Maguire is, for sure. Needs to be fit.
Fred can play a bit, especially in the right system, but shouldn't start for a club with Utds ambition.
The other two are not CL standard.
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
McTominay doesn’t even start for Scotland FFS
Shaw was the biggest issue today. How is Salah left free 3/4 times at the back post?
Either him or Rashford not tracking back.
comment by Busby (U19985)
posted 32 seconds ago
Shaw was the biggest issue today. How is Salah left free 3/4 times at the back post?
Either him or Rashford not tracking back.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Shaw is massively overrated.
Gets caught out defensively far too much, Mourinho wasn't wrong about that.
Shaw can’t just stand on Salah when the midfield and the CBs are out of position and not getting anywhere near the ball.
I'd keep Fred. Doesn't have the elite quality but like Lingard he works hard and can be a good squad player if we had a crap together
McTominay, Wan Bissaka, Maguire - these are not even good to have around as squad players. They need to be moved on. ASAP
I'd keep Fred. Doesn't have the elite quality but like Lingard he works hard and can be a good squad player if we had a crap together
—————
Erm, what?
Maguire is terrible.
Slow, clumsy, poor positionally.
Forget the fee we paid. Needs to be sold and thr decencr be rebuilt
comment by Lurker (U21432)
posted 36 seconds ago
our crap together^^
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I think Fred is the worst, all he does is run about like a headless chicken.
McTominay isn’t up to much, stands out in the Scotland team as a weak link which should tell you all you need to know. He’s lucky he’s a unit or he would never play.
Wan-Bissaka is average but possibly good enough for second choice. Maguire is decent at his best
Let's not forget about Luke Shaw either. He's been diabolical in most of our matches this season including today.
comment by The Lambeau Leap (U21050)
posted 52 minutes ago
McTominay doesn’t even start for Scotland FFS
----------------------------------------------------------------------
You’ve got the wrong Scottish player. You need Gilmour!
Cresswell is twice the player Shaw will ever be
Shaw <<<<<<<<<<<< Robbo
Only the deluded would have it any other way and based on international performances which are not representative.
comment by Silver (U6112)
posted 2 minutes ago
Shaw <<<<<<<<<<<< Robbo
Only the deluded would have it any other way and based on international performances which are not representative.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Yes they're a different level. Shaw is a decent premier league left back.
Robertson is a world class left back. Shaw makes the odd decent run, and shoulder barges someone over and people scream world class.
comment by Silver (U6112)
posted 3 minutes ago
Only the deluded would have it any other way and based on international performances which are not representative.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
still droning on about this? not enough credit being given to the poor wee scotsman?
and the "deluded" presumably includes the pl players, who voted shaw into the team of the year last season?
Just keep buying more players fellas 🤣
comment by Don Draper's dandruff (U20155)
posted 25 minutes ago
comment by Silver (U6112)
posted 3 minutes ago
Only the deluded would have it any other way and based on international performances which are not representative.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
still droning on about this? not enough credit being given to the poor wee scotsman?
and the "deluded" presumably includes the pl players, who voted shaw into the team of the year last season?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
disappointed you didn't use scotchman tbh
Shaw was like he won his place in a raffle today. Unexpectedly bad but the blinkered will not see.
Page 1 of 1
First
Previous
1
Next
Latest
Sign in if you want to comment
Fred AWB McT Maguire
Page 1 of 1
posted on 24/10/21
Maguire is, for sure. Needs to be fit.
Fred can play a bit, especially in the right system, but shouldn't start for a club with Utds ambition.
The other two are not CL standard.
posted on 24/10/21
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 24/10/21
McTominay doesn’t even start for Scotland FFS
posted on 24/10/21
Shaw was the biggest issue today. How is Salah left free 3/4 times at the back post?
Either him or Rashford not tracking back.
posted on 24/10/21
comment by Busby (U19985)
posted 32 seconds ago
Shaw was the biggest issue today. How is Salah left free 3/4 times at the back post?
Either him or Rashford not tracking back.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Shaw is massively overrated.
Gets caught out defensively far too much, Mourinho wasn't wrong about that.
posted on 24/10/21
Shaw can’t just stand on Salah when the midfield and the CBs are out of position and not getting anywhere near the ball.
posted on 24/10/21
Maguire for sure.
posted on 24/10/21
I'd keep Fred. Doesn't have the elite quality but like Lingard he works hard and can be a good squad player if we had a crap together
McTominay, Wan Bissaka, Maguire - these are not even good to have around as squad players. They need to be moved on. ASAP
posted on 24/10/21
our crap together^^
posted on 24/10/21
I'd keep Fred. Doesn't have the elite quality but like Lingard he works hard and can be a good squad player if we had a crap together
—————
Erm, what?
posted on 24/10/21
Maguire is terrible.
Slow, clumsy, poor positionally.
Forget the fee we paid. Needs to be sold and thr decencr be rebuilt
posted on 24/10/21
comment by Lurker (U21432)
posted 36 seconds ago
our crap together^^
----------------------------------------------------------------------
posted on 24/10/21
I think Fred is the worst, all he does is run about like a headless chicken.
McTominay isn’t up to much, stands out in the Scotland team as a weak link which should tell you all you need to know. He’s lucky he’s a unit or he would never play.
Wan-Bissaka is average but possibly good enough for second choice. Maguire is decent at his best
posted on 24/10/21
No but Ole going to Ole.
posted on 24/10/21
Fred is woeful
posted on 24/10/21
Let's not forget about Luke Shaw either. He's been diabolical in most of our matches this season including today.
posted on 24/10/21
comment by The Lambeau Leap (U21050)
posted 52 minutes ago
McTominay doesn’t even start for Scotland FFS
----------------------------------------------------------------------
You’ve got the wrong Scottish player. You need Gilmour!
posted on 24/10/21
Cresswell is twice the player Shaw will ever be
posted on 24/10/21
Shaw <<<<<<<<<<<< Robbo
Only the deluded would have it any other way and based on international performances which are not representative.
posted on 24/10/21
comment by Silver (U6112)
posted 2 minutes ago
Shaw <<<<<<<<<<<< Robbo
Only the deluded would have it any other way and based on international performances which are not representative.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Yes they're a different level. Shaw is a decent premier league left back.
Robertson is a world class left back. Shaw makes the odd decent run, and shoulder barges someone over and people scream world class.
posted on 24/10/21
comment by Silver (U6112)
posted 3 minutes ago
Only the deluded would have it any other way and based on international performances which are not representative.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
still droning on about this? not enough credit being given to the poor wee scotsman?
and the "deluded" presumably includes the pl players, who voted shaw into the team of the year last season?
posted on 24/10/21
Just keep buying more players fellas 🤣
posted on 24/10/21
comment by Don Draper's dandruff (U20155)
posted 25 minutes ago
comment by Silver (U6112)
posted 3 minutes ago
Only the deluded would have it any other way and based on international performances which are not representative.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
still droning on about this? not enough credit being given to the poor wee scotsman?
and the "deluded" presumably includes the pl players, who voted shaw into the team of the year last season?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
disappointed you didn't use scotchman tbh
Shaw was like he won his place in a raffle today. Unexpectedly bad but the blinkered will not see.
Page 1 of 1