or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 1070062 comments are related to an article called:

Good News

Page 41802 of 42803

comment by Phenom (U20037)

posted on 19/9/21

45mins enjoyed

45mins we bent over

posted on 19/9/21

Meh.

F*cking plastics.

posted on 19/9/21

US is terribly terrible for drink driving

I thought today was alright

comment by Blarmy (U14547)

posted on 19/9/21

Dont take this the wrong way - cause ive said before I have issue with Alonso and the 'justice' he faced

But is there a moral difference between him and Merson who got drunk enough to pass out driving and crashed into a lorry on a motorway?

posted on 19/9/21

I won’t ever take something like that the wrong way

It’s a good question - in essence they are the same but the outcome does unfortunately differentiate the situation

comment by Blarmy (U14547)

posted on 19/9/21

The actual differences are - Alonso had passengers and was speeding

But Merson was more intoxicated and if you are passing out on the motorway its just pure luck that no one gets badly hurt or worse

posted on 19/9/21

I think had Alonso done just time I wouldn’t begrudge him a playing career after (which obvs wouldn’t have happened)

comment by Blarmy (U14547)

posted on 19/9/21

comment by Edinspur (U1109)
posted 2 minutes ago
I won’t ever take something like that the wrong way

It’s a good question - in essence they are the same but the outcome does unfortunately differentiate the situation
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Legally yes, morally im not sure

comment by Blarmy (U14547)

posted on 19/9/21

Merson's is more tolerated because it came with a pattern of alcohol abuse and addiction too

comment by Blarmy (U14547)

posted on 19/9/21

No one hates Gazza or Best either for being drunk drivers. They sympathise with their issues moreso

posted on 19/9/21

I think so morally, I’m sure you’ve once in your life gone stupidly over the speed limit (think the highest I ever hit was 100mph in the USA).

However killing a passenger going at 90 is morally worse in my opinion.

posted on 19/9/21

I think Gazza gets a lot of apologists somewhat disappointingly.

comment by Blarmy (U14547)

posted on 19/9/21

Lee Hughes didnt have passengers, he would be the same level as Merson then

comment by Blarmy (U14547)

posted on 19/9/21

My cousin got into a crash going a little bit over the speed limit with his 2 year old son in the back. No one got hurt but I dont think he's ever forgiven himself for the incident

posted on 19/9/21

Personally I think outcome plays a factor morally

comment by Blarmy (U14547)

posted on 19/9/21

I really dont understand your thinking there as there is no control over the outcome from the perpetrator

They all got behind a wheel while too drunk to drive, where was the moral choice that affects the outcome that separates them?

comment by Blarmy (U14547)

posted on 19/9/21

Form a societal perspective i can see that justice has to be done for the victims. But from the individual perspective of the criminal i dont see a moral difference in cases here

posted on 19/9/21

I’m not sure I can argue my stance well at all tbf as it isn’t logical but I just think outcome plays such a huge factor in the morales of certain situations

posted on 19/9/21

Maybe it’s because in my mind outcome changes the risk profile of the situation

posted on 19/9/21

A lot of out come bias after today’s game as well

posted on 19/9/21

It's about nuance isn't it? Obviously anyone getting behind the wheel drunk is in the wrong, but each case is different. Alonso was doing 70 in a 30 limit in the rain with a car full of people. I definitely think that's worse than going out on your own and crashing on a motorway.

I mean, drunk or not 70 in a 30 is facking outrageous.

comment by Blarmy (U14547)

posted on 19/9/21

I actually view the motorway as the more dangerous place to be drunk driving but i see that point on the speed

posted on 19/9/21

I used to know someone that got banned for doing over 100 in a 30. Moaned about the ban, too. He was lucky he didn't kill someone. Caant

comment by Blarmy (U14547)

posted on 19/9/21

Its an unfortunate part of the Alonso one as well that the victim wasnt wearing a seat belt

posted on 19/9/21

comment by Blarmy (U14547)
posted less than a minute ago
I actually view the motorway as the more dangerous place to be drunk driving but i see that point on the speed
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Maybe? Again, it's situation dependent. At night after the pin when it's likely quiet you're more likely to kill yourself. In town there's pedestrians and walls to hit..

Page 41802 of 42803

Sign in if you want to comment