Another option is needed, hopefully coming in the looming window. However, to those saying we should go for Lewandowski, he would miss as many simple chances as Giroud does, however he creates more for himself whereas Giroud does for others. Lewandowski would only be a minor improvement for the team as a whole in my view.

comment by Oxtail (U18859)

posted on 24/12/13

Giroud is fine. Just relax

comment by DTM (U8348)

posted on 24/12/13

U guys are thick

Chelsea out played arsenal yesterday

posted on 24/12/13

Another option is needed, hopefully coming in the looming window. However, to those saying we should go for Lewandowski, he would miss as many simple chances as Giroud does, however he creates more for himself whereas Giroud does for others. Lewandowski would only be a minor improvement for the team as a whole in my view.
-------------------------
Lewandowski a 'minor improvement' on Giroud you have 0% football knowledge I'm sorry to say. He wouldn't miss as many as Giroud don't be stupid! Would Giroud ever score 1 Vs Real never mind 4??

comment by DTM (U8348)

posted on 24/12/13

Lewandowski to Arsenal

How bout Shaun Maloney

posted on 24/12/13

Giroud is not good enough, he no longer deserves a starting place. It is time Bendtner/Podolski were given a chance up front.

posted on 24/12/13

Thank you for your input, Inventor, but you misread what I said. Lewandowski is a better striker than Giroud, but in terms of what he would add to the team, the improvement would be minor.

And as for 0% footballing knowledge, if you'd seen Lewandowski beyond simply the Champions league match then perhaps you would realise how wasteful he can be.

posted on 24/12/13

@Andre
How Chelsea outplayed Arsenal yesterday?
Arsenal played possession football, Chelsea played counter to attack our slow transition/high defense. We took our chances and they took theirs. They hit the crossbar once and we had 2 close range scoring chances.
Did you watch the game or just come in to B.S.?

comment by DTM (U8348)

posted on 24/12/13

Possession means nothing and arsenal only had one shot on target at home?

Wenger afraid to make substitution

Jose brought 2 attacking players and a defender on yesterday

posted on 24/12/13

It would be hard to say that either side outplayed the other yesterday, poor game not aided by the conditions, but neither side did too well with their chances. Giroud's miss was no worse than Willian's weak shot from the inside left channel straight at Szczesny.

posted on 24/12/13

comment by Sömeday_693 (U8892)
posted 46 seconds ago
It would be hard to say that either side outplayed the other yesterday, poor game not aided by the conditions, but neither side did too well with their chances. Giroud's miss was no worse than Willian's weak shot from the inside left channel straight at Szczesny.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
You are joking, right? Willian would have had to produce an Henry-esque finish or hope for a keeper error. Giroud just had to strike it cleanly.

comment by DTM (U8348)

posted on 24/12/13

Stop playing the victim here gunners

Wenger was happy with a point so was Jose!

Cry babies

posted on 24/12/13

Giroud is not good enough to be 1st choice for a top 4 english side, chelsea can't persist with torres and eto'o forever, we can't do the same with giroud

posted on 24/12/13

Even Wenger is fed up with Giroud, and will certainly start Bendtner against West Ham, and that tells you all you need to know about Giroud - AWFUL!! On current form, Adebayor looks like Maradona compared to Giroud.

posted on 24/12/13

Yes, possession means "nothing" but you haven't answered my question, Andre.
How Chelsea "outplayed" Arsenal?
Both team played 2 different styles yesterday, and no team really dominated the other, in terms of possession, shot on goal, corners, freekicks...
I have to admit Arsenal did not play a good game, neither Chelsea. Even Chelsea brought on 2 attacking players late in the game (they also took out Hazard and Torres), their attack did not improve and suddenly turned lethal. Looked like both teams were satisfied with 1 point.
So, how did you get that "outplayed accessment??

posted on 24/12/13

Thank you for your input, Inventor, but you misread what I said. Lewandowski is a better striker than Giroud, but in terms of what he would add to the team, the improvement would be minor.
----------------------
More pace
better on the ball
goals out of nothing
goals out of something
basically 10x better than Giroud at every you want a striker to be good at.

Major improvement if you ask me. Giroud's biggest contributions to our team is his defending from set-pieces and bringing midfielders into the game, unfortunately we need goals from our main man as nobody else will do it regularly

comment by DTM (U8348)

posted on 24/12/13

So, how did you get that "outplayed accessment??

Chelsea outplayed Arsenal yesterday and Ur first and only shot on target was in the 85 mins

posted on 24/12/13

comment by The Grand Cannon (U18697)
posted 2 minutes ago
Even Wenger is fed up with Giroud, and will certainly start Bendtner against West Ham, and that tells you all you need to know about Giroud - AWFUL!! On current form, Adebayor looks like Maradona compared to Giroud.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Always said Adebayor was better than Giroud and got called all sorts for it. I have always maintained Bendtner is the more talented striker and should be given a chance to prove it.

posted on 24/12/13

Another thread about the statue. Give it a rest ffs.

posted on 24/12/13

You are joking, right? Willian would have had to produce an Henry-esque finish or hope for a keeper error. Giroud just had to strike it cleanly.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

No, I'm not joking - they were from comparable angles, Willian had more time and had a better angle to play it across the keeper. It would not have take a wonderous finish but his shot was poor. Giroud's attempt was worse, but first time on the bounce so probably a slightly more difficult chance.

I'm not saying Giroud shouldn't have got a shot on target - he should, and he should be scoring more and generally doing but let's just have a little perspective. We need another option, that at least we can agree on.

posted on 24/12/13

Always said Adebayor was better than Giroud and got called all sorts for it. I have always maintained Bendtner is the more talented striker and should be given a chance to prove it.
------------------------
Same, what;'s worse is I said Giroud wasn't good enough from the moment RVP left, he arrived about 2 days before RVP departed and I welcomed that buy as good back-up but when I learnt he'd be our main man I said it from early and I got scrutinised for it because I should give him a chance.... fast forward a year and a half and more realise but very few are still deluded enough to believe he's the answer

posted on 24/12/13

how many real scoring chance did Chelsea had besides hitting the crossbar?

posted on 24/12/13

Always said Adebayor was better than Giroud and got called all sorts for it. I have always maintained Bendtner is the more talented striker and should be given a chance to prove it.
=========================
They may both be more talented than Giroud, but their attitude is just as, if not more likely to let you down than any lack of ability Giroud has.

posted on 24/12/13

Funny that this post turned out to be another "who's better than Giroud" discussion...
I thought we have quite a number of areas that need to be improved, than just bashing Giroud or single out a player or two.

posted on 24/12/13

Arsenal had 2 shots on target actually it was an even game. 1st half Chelsea were the better team but 2nd half it was Arsenal.

Page 1 of 2

Sign in if you want to comment