or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 35 comments are related to an article called:

Player ratings

Page 1 of 2

posted on 19/1/20

Can’t fault them to be honest

posted on 19/1/20

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 19/1/20

Shaw? 7? For what

posted on 19/1/20

I think a 2 for James is harsh. Made some good runs into space but Pereira was determined to give the ball away every time he did

posted on 19/1/20

Don't get why De Gea got a 7. Both goals we conceded, Romero would have easily saved.

comment by MUFCdan (U1463)

posted on 19/1/20

comment by ManUtdDaredevil (U9612)
posted 12 minutes ago
Shaw? 7? For what
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Thought he did well

comment by MUFCdan (U1463)

posted on 19/1/20

comment by Posh Mufc Great Hafi Not Arrogant Just Better (U6578)
posted 5 minutes ago
Don't get why De Gea got a 7. Both goals we conceded, Romero would have easily saved.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Made some great saves and no chance Romero saves the first

posted on 19/1/20

Shaw was very good - pretty much everyone agrees

posted on 19/1/20

De Gea 6
AWB 5
Lindelof 3
Maguire 6
Shaw 7
Williams 6
Matic 7
Fred 8
Pereira 2
Martial 7
James 4

posted on 19/1/20

If you at the replay, the header was straight at De Gea, just had to raise his hands and he would have saved it. 2nd goal straight through him.

posted on 19/1/20

Mean look. I think our best player was Matic.

posted on 19/1/20

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 19/1/20

I honestly think De Gea doesn't react to shots anymore especially away from home. I think De Gea away save percentage is like 50% since we beat PSG and most of the 50% save percentage is saves that lead to a goal so it is more like 25%.

posted on 19/1/20

comment by Posh Mufc Great Hafi Not Arrogant Just Better (U6578)
posted 3 minutes ago
If you at the replay, the header was straight at De Gea, just had to raise his hands and he would have saved it. 2nd goal straight through him.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I'd roll the dice and get a player we really need for David at this point. Romero and Henderson are good enough and if DDG has another poor season, we'd get very little for him.

posted on 19/1/20

I reckon if you look at away games since we beat PSG, opposition keepers are like 90% save percentage against us and we are like 50%. Thats why we struggle to win. I think we had near the most dominant stats away from home of most teams since we beat PSG but struggle to score and concede regularly.

How can Man Utd away from home concede tons more goals than expected and score a lot less goals than expected for nearly a whole year? Its like as if we got the 20th best keeper and 20th best side at finishing away from home for 1 year.

posted on 19/1/20

Prefer your ratings Bobby

posted on 19/1/20

Matic has been quite good since he returned
Had a good game today particularly 2nd half

Pick of the bunch were shaw , Williams , fred and matic

posted on 19/1/20

Martial 4 ? Are you mad or just have an agenda against him ?

posted on 19/1/20

Bobby, good and honest ratings

posted on 19/1/20

Martial missed an open goal or shall I say 90% of the goal open and blasted it over from a few yards. You know that miss was bad as Liverpool pundits can't believe he missed that sitter.

posted on 19/1/20

Thought Dave could have done better with Arsenals second goal, it was a flicked header, not a bullet header, he got two hands on it and pushed it back into play then hit the ground rendering himself useless, should have tried to hold on to that at least.

posted on 19/1/20

De Gea is like statistically like the worst keeper in the league since March 2019.

posted on 19/1/20

Thought Shaw and Fred were our best players today. Martial when he got the ball was the only one who looked like he would create something. Perreira and James were terrible. AWB was getting a lot of stick which I thought was unjust considering he got zero help from anyone

posted on 19/1/20

comment by Bobby Dazzler (U1449)
posted 27 minutes ago
De Gea 6
AWB 5
Lindelof 3
Maguire 6
Shaw 7
Williams 6
Matic 7
Fred 8
Pereira 2
Martial 7
James 4


----------------------------------------------------------------------
more reflective of the game imo.

posted on 19/1/20

I thought Matic was your best player and agree Shaw and Fred were decent

Page 1 of 2

Sign in if you want to comment