or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 109 comments are related to an article called:

Harry Maguire

Page 3 of 5

posted on 21/1/20

comment by Techno (U22280)
posted 9 seconds ago
comment by Robb Fernandes (U22311)
posted 2 minutes ago
comment by Roys Keane (U11635)
posted 7 seconds ago
Chelsea just dropped points against the gooners

Have a chance to make up some ground tomorrow
----------------------------------------------------------------------

They’ve gotten 14 points from their last 12 games. Basically begging us to get 4th place. Be disappointing if we don’t get it.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
It's there for the taking. We just need a couple of signings. Let's see how much ambition the board have.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Cavani is available

Have a feeling Chelsea will go get him while we go sign some 16 year old

posted on 21/1/20

comment by Techno (U22280)
posted 29 seconds ago
comment by Robb Fernandes (U22311)
posted 2 minutes ago
comment by Roys Keane (U11635)
posted 7 seconds ago
Chelsea just dropped points against the gooners

Have a chance to make up some ground tomorrow
----------------------------------------------------------------------

They’ve gotten 14 points from their last 12 games. Basically begging us to get 4th place. Be disappointing if we don’t get it.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
It's there for the taking. We just need a couple of signings. Let's see how much ambition the board have.
------------------------------------------------------------------

Bruno will go right down to the wire with Ed giving sporting what they wanted all along

posted on 21/1/20

A Good CB. Nothing more.

posted on 21/1/20

I said at the time when you signed him he was average. He would be our 4th best defender if he was in our squad.

They called him a sunday league defender here in Holland when the Netherlands played England.

posted on 21/1/20

Did you see Chicharito signed for LA Galaxy today? He’s gonna be a huge star there.

.....

No he isn’t. He isn’t anywhere near the level Wazza was.

posted on 21/1/20

comment by manutd1982 (U6633)
posted 16 minutes ago
Pretty much the main reason we went for Maguire was because of his reputation on the ball. That’s also why we loaned out Mike.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Im not Mike's biggest fan. He was average on the ball but even with that disadvantage he's twice the defender Maguire will ever be.

Who knows Maguire with a different partner like Tuanzebe may improve us next season. He can't get any worse.

posted on 21/1/20

Robb

‐----

Would you be satisfied with Fernandes, Cavani and a 16 yo midfielder this window?

posted on 21/1/20

His only problem is the fee means obv comparisons with a certain Liverpool cb. He hasn't had that level of impact

posted on 21/1/20

comment by Plump Pistorius (U22314)
posted 2 minutes ago
Robb

‐----

Would you be satisfied with Fernandes, Cavani and a 16 yo midfielder this window?
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Hell yeah, it’s probably the only way we’ll make the CL tbh

posted on 21/1/20

Can't believe we never made a serious attempt to buy VVD whilst he was at Southampton or Celtic. He's the closest thing to Rio Ferdinand.

posted on 21/1/20

Disappointing Mike didn't stay and fight for his place or is that something pro footballers don't do anymore

posted on 21/1/20

comment by Plump Pistorius (U22314)
posted 1 minute ago
Can't believe we never made a serious attempt to buy VVD whilst he was at Southampton or Celtic. He's the closest thing to Rio Ferdinand.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Absolutely

Nor do I understand why we didn’t go for Aguero and Silva back in 2010.

comment by Busby (U19985)

posted on 21/1/20

"He’s ok on the ball but too many times I see him misplace passes and give the ball away"

He's so often left looking for options though, our midfield are awful at finding space.

posted on 21/1/20

comment by Plump Pistorius (U22314)
posted 2 minutes ago
Can't believe we never made a serious attempt to buy VVD whilst he was at Southampton or Celtic. He's the closest thing to Rio Ferdinand.
------------------------------------------------------------------

True particularly when lvg was here and he was at Celtic

posted on 21/1/20

comment by Robb Fernandes (U22311)
posted 21 seconds ago
comment by Plump Pistorius (U22314)
posted 2 minutes ago
Robb

‐----

Would you be satisfied with Fernandes, Cavani and a 16 yo midfielder this window?
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Hell yeah, it’s probably the only way we’ll make the CL tbh
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Ed is taking a lot of flak and rightly so for a serious dereliction of duty overseeing such a catalogue of recruitment failure; he needs to start delivering.

Cavani and Bruno would add serious creativity and goal threat to our attack. Both should have been recruited last summer imho.

posted on 21/1/20

comment by Robb Fernandes (U22311)
posted 34 minutes ago
comment by Techno (U22280)
posted 1 minute ago
In a way, Maguire was a bit of a panic buy. We needed someone in the short term who could head a ball and show leadership. He was our only option despite his shortcomings. Leicester know we were desperate and held out for the full amount.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

I wonder if our summer had gone like this

Kept Smalling
Kept Lukaku and Ole had committed to getting him match fit and motivated like Conte has
Bought Tielemans
Bought Ricardo Pereira
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Lukaku needed to go. Never fit, would have become a cancer and watch him in italy, he is just as rubbish. The opposition is just that bit weaker.

Tielemans would have probably cost us twice the price he cost Leicester and wasn't really Oles priority in midfield. The attacking midfield position was always the problems ergo the links with them. Also, we have Matic, Fred, Pogba, McTominay, Pereira in that midfield role. Had lingard and Mata in attacking midfield.

Ricardo would have suited us better but we got infatuated with AwB. A good defender though and the attacking can be improved. Can't teach defense.

Maguire was a DESPERATION buy, caused by everyone saying we needed a defender. This is why we should not take anything this serious.

posted on 21/1/20

Smalling is better than Maguire.

posted on 21/1/20

comment by Plump Pistorius (U22314)
posted 34 seconds ago
comment by Robb Fernandes (U22311)
posted 21 seconds ago
comment by Plump Pistorius (U22314)
posted 2 minutes ago
Robb

‐----

Would you be satisfied with Fernandes, Cavani and a 16 yo midfielder this window?
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Hell yeah, it’s probably the only way we’ll make the CL tbh
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Ed is taking a lot of flak and rightly so for a serious dereliction of duty overseeing such a catalogue of recruitment failure; he needs to start delivering.

Cavani and Bruno would add serious creativity and goal threat to our attack. Both should have been recruited last summer imho.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

I think we might just squeak the Bruno deal through. I think Sporting are just trying to hold out for as much as possible. He played tonight for them btw.

Cavani is wanted by Chelsea and Atletico. But I’d hope our club (stupid I know) would make a huge effort to bring him in. Rashfords goals have saved our season. Without them it could get ugly

posted on 21/1/20

Lukaku needed to go. Never fit, would have become a cancer and watch him in italy, he is just as rubbish. The opposition is just that bit weaker.
———

Absolute rubbish. One season where he was unfit doesn’t define a career where he’s always been fit and motivated. And he’s smashing it in Italy. Even scored a couple of goals in the CL.

posted on 21/1/20

comment by Robb Fernandes (U22311)
posted 2 minutes ago
comment by Plump Pistorius (U22314)
posted 1 minute ago
Can't believe we never made a serious attempt to buy VVD whilst he was at Southampton or Celtic. He's the closest thing to Rio Ferdinand.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Absolutely

Nor do I understand why we didn’t go for Aguero and Silva back in 2010.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Yeah.

We missed out on some gems over the years. You could compile a XI of all the talent who came so close to signing for us but got sucked into into the Carrington Triangle.

Remember Nadal, Ronaldhino, Salas, Batastuta, etc etc ?! For all SAFs and David Gill's transfer success they missed out on shed load of talent. Can't complain overall though.

posted on 21/1/20

comment by Plump Pistorius (U22314)
posted 49 seconds ago
comment by Robb Fernandes (U22311)
posted 2 minutes ago
comment by Plump Pistorius (U22314)
posted 1 minute ago
Can't believe we never made a serious attempt to buy VVD whilst he was at Southampton or Celtic. He's the closest thing to Rio Ferdinand.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Absolutely

Nor do I understand why we didn’t go for Aguero and Silva back in 2010.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Yeah.

We missed out on some gems over the years. You could compile a XI of all the talent who came so close to signing for us but got sucked into into the Carrington Triangle.

Remember Nadal, Ronaldhino, Salas, Batastuta, etc etc ?! For all SAFs and David Gill's transfer success they missed out on shed load of talent. Can't complain overall though.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

One name that always makes me laugh is David Hirst. SAF wanted him big time and if we’d gotten him I doubt we’d have gotten Cantona. Sometimes bullets are dodged

posted on 21/1/20

comment by Redastomatoes- Feels very Moyesian...cleverson... (U12026)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by Robb Fernandes (U22311)
posted 34 minutes ago
comment by Techno (U22280)
posted 1 minute ago
In a way, Maguire was a bit of a panic buy. We needed someone in the short term who could head a ball and show leadership. He was our only option despite his shortcomings. Leicester know we were desperate and held out for the full amount.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

I wonder if our summer had gone like this

Kept Smalling
Kept Lukaku and Ole had committed to getting him match fit and motivated like Conte has
Bought Tielemans
Bought Ricardo Pereira
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Lukaku needed to go. Never fit, would have become a cancer and watch him in italy, he is just as rubbish. The opposition is just that bit weaker.

Tielemans would have probably cost us twice the price he cost Leicester and wasn't really Oles priority in midfield. The attacking midfield position was always the problems ergo the links with them. Also, we have Matic, Fred, Pogba, McTominay, Pereira in that midfield role. Had lingard and Mata in attacking midfield.

Ricardo would have suited us better but we got infatuated with AwB. A good defender though and the attacking can be improved. Can't teach defense.

Maguire was a DESPERATION buy, caused by everyone saying we needed a defender. This is why we should not take anything this serious.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Ricardo is the RB Utd are crying out for. Good in defence, outstanding going forward.

We need to unearth another Brandon Williams for the right side.

posted on 21/1/20

Nor do I understand why we didn’t go for Aguero and Silva back in 2010.

--------------

To be fair to that crop, they probably thought they were joining United. Their agent likely said 'Manchester' were interested in them and they just naturally assumed SAF had come calling.

posted on 21/1/20

comment by _Viva_Vida (U6044)
posted 1 minute ago
Nor do I understand why we didn’t go for Aguero and Silva back in 2010.

--------------

To be fair to that crop, they probably thought they were joining United. Their agent likely said 'Manchester' were interested in them and they just naturally assumed SAF had come calling.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
A Robinho special 😂

posted on 21/1/20

comment by Robb Fernandes (U22311)
posted 56 seconds ago
comment by Plump Pistorius (U22314)
posted 49 seconds ago
comment by Robb Fernandes (U22311)
posted 2 minutes ago
comment by Plump Pistorius (U22314)
posted 1 minute ago
Can't believe we never made a serious attempt to buy VVD whilst he was at Southampton or Celtic. He's the closest thing to Rio Ferdinand.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Absolutely

Nor do I understand why we didn’t go for Aguero and Silva back in 2010.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Yeah.

We missed out on some gems over the years. You could compile a XI of all the talent who came so close to signing for us but got sucked into into the Carrington Triangle.

Remember Nadal, Ronaldhino, Salas, Batastuta, etc etc ?! For all SAFs and David Gill's transfer success they missed out on shed load of talent. Can't complain overall though.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

One name that always makes me laugh is David Hirst. SAF wanted him big time and if we’d gotten him I doubt we’d have gotten Cantona. Sometimes bullets are dodged
----------------------------------------------------------------------

True.

Cantona was the biggest catalyst in our domination of the domestic game.

SAF saw something in the Frenchman that no one else saw.

Imagine if we got Shearer instead of Ole? No Nou Camp drama?

Page 3 of 5

Sign in if you want to comment