is the charity shield a competitive gane
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
comment by just plain old Dunc (U11713)
posted 2 minutes ago
is the charity shield a competitive gane
----------------------------------------------------------------------
no
The Charity Shield isn't and never will be a competitive match, it's a glorified friendly with a trophy at the end. Always nice to win though.
I wouldn't consider it a competitive game but according to Wiki only in England is this fixture seen as a friendly.
Other countries see it as major silverware.
comment by manutd1982 (U6633)
posted 1 minute ago
The Charity Shield isn't and never will be a competitive match, it's a glorified friendly with a trophy at the end. Always nice to win though.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
It's a trophy if you win it and a meaningless game if you lose IMO.
It's a 100 year old competition isn't it? It's pretty meaningful imo.
Where does it say that on wiki? The fact Italy play theirs in China shows how little they think of it. It's at the start of the season, teams aren't fully fit, it can't really ever mean much.
According to the united site it is.
Arab
It has history but it isn't that meaningful, hence why it's called the charity/community shield. It's a bit of fun. And it's memorable moments in time aren't great games or real quality, it's more trivial stuff like Keegan and Bremner getting set off.
Slm not.according to the United site. In fact no one has scored in their first three games for about 30 years.
Hull will be tricky if we are not on it this weekend
"The Zlatan" shall be his title.
The community shield vs city a few years ago wasn't a 'nothing match' at all.
Page 1 of 1
First
Previous
1
Next
Latest
Sign in if you want to comment
The Zlatan
Page 1 of 1
posted on 24/8/16
is the charity shield a competitive gane
posted on 24/8/16
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 24/8/16
comment by just plain old Dunc (U11713)
posted 2 minutes ago
is the charity shield a competitive gane
----------------------------------------------------------------------
no
posted on 24/8/16
The Charity Shield isn't and never will be a competitive match, it's a glorified friendly with a trophy at the end. Always nice to win though.
posted on 24/8/16
I wouldn't consider it a competitive game but according to Wiki only in England is this fixture seen as a friendly.
Other countries see it as major silverware.
posted on 24/8/16
comment by manutd1982 (U6633)
posted 1 minute ago
The Charity Shield isn't and never will be a competitive match, it's a glorified friendly with a trophy at the end. Always nice to win though.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
It's a trophy if you win it and a meaningless game if you lose IMO.
posted on 24/8/16
It's a 100 year old competition isn't it? It's pretty meaningful imo.
posted on 24/8/16
Didn't RvN do this?
posted on 24/8/16
Where does it say that on wiki? The fact Italy play theirs in China shows how little they think of it. It's at the start of the season, teams aren't fully fit, it can't really ever mean much.
posted on 24/8/16
According to the united site it is.
posted on 24/8/16
Arab
It has history but it isn't that meaningful, hence why it's called the charity/community shield. It's a bit of fun. And it's memorable moments in time aren't great games or real quality, it's more trivial stuff like Keegan and Bremner getting set off.
posted on 24/8/16
Slm not.according to the United site. In fact no one has scored in their first three games for about 30 years.
posted on 24/8/16
Hull will be tricky if we are not on it this weekend
posted on 24/8/16
"The Zlatan" shall be his title.
posted on 24/8/16
The community shield vs city a few years ago wasn't a 'nothing match' at all.
Page 1 of 1