Very unfortunate, feel for Harvey Elliott but this is a legitimate tackle and sadly he got hurt. Both feet leave the ground, it happens when you run. Cooper makes exactly the same challenge later…should he be sent off for dangerous play?
this is a legitimate tackle
====
It simply isn't. It is the very definition of serious foul play.
https://youtu.be/mV9-BzaXlsU
https://youtu.be/BxG6OaQUCgI
Well these were far worse on Ronaldo in the past and no red card was given.
This was also not given as a red card when far worse on Greenwood. That was the same season in reverse fixture Greenwood was lamped inside the box and no penalty was given in Southmapton away game so 4 points dropped due to poor refs. This season again 2 points dropped to Southamptob as refs think shoving Bruno out the way while kicking his legs is legal lol. It was the worst foul of the whole game and the goal stood.
https://youtu.be/iY2ApmKFfjI
https://youtu.be/qmTyPd5oqqg
Ronaldo doesn’t get anywhere near a player= red card while someone cleans him out= no red card.
Wonder if Harry kane will be sending his best wishes
Clearly tackling Elliot from behind, which is outlawed because of the risk of serious injury. You see defenders allowing runners to run if their run cuts across them, because a tackle is mostly a foul and a card most times. Red card because of damage caused this time.
Total freak accident. Cooper did exactly the same thing to Mane I think it was yet Mane was absolutely fine like 99% of players tackled like that.
Feel terrible for the young lad but it's a contact sport, and it was a physical game, 100 mph. A tough tackle but not a red, ref let the game flow.
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
Fwiw I thought VVD was class, going over to the Leeds player to empathise.
comment by Hector (U3606)
posted 11 minutes ago
Fwiw I thought VVD was class, going over to the Leeds player to empathise.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Yep much classier than LFC fans on here
comment by CFC: Quad stoppers (U20729)
posted 43 seconds ago
comment by Hector (U3606)
posted 11 minutes ago
Fwiw I thought VVD was class, going over to the Leeds player to empathise.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Yep much classier than LFC fans on here
----------------------------------------------------------------------
How so?
Not blaming and judging
Most important thing is talented player gets well.
He looked good v the champions of Europe
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
comment by Ace (U22467)
posted 11 minutes ago
Also OP, have you shared that image from your own google drive - Glenn/glenghis? Maybe a coincidence but if so you may want to remove for the sake of anonymity.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Noticed the same. DJ will love this.
It was a tackle from behind, both feet off the ground, and at pace.
His trailing foot wiped Elliott out.so clearly 2 footed.
I can see why it was given as a red but wouldn’t have thrown a tantrum if it wasn’t.
Comment deleted by Article Creator
Two footed tackle in football, an illegal tackle in which a player jumps or slides forwards with both legs stretched towards an opposing player
Comment deleted by Article Creator
Comment deleted by Article Creator
Comment deleted by Article Creator
comment by Ace (U22467)
posted 26 minutes ago
It wasn’t a red. The ref allowed play to continue in Leeds favour and only blew up when Salah became hysterics, and only sent him off when he saw it was a bad injury. Moments later Cooper made an identical tackle on Mane which won the ball, I didn’t hear anyone calling for a red there. Tackles like that are made every game and don’t result in red cards
-----
Tackles like that aren't made evey game and if they are then the ref punishes them most times. Anyone got a clip of this other tackle on Mane? They keep saying it's similar but I reckon you'll find its nowhere near the same.
Comment deleted by Article Creator
Definite red card. It was made from behind, so would definitely need to go through the player to get any of the ball.
Secondly was a lunge, it wasn’t as if he was standing while he made it, ie the full weight of Struijk and the forward momentum carried through the challenge. This is dangerous play.
This is why this kind of challenge should be outlawed, the player making that challenge is out of control as once airborne cannot pull out of the challenge or reduce its impact.
Look at Elliots ankle yes, but also see that Struijk is making it from behind. The fact that it can have a huge injury result from it means this kind of challenge is correctly viewed as a red card.
It wasn’t how Elliott landed either, it’s the full weight of Struijk on that ankle.
https://imgur.com/a/HaAmn9B
Sign in if you want to comment
Definitely red card
Page 1 of 3
posted on 13/9/21
It was not a red
posted on 13/9/21
Very unfortunate, feel for Harvey Elliott but this is a legitimate tackle and sadly he got hurt. Both feet leave the ground, it happens when you run. Cooper makes exactly the same challenge later…should he be sent off for dangerous play?
posted on 13/9/21
this is a legitimate tackle
====
It simply isn't. It is the very definition of serious foul play.
posted on 13/9/21
https://youtu.be/mV9-BzaXlsU
https://youtu.be/BxG6OaQUCgI
Well these were far worse on Ronaldo in the past and no red card was given.
This was also not given as a red card when far worse on Greenwood. That was the same season in reverse fixture Greenwood was lamped inside the box and no penalty was given in Southmapton away game so 4 points dropped due to poor refs. This season again 2 points dropped to Southamptob as refs think shoving Bruno out the way while kicking his legs is legal lol. It was the worst foul of the whole game and the goal stood.
https://youtu.be/iY2ApmKFfjI
posted on 13/9/21
https://youtu.be/qmTyPd5oqqg
Ronaldo doesn’t get anywhere near a player= red card while someone cleans him out= no red card.
posted on 13/9/21
Wonder if Harry kane will be sending his best wishes
posted on 13/9/21
Clearly tackling Elliot from behind, which is outlawed because of the risk of serious injury. You see defenders allowing runners to run if their run cuts across them, because a tackle is mostly a foul and a card most times. Red card because of damage caused this time.
posted on 13/9/21
Total freak accident. Cooper did exactly the same thing to Mane I think it was yet Mane was absolutely fine like 99% of players tackled like that.
posted on 13/9/21
Feel terrible for the young lad but it's a contact sport, and it was a physical game, 100 mph. A tough tackle but not a red, ref let the game flow.
posted on 13/9/21
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 13/9/21
Fwiw I thought VVD was class, going over to the Leeds player to empathise.
posted on 13/9/21
comment by Hector (U3606)
posted 11 minutes ago
Fwiw I thought VVD was class, going over to the Leeds player to empathise.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Yep much classier than LFC fans on here
posted on 13/9/21
comment by CFC: Quad stoppers (U20729)
posted 43 seconds ago
comment by Hector (U3606)
posted 11 minutes ago
Fwiw I thought VVD was class, going over to the Leeds player to empathise.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Yep much classier than LFC fans on here
----------------------------------------------------------------------
How so?
posted on 13/9/21
Not blaming and judging
Most important thing is talented player gets well.
He looked good v the champions of Europe
posted on 13/9/21
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 13/9/21
comment by Ace (U22467)
posted 11 minutes ago
Also OP, have you shared that image from your own google drive - Glenn/glenghis? Maybe a coincidence but if so you may want to remove for the sake of anonymity.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Noticed the same. DJ will love this.
posted on 13/9/21
It was a tackle from behind, both feet off the ground, and at pace.
His trailing foot wiped Elliott out.so clearly 2 footed.
I can see why it was given as a red but wouldn’t have thrown a tantrum if it wasn’t.
posted on 13/9/21
Comment deleted by Article Creator
posted on 13/9/21
Two footed tackle in football, an illegal tackle in which a player jumps or slides forwards with both legs stretched towards an opposing player
posted on 13/9/21
Comment deleted by Article Creator
posted on 13/9/21
Comment deleted by Article Creator
posted on 13/9/21
Comment deleted by Article Creator
posted on 13/9/21
comment by Ace (U22467)
posted 26 minutes ago
It wasn’t a red. The ref allowed play to continue in Leeds favour and only blew up when Salah became hysterics, and only sent him off when he saw it was a bad injury. Moments later Cooper made an identical tackle on Mane which won the ball, I didn’t hear anyone calling for a red there. Tackles like that are made every game and don’t result in red cards
-----
Tackles like that aren't made evey game and if they are then the ref punishes them most times. Anyone got a clip of this other tackle on Mane? They keep saying it's similar but I reckon you'll find its nowhere near the same.
posted on 13/9/21
Comment deleted by Article Creator
posted on 13/9/21
Definite red card. It was made from behind, so would definitely need to go through the player to get any of the ball.
Secondly was a lunge, it wasn’t as if he was standing while he made it, ie the full weight of Struijk and the forward momentum carried through the challenge. This is dangerous play.
This is why this kind of challenge should be outlawed, the player making that challenge is out of control as once airborne cannot pull out of the challenge or reduce its impact.
Look at Elliots ankle yes, but also see that Struijk is making it from behind. The fact that it can have a huge injury result from it means this kind of challenge is correctly viewed as a red card.
It wasn’t how Elliott landed either, it’s the full weight of Struijk on that ankle.
https://imgur.com/a/HaAmn9B
Page 1 of 3