or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 209 comments are related to an article called:

Black Managers......

Page 9 of 9

posted on 17/4/15

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 17/4/15

It doesn't eliminate discrimination, it just changes the targets of it.
=======================================================
That's not what it appears to have done in America, where it's largely regarded as a success.

How do you know it discriminates against whites, if it doesn't oblige anybody to employ a black coach? How does it do this?

Are you arguing that it is discrimination against whites to implement a measure that gets rid of preferential treatment for whites?

posted on 17/4/15

comment by Ttliv87 (U11882)
posted 6 minutes ago
comment by Wessie Road (U10652)
posted 3 hours, 48 minutes ago
I know, you think it's some Liverpool thing
=======================================================
Ok, I'll take your word for it.
So leaving that aside, what is the downside of the Rooney rule?


----------------------------------------------------------------------
It doesn't eliminate discrimination, it just changes the targets of it.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

It tries to fix historical discrimination. I do not support it but sitting down with your fingers in your ears pretending it does not exist is silly

posted on 17/4/15

Did anyone see the Guardians latest attempt to kick racism out of football today? Hilarious

posted on 17/4/15

Did anyone see the Guardians latest attempt to kick racism out of football today?
==========================================================

YOU are a Guardian reader?

posted on 17/4/15

I'm an enigma

posted on 17/4/15

I'm an enigma
===========================================================
Careful how you say that, Frenchie.

Don't like the Guardian, myself. Can't remember the last time I read it (then again, don't very often buy a newspaper at all. I can afford bog paper).

posted on 17/4/15

Guardian has the best puzzles

posted on 17/4/15

I'm all for the Rooney Rule, not because I think it will suddenly make managers better because they have black skin but because it will stop people asking for it and thinking it will improve matters.

It will in my opinion continue only this time it will be all this black managers interviewed but not getting the job.

In time there will be some black managers who are good at the job and this will all stop. Unfortunately that's going to take time as percentages increase.

Page 9 of 9

Sign in if you want to comment