comment by Tiddles (U17634)
posted 6 minutes ago
I agree the penalty was extremely harsh Process. He is so close to the ball and there’s nothing that he can do to stop it from hitting him.
Completely disagree about the DDG ruling though. You can’t be off the line before the ball is kicked and he was, so must be retaken. Change the rule if you want to but that was the correct decision.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I get that but it’s a dreadful rule that seriously reduced the keepers already slim chance of saving a penalty.
Wasn’t the refs fault. Common sense and referees discretion should be the deciding factor in these circumstances.
Same if the ball it’s an attackers hand in the lead up to the goal.
comment by Ace (U22467)
posted 7 minutes ago
The worst decision was Kanes goal against Sheffield Utd being ruled out after Moura was fouled and the ball brushed his arm as he hit the ground. They didn’t even give a free kick for the foul, but that aside that was far and away the worst decision in VAR history, beyond the pale.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Another horrendous call.
comment by _Viva_Vida (U6044)
posted 12 seconds ago
I don’t think it was the correct decision given the laws of the game.
His arm was in a completely natural position and out by his side because he was running. The law states that it needs to be in an ‘unnatural’ position.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I agree. He wasn't even blocking a shot, he was running along side him.
comment by The Process (U20671)
posted 14 seconds ago
comment by Ace (U22467)
posted 7 minutes ago
The worst decision was Kanes goal against Sheffield Utd being ruled out after Moura was fouled and the ball brushed his arm as he hit the ground. They didn’t even give a free kick for the foul, but that aside that was far and away the worst decision in VAR history, beyond the pale.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Another horrendous call.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Correct call according to the rules. Stupid rule though.
Gabriel handles, nothing given.
Bowen is tripped in a fashion that regularly sees teams in red shirts given a penalty, again nothing is given.
Lindelhofs hand albeit accidentily blocked a goalbound effort. Its a pen.
The arsenal handball was nothing similar
comment by Rouge (U19907)
posted 28 seconds ago
Lindelhofs hand albeit accidentily blocked a goalbound effort. Its a pen.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
that's not the rule.
comment by ● Billy The Yidd ● 2020* (U3924)
posted 1 minute ago
Gabriel handles, nothing given.
Bowen is tripped in a fashion that regularly sees teams in red shirts given a penalty, again nothing is given.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Bowen dived having not been touched. The Arsenal player tried to head the ball and it hit his upper arm. He wasn't blocking a shot.
Learn the rules.
comment by There'sOnlyOneRed's (U1721)
posted 2 minutes ago
comment by The Process (U20671)
posted 14 seconds ago
comment by Ace (U22467)
posted 7 minutes ago
The worst decision was Kanes goal against Sheffield Utd being ruled out after Moura was fouled and the ball brushed his arm as he hit the ground. They didn’t even give a free kick for the foul, but that aside that was far and away the worst decision in VAR history, beyond the pale.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Another horrendous call.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Correct call according to the rules. Stupid rule though.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
That’s what I mean. The refs aren’t the problem the rules are.
I’d heard Utd could be 2nd this year
Didn’t realise they meant in every game 😊
comment by There'sOnlyOneRed's (U1721)
posted 47 minutes ago
comment by ● Billy The Yidd ● 2020* (U3924)
posted 1 minute ago
Gabriel handles, nothing given.
Bowen is tripped in a fashion that regularly sees teams in red shirts given a penalty, again nothing is given.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Bowen dived having not been touched. The Arsenal player tried to head the ball and it hit his upper arm. He wasn't blocking a shot.
Learn the rules.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
BS that was a pen all day, I feel sorry for West Ham they were robbed.
comment by Mons (U21799)
posted 1 hour, 51 minutes ago
Ole
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Trying so hard to belong... so many comments yet no one is paying attention, poor lad, here have some
Only just saw it on MOTD and thought both decisions were incredibly harsh. Pen was so little distance and almost looked like De Gea had a foot on the line still. Remarkable they deemed it as a clear and obvious error to be overturned.
Shouldn't be a penalty in my opinion but I was unaware of the rule changes. If the rules state those are now penalties then fair enough, but that is seriously worrying going forward.
United had a few ridiculous decisions go there way at the back end of last season though so don't think you can complain too much about one going against you, however, and not convinced it changed the result today either.
comment by Dr Tobias Fünke (U1217)
posted 9 hours, 41 minutes ago
comment by ● Billy The Yidd ● 2020* (U3924)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by Got_Better (U6241)
posted 6 minutes ago
Both correct decisions and in line with the laws of the game. Your issue is with the law makers not the ref or VAR....and yes, if it happens to liverpool I will be fuming too.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
It happened with Pool last season at Klanfield against City when TAA handled the ball, but Michael Oliverpool (and VAR) ignored it.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Bernardo handled it first.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Var still think that taa didn't handball it. Gallagher confirmed it after. Because if they are both handball any advantage Liverpool had would of been stopped by the taa handball. Meaning fabinho doesn't score.
There needs to be consistency all throughout penalties.
For example lindelof... arm in a natural position and running alongside the defender and hot from about a yard - clearly accidental - penalty given
Pogba running between 2 defenders and accidentally tripped stopping him from getting further forward - penalty not given.... what's the actual difference... neither was clearly intentional
The penalty yesterday was a complete var sh 1tshow. I thought they might be sorting var out but that was fecking farcical.
comment by Blue_mooning (U12093)
posted 4 hours, 40 minutes ago
comment by Dr Tobias Fünke (U1217)
posted 9 hours, 41 minutes ago
comment by ● Billy The Yidd ● 2020* (U3924)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by Got_Better (U6241)
posted 6 minutes ago
Both correct decisions and in line with the laws of the game. Your issue is with the law makers not the ref or VAR....and yes, if it happens to liverpool I will be fuming too.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
It happened with Pool last season at Klanfield against City when TAA handled the ball, but Michael Oliverpool (and VAR) ignored it.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Bernardo handled it first.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Var still think that taa didn't handball it. Gallagher confirmed it after. Because if they are both handball any advantage Liverpool had would of been stopped by the taa handball. Meaning fabinho doesn't score.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
That's the point, none of them were handball according to the rules.
Sign in if you want to comment
2 of the worst decisions I’ve seen
Page 2 of 2
posted on 19/9/20
comment by Tiddles (U17634)
posted 6 minutes ago
I agree the penalty was extremely harsh Process. He is so close to the ball and there’s nothing that he can do to stop it from hitting him.
Completely disagree about the DDG ruling though. You can’t be off the line before the ball is kicked and he was, so must be retaken. Change the rule if you want to but that was the correct decision.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I get that but it’s a dreadful rule that seriously reduced the keepers already slim chance of saving a penalty.
Wasn’t the refs fault. Common sense and referees discretion should be the deciding factor in these circumstances.
Same if the ball it’s an attackers hand in the lead up to the goal.
posted on 19/9/20
comment by Ace (U22467)
posted 7 minutes ago
The worst decision was Kanes goal against Sheffield Utd being ruled out after Moura was fouled and the ball brushed his arm as he hit the ground. They didn’t even give a free kick for the foul, but that aside that was far and away the worst decision in VAR history, beyond the pale.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Another horrendous call.
posted on 19/9/20
comment by _Viva_Vida (U6044)
posted 12 seconds ago
I don’t think it was the correct decision given the laws of the game.
His arm was in a completely natural position and out by his side because he was running. The law states that it needs to be in an ‘unnatural’ position.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I agree. He wasn't even blocking a shot, he was running along side him.
posted on 19/9/20
comment by The Process (U20671)
posted 14 seconds ago
comment by Ace (U22467)
posted 7 minutes ago
The worst decision was Kanes goal against Sheffield Utd being ruled out after Moura was fouled and the ball brushed his arm as he hit the ground. They didn’t even give a free kick for the foul, but that aside that was far and away the worst decision in VAR history, beyond the pale.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Another horrendous call.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Correct call according to the rules. Stupid rule though.
posted on 19/9/20
Ole is at the wheel
posted on 19/9/20
Gabriel handles, nothing given.
Bowen is tripped in a fashion that regularly sees teams in red shirts given a penalty, again nothing is given.
posted on 19/9/20
Lindelhofs hand albeit accidentily blocked a goalbound effort. Its a pen.
The arsenal handball was nothing similar
posted on 19/9/20
Ole is at the wheel
posted on 19/9/20
comment by Rouge (U19907)
posted 28 seconds ago
Lindelhofs hand albeit accidentily blocked a goalbound effort. Its a pen.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
that's not the rule.
posted on 19/9/20
comment by ● Billy The Yidd ● 2020* (U3924)
posted 1 minute ago
Gabriel handles, nothing given.
Bowen is tripped in a fashion that regularly sees teams in red shirts given a penalty, again nothing is given.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Bowen dived having not been touched. The Arsenal player tried to head the ball and it hit his upper arm. He wasn't blocking a shot.
Learn the rules.
posted on 19/9/20
comment by There'sOnlyOneRed's (U1721)
posted 2 minutes ago
comment by The Process (U20671)
posted 14 seconds ago
comment by Ace (U22467)
posted 7 minutes ago
The worst decision was Kanes goal against Sheffield Utd being ruled out after Moura was fouled and the ball brushed his arm as he hit the ground. They didn’t even give a free kick for the foul, but that aside that was far and away the worst decision in VAR history, beyond the pale.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Another horrendous call.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Correct call according to the rules. Stupid rule though.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
That’s what I mean. The refs aren’t the problem the rules are.
posted on 19/9/20
I’d heard Utd could be 2nd this year
Didn’t realise they meant in every game 😊
posted on 19/9/20
posted on 19/9/20
The irony
posted on 19/9/20
comment by There'sOnlyOneRed's (U1721)
posted 47 minutes ago
comment by ● Billy The Yidd ● 2020* (U3924)
posted 1 minute ago
Gabriel handles, nothing given.
Bowen is tripped in a fashion that regularly sees teams in red shirts given a penalty, again nothing is given.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Bowen dived having not been touched. The Arsenal player tried to head the ball and it hit his upper arm. He wasn't blocking a shot.
Learn the rules.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
posted on 19/9/20
Ole
posted on 19/9/20
BS that was a pen all day, I feel sorry for West Ham they were robbed.
posted on 19/9/20
comment by Mons (U21799)
posted 1 hour, 51 minutes ago
Ole
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Trying so hard to belong... so many comments yet no one is paying attention, poor lad, here have some
posted on 19/9/20
Only just saw it on MOTD and thought both decisions were incredibly harsh. Pen was so little distance and almost looked like De Gea had a foot on the line still. Remarkable they deemed it as a clear and obvious error to be overturned.
Shouldn't be a penalty in my opinion but I was unaware of the rule changes. If the rules state those are now penalties then fair enough, but that is seriously worrying going forward.
United had a few ridiculous decisions go there way at the back end of last season though so don't think you can complain too much about one going against you, however, and not convinced it changed the result today either.
posted on 20/9/20
comment by Dr Tobias Fünke (U1217)
posted 9 hours, 41 minutes ago
comment by ● Billy The Yidd ● 2020* (U3924)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by Got_Better (U6241)
posted 6 minutes ago
Both correct decisions and in line with the laws of the game. Your issue is with the law makers not the ref or VAR....and yes, if it happens to liverpool I will be fuming too.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
It happened with Pool last season at Klanfield against City when TAA handled the ball, but Michael Oliverpool (and VAR) ignored it.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Bernardo handled it first.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Var still think that taa didn't handball it. Gallagher confirmed it after. Because if they are both handball any advantage Liverpool had would of been stopped by the taa handball. Meaning fabinho doesn't score.
posted on 20/9/20
There needs to be consistency all throughout penalties.
For example lindelof... arm in a natural position and running alongside the defender and hot from about a yard - clearly accidental - penalty given
Pogba running between 2 defenders and accidentally tripped stopping him from getting further forward - penalty not given.... what's the actual difference... neither was clearly intentional
posted on 20/9/20
The penalty yesterday was a complete var sh 1tshow. I thought they might be sorting var out but that was fecking farcical.
posted on 20/9/20
comment by Blue_mooning (U12093)
posted 4 hours, 40 minutes ago
comment by Dr Tobias Fünke (U1217)
posted 9 hours, 41 minutes ago
comment by ● Billy The Yidd ● 2020* (U3924)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by Got_Better (U6241)
posted 6 minutes ago
Both correct decisions and in line with the laws of the game. Your issue is with the law makers not the ref or VAR....and yes, if it happens to liverpool I will be fuming too.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
It happened with Pool last season at Klanfield against City when TAA handled the ball, but Michael Oliverpool (and VAR) ignored it.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Bernardo handled it first.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Var still think that taa didn't handball it. Gallagher confirmed it after. Because if they are both handball any advantage Liverpool had would of been stopped by the taa handball. Meaning fabinho doesn't score.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
That's the point, none of them were handball according to the rules.
Page 2 of 2