or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 68 comments are related to an article called:

The Y Word:Update

Page 2 of 3

posted on 4/10/13

I can't see how they're going to enforce it.

Are they going to arrest the entire Park Lane end? Even with the strict warnings before the Cheslea game, the whole South Lower, Upper and the shelf were singing in.

Not one person was arrested.

comment by GOODBYE (U1029)

posted on 4/10/13

Roman is Jewish

David Gold half Jewish

posted on 4/10/13

"Imagine the uproar if they arrest someone who's Jewish?"

That is the one we want.
Once that happens, the fans have a cause celebre and the whole thing is dead. The yellow star IMHO just adds to the persecution aspect the fans are feeling (and just like in the 1930s emphasises how a minority of rabid b-a-s-t-a-r-ds can deflect the true issue) .

comment by GOODBYE (U1029)

posted on 4/10/13

Doovde

As far as I've read they will speak with people and warn them and tell them what they're singing is wrong, and educated them, then if it happens again arrests will happen?

posted on 4/10/13

"I can't see how they're going to enforce it."

Like statistics, they are going to do a "population sample" .
The fans have to correspondingly cook the books to ensure that of the small sample, Plod picks up as many Jewish supporters as possible.

posted on 4/10/13

"As far as I've read they will speak with people and warn them and tell them what they're singing is wrong, and educated them"

"educate" them ??
About what ?? About the origins and history of the songs ??
And if the people are Jewish : about the connotations of the word ??

...

comment by GOODBYE (U1029)

posted on 4/10/13

RD I'm just passing the message pal

I think it's got out of hand now

comment by Jay. (U16498)

posted on 4/10/13

Will fans need to actually provide evidence that they're Jewish? fack me we will go back to wearing Jewish star's during games

---

I think they will just need to drop their kegs when questioned.

In all honesty though, it is fecking ridiculous. Why, after you've been singing it for as long as anyone can remember, is it now suddenly an issue?

Why is the SOBL getting offended on behalf of the Jews? I mean, you could understand if you were calling people Jewish s or something similar, but I doubt most Jews, especially those associated with your club, see it as an insult.

The SOBL should just fúck off

comment by Jay. (U16498)

posted on 4/10/13

"As far as I've read they will speak with people and warn them and tell them what they're singing is wrong, and educated them"

---

Educating football fans, because that is going to work

comment by GOODBYE (U1029)

posted on 4/10/13

I did listen to Baddiel on Talksport and he made some good points, he said he didn't want to outlaw the word just raise awareness, (the same Baddiel who did this... http://s3.thejournal.ie/media/2013/05/lee2.jpg )

But what he's done is 10x worse!

I understand that the songs against us based on the fact we adopted the word, but it's now out of control

posted on 4/10/13

"I think it's got out of hand now"

Yes, but the supporters now have the chance to decisively put this one to death. It also would give some answers on the match day demographic (how many Jewish Spurs supporters are usually at WHL singing along etc) .

comment by GOODBYE (U1029)

posted on 4/10/13

What's your honest thoughts RD?

posted on 4/10/13

I think it's personal choice. I used to sing it, probably wouldn't these days.. certainly doesn't offend me

comment by (U9213)

posted on 4/10/13

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 4/10/13

I grew up as a Spurs supporter when the songs started.
I am fully aware of the history and rationale.
A rationale that s like Baddiel fully refuse to acknowledge (because it doesn't fit their agenda) .

I think the songs should stop, not because of offence but because I consider the original battle to be long won.

I expect Plod to be ACTUALLY making 100x arrests of /Chelsky vermin who do the nastiness as those Spurs supporters who are being threatened with arrest for their songs.

comment by GOODBYE (U1029)

posted on 4/10/13

No personal insults 4th

Stay on topic

comment by (U9213)

posted on 4/10/13

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

comment by GOODBYE (U1029)

posted on 4/10/13

RD

Well put

comment by GOODBYE (U1029)

posted on 4/10/13

4th

I know it was probably Galv influenced, but it's cool

posted on 4/10/13

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 4/10/13

The Romford Racist Raptor hath spoken. And been Recordered.

comment by GOODBYE (U1029)

posted on 4/10/13

Rapt, to jail you go

posted on 4/10/13

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

comment by GOODBYE (U1029)

posted on 4/10/13

Just spreading the word Rap, don't shoot the messenger

posted on 4/10/13

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

Page 2 of 3

Sign in if you want to comment