I think it's about time Downing started warming the bench, he has been atrocious, I'd rather see any of our talented youngsters start ahead of him! Suso or Sterling would be prime examples.

Downing badly needs a goal though, maybe he will finally get one against L1 opposition.

In an ideal world I would bench him, but he is the only winger we have, and simply has to start at least while Carroll is in the team.

Downing is the sort of player than can be rubbish for a couple of months and then be excellent for a couple of months. Hopefully the tide is about to turn, otherwise he is in danger of being washed away.

Reina
Johnson Carra Coates Robinson
Maxi Adam Henderson Downing
Kuyt Carroll

I'd start Kelly vs City in Carling cup vs City..

Isn't Robinson still injured? Or is he fit now?

-------------------Reina-----------------
Kelly---Carra--------Coates--Aurelio
Johnson--Gerrard----Shelvey---Sterling
------------Maxi---------Kuyt--------

Youth and experience, perfect mix.