Stokes.. Just like O'Dea is with Leeds,Jos is doing well

Charlie, have you seen both of them actually play though? Wouldn't take O'Dea back no matter what to be honest but I always had a soft spot for Hoovield as I feel he was never given a proper chance and was very unlucky with injuries. Lenny should have also told him, and many other Celtic players to be fair, to shut the hell up and stop boasting to the press about how good we are!

Anyway, would you have any of them back?

Be fair a have only watched Jos twice for southampton.. A would take O'Dea back just now,he's better than the CB'S we have

He had a bit of a shaky start, at fault for a goal, some wayward passes etc but the injury to the man ahead of him in the pecking order has given Jos a run in the team and he has looked stronger and stronger as the games have gone by, been man of the match in a couple.

He has not been mouthy in interviews so maybe his time at Celtic and being sent out on loan again has done him good. He is staying with one of our other new players and seems to have settled in really well (lots of banter on their Twitter pages), fans are hoping his loan will turn into a permanent move in January, don't know what you think about that?

I reckon we'll sign him. Celtic need some money

Hope Lennon does not get sacked until February.
Fingers crossed, lets face it, its in the post.