comment by Hengy (U9129)
posted 13 minutes ago
Mando 3 wasn’t average
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Yeh, you’re right.. wasn’t average at all.
Fecking bantha fodder is what it is
comment by Hengy (U9129)
posted 30 minutes ago
Mando 3 wasn’t average
----------------------------------------------------------------------
it was average at best season 3 was about 5/10.
Ahsoka has been decent ... not much more for me than that tbh. hovering around the 6/10-7/10 mark above average but far from great.
comment by Hengy (U9129)
posted 8 seconds ago
5 lol
----------------------------------------------------------------------
it was average .... 5/10 is average, slap bang in the middle.
OB1 was about a 3/10, 4 on a good day it was pretty poor.
BoB was 4/10 also not as bad as OB1 but both below average.
comment by Taki Minamino (U20650)
posted 32 seconds ago
dave failoni
----------------------------------------------------------------------
wouldnt quite say that.
Mando season 1 & 2 was right up there for me, that had me just as much as the original films did. I gave them 8-9/10.
I have seen CW but by all accounts its pretty damn good.
Ahoska is ok I certianly dont hate it. There is some big flaws however IMO.
I think its a very poor decision to make CW/Rebels not sure which almost mandatory watching if you want to know what is going on. Iv had to read up separate material in order for it to make sense to me.
If this was a complete casual watching it on the back of Mandalorian Im guessing they dont have a clue what going on!!!
comment by whodunnit (U22710)
posted 1 hour, 20 minutes ago
comment by Taki Minamino (U20650)
posted 32 seconds ago
dave failoni
----------------------------------------------------------------------
wouldnt quite say that.
Mando season 1 & 2 was right up there for me, that had me just as much as the original films did. I gave them 8-9/10.
I have seen CW but by all accounts its pretty damn good.
Ahoska is ok I certianly dont hate it. There is some big flaws however IMO.
I think its a very poor decision to make CW/Rebels not sure which almost mandatory watching if you want to know what is going on. Iv had to read up separate material in order for it to make sense to me.
If this was a complete casual watching it on the back of Mandalorian Im guessing they dont have a clue what going on!!!
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Unfortunately this is true… my mates don’t have a clue who’s who, and don’t know why I was excited to see the Night Sisters… it’s been hard to explain.
And they won’t watch CW or Rebels.
Which has been said, these 2 animated shows, are essential viewing.
comment by StringerBell (U11749)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by whodunnit (U22710)
posted 1 hour, 20 minutes ago
comment by Taki Minamino (U20650)
posted 32 seconds ago
dave failoni
----------------------------------------------------------------------
wouldnt quite say that.
Mando season 1 & 2 was right up there for me, that had me just as much as the original films did. I gave them 8-9/10.
I have seen CW but by all accounts its pretty damn good.
Ahoska is ok I certianly dont hate it. There is some big flaws however IMO.
I think its a very poor decision to make CW/Rebels not sure which almost mandatory watching if you want to know what is going on. Iv had to read up separate material in order for it to make sense to me.
If this was a complete casual watching it on the back of Mandalorian Im guessing they dont have a clue what going on!!!
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Unfortunately this is true… my mates don’t have a clue who’s who, and don’t know why I was excited to see the Night Sisters… it’s been hard to explain.
And they won’t watch CW or Rebels.
Which has been said, these 2 animated shows, are essential viewing.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
yeah it really should have been made more clear its more a continuation of a different show. Thankfully the with stuff I out 2 and 2 together its not to hard to work out.
but space whales, the witches, Thrawn etc none of this has ever really been even referenced before (other than mando season 3) in any other SW show or film I have seen or if it was it was very subtly hinted at Im sure.
They defo appeared in the who as if you should already be aware of who they are and what they are about.
Same goes with Thrawn, as of yet to the average casual he is nothing more than another Imperial Officer.
They most probably think he’s Cad Banes brother or something, Red Eyes, Blue skin….
But Disney/LucasFilm boxed themselves into a corner, and in fear of losing viewership, they tried to say, nah, you don’t have to watch, well, maybe season 4 of Rebels….oh really, Nah Fam. That won’t fly…
I’m conflicted on my rating… the SW fan in me wants to boost the rating to 7.5.
As I said, the SW stuff is like a warm blanket… but then, I mean Sabine & Ezra.. I dunno…
But it’s safe to say, this show is miles better than Mando 3 and Kenobi and BoBF.
It’s defo in the good books… think I’ll end up giving the series an overall 8/10.
comment by StringerBell (U11749)
posted 3 minutes ago
I’m conflicted on my rating… the SW fan in me wants to boost the rating to 7.5.
As I said, the SW stuff is like a warm blanket… but then, I mean Sabine & Ezra.. I dunno…
But it’s safe to say, this show is miles better than Mando 3 and Kenobi and BoBF.
It’s defo in the good books… think I’ll end up giving the series an overall 8/10.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
8 is far to high for me..... to me that means its very very good, close to being amazing (9) which it isnt for me.
its decent for me so far, granted Im coming at this from a position of not watching CW/Rebels
comment by D'Jeezus Mackaroni (U1137)
posted 6 minutes ago
Solid 4/10
----------------------------------------------------------------------
get out of it you….
comment by Hengy (U9129)
posted 4 hours, 55 minutes ago
Mando 3 wasn’t average
----------------------------------------------------------------------
It certainly wasn't good. An easy 5 or 6/10.
can they do an anakin series while hes still young enough?
comment by Taki Minamino (U20650)
posted 27 minutes ago
can they do an anakin series while hes still young enough?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I would love an Anakin CW series.
comment by whodunnit (U22710)
posted 1 hour ago
comment by StringerBell (U11749)
posted 3 minutes ago
I’m conflicted on my rating… the SW fan in me wants to boost the rating to 7.5.
As I said, the SW stuff is like a warm blanket… but then, I mean Sabine & Ezra.. I dunno…
But it’s safe to say, this show is miles better than Mando 3 and Kenobi and BoBF.
It’s defo in the good books… think I’ll end up giving the series an overall 8/10.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
8 is far to high for me..... to me that means its very very good, close to being amazing (9) which it isnt for me.
its decent for me so far, granted Im coming at this from a position of not watching CW/Rebels
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I agree, it's not an 8 for me.
I think a 7 seems accurate.
comment by The Guvnor XI -Iron sharpens Iron- (U12889)
posted 4 minutes ago
comment by whodunnit (U22710)
posted 1 hour ago
comment by StringerBell (U11749)
posted 3 minutes ago
I’m conflicted on my rating… the SW fan in me wants to boost the rating to 7.5.
As I said, the SW stuff is like a warm blanket… but then, I mean Sabine & Ezra.. I dunno…
But it’s safe to say, this show is miles better than Mando 3 and Kenobi and BoBF.
It’s defo in the good books… think I’ll end up giving the series an overall 8/10.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
8 is far to high for me..... to me that means its very very good, close to being amazing (9) which it isnt for me.
its decent for me so far, granted Im coming at this from a position of not watching CW/Rebels
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I agree, it's not an 8 for me.
I think a 7 seems accurate.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I have to give it a 6 I think.... granted that would prob increase if I was up to date with the background material.
its above average but filling in the gaps means I need to drop it a point.
I would imagine there is a lot more answers for you guys and nostalgia being addressed from CW and Rebels.
comment by whodunnit (U22710)
posted 19 minutes ago
comment by The Guvnor XI -Iron sharpens Iron- (U12889)
posted 4 minutes ago
comment by whodunnit (U22710)
posted 1 hour ago
comment by StringerBell (U11749)
posted 3 minutes ago
I’m conflicted on my rating… the SW fan in me wants to boost the rating to 7.5.
As I said, the SW stuff is like a warm blanket… but then, I mean Sabine & Ezra.. I dunno…
But it’s safe to say, this show is miles better than Mando 3 and Kenobi and BoBF.
It’s defo in the good books… think I’ll end up giving the series an overall 8/10.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
8 is far to high for me..... to me that means its very very good, close to being amazing (9) which it isnt for me.
its decent for me so far, granted Im coming at this from a position of not watching CW/Rebels
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I agree, it's not an 8 for me.
I think a 7 seems accurate.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I have to give it a 6 I think.... granted that would prob increase if I was up to date with the background material.
its above average but filling in the gaps means I need to drop it a point.
I would imagine there is a lot more answers for you guys and nostalgia being addressed from CW and Rebels.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
The Anakin episode alone boosts the season and the other CW and Rebels references.
However, they've done things in the show that feel different to the animated shows, which makes it less compelling at certain points.
My current live action ranking:
1. Mando season 2
2. Andor
3. Mando season 1
4. Mando season 3
5. Book of Boba
6. Obi Wan
comment by The Guvnor XI -Iron sharpens Iron- (U12889)
posted 48 minutes ago
My current live action ranking:
1. Mando season 2
2. Andor
3. Mando season 1
4. Mando season 3
5. Book of Boba
6. Obi Wan
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Can't disagree with this much. What makes it worse is both Mando 3 and Ahsoka are just filler. And as above Ahsoka can be confusing filler, like I can understand if this was gonna to be introducing the characters but they didn't, and it's straight up you need to have seen Rebels, and CW will help. I am not gonna lie, it's the most Star Warsy I would say out of all the live action, the feeling, the music, the spaceship stuff and even the light sabres are the best since ep3 (no where near as good, but the best we've had in 20 years!)
Sign in if you want to comment
A Galaxy Far Far Away......
Page 498 of 600
499 | 500 | 501 | 502 | 503
posted on 27/9/23
Mando 3 wasn’t average
posted on 27/9/23
comment by Hengy (U9129)
posted 13 minutes ago
Mando 3 wasn’t average
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Yeh, you’re right.. wasn’t average at all.
Fecking bantha fodder is what it is
posted on 27/9/23
comment by Hengy (U9129)
posted 30 minutes ago
Mando 3 wasn’t average
----------------------------------------------------------------------
it was average at best season 3 was about 5/10.
posted on 27/9/23
Ahsoka has been decent ... not much more for me than that tbh. hovering around the 6/10-7/10 mark above average but far from great.
posted on 27/9/23
5 lol
posted on 27/9/23
comment by Hengy (U9129)
posted 8 seconds ago
5 lol
----------------------------------------------------------------------
it was average .... 5/10 is average, slap bang in the middle.
posted on 27/9/23
OB1 was about a 3/10, 4 on a good day it was pretty poor.
BoB was 4/10 also not as bad as OB1 but both below average.
posted on 27/9/23
dave failoni
posted on 27/9/23
comment by Taki Minamino (U20650)
posted 32 seconds ago
dave failoni
----------------------------------------------------------------------
wouldnt quite say that.
Mando season 1 & 2 was right up there for me, that had me just as much as the original films did. I gave them 8-9/10.
I have seen CW but by all accounts its pretty damn good.
Ahoska is ok I certianly dont hate it. There is some big flaws however IMO.
I think its a very poor decision to make CW/Rebels not sure which almost mandatory watching if you want to know what is going on. Iv had to read up separate material in order for it to make sense to me.
If this was a complete casual watching it on the back of Mandalorian Im guessing they dont have a clue what going on!!!
posted on 27/9/23
*I havent seen CW
posted on 27/9/23
comment by whodunnit (U22710)
posted 1 hour, 20 minutes ago
comment by Taki Minamino (U20650)
posted 32 seconds ago
dave failoni
----------------------------------------------------------------------
wouldnt quite say that.
Mando season 1 & 2 was right up there for me, that had me just as much as the original films did. I gave them 8-9/10.
I have seen CW but by all accounts its pretty damn good.
Ahoska is ok I certianly dont hate it. There is some big flaws however IMO.
I think its a very poor decision to make CW/Rebels not sure which almost mandatory watching if you want to know what is going on. Iv had to read up separate material in order for it to make sense to me.
If this was a complete casual watching it on the back of Mandalorian Im guessing they dont have a clue what going on!!!
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Unfortunately this is true… my mates don’t have a clue who’s who, and don’t know why I was excited to see the Night Sisters… it’s been hard to explain.
And they won’t watch CW or Rebels.
Which has been said, these 2 animated shows, are essential viewing.
posted on 27/9/23
comment by StringerBell (U11749)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by whodunnit (U22710)
posted 1 hour, 20 minutes ago
comment by Taki Minamino (U20650)
posted 32 seconds ago
dave failoni
----------------------------------------------------------------------
wouldnt quite say that.
Mando season 1 & 2 was right up there for me, that had me just as much as the original films did. I gave them 8-9/10.
I have seen CW but by all accounts its pretty damn good.
Ahoska is ok I certianly dont hate it. There is some big flaws however IMO.
I think its a very poor decision to make CW/Rebels not sure which almost mandatory watching if you want to know what is going on. Iv had to read up separate material in order for it to make sense to me.
If this was a complete casual watching it on the back of Mandalorian Im guessing they dont have a clue what going on!!!
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Unfortunately this is true… my mates don’t have a clue who’s who, and don’t know why I was excited to see the Night Sisters… it’s been hard to explain.
And they won’t watch CW or Rebels.
Which has been said, these 2 animated shows, are essential viewing.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
yeah it really should have been made more clear its more a continuation of a different show. Thankfully the with stuff I out 2 and 2 together its not to hard to work out.
but space whales, the witches, Thrawn etc none of this has ever really been even referenced before (other than mando season 3) in any other SW show or film I have seen or if it was it was very subtly hinted at Im sure.
They defo appeared in the who as if you should already be aware of who they are and what they are about.
Same goes with Thrawn, as of yet to the average casual he is nothing more than another Imperial Officer.
posted on 27/9/23
They most probably think he’s Cad Banes brother or something, Red Eyes, Blue skin….
But Disney/LucasFilm boxed themselves into a corner, and in fear of losing viewership, they tried to say, nah, you don’t have to watch, well, maybe season 4 of Rebels….oh really, Nah Fam. That won’t fly…
posted on 27/9/23
I’m conflicted on my rating… the SW fan in me wants to boost the rating to 7.5.
As I said, the SW stuff is like a warm blanket… but then, I mean Sabine & Ezra.. I dunno…
But it’s safe to say, this show is miles better than Mando 3 and Kenobi and BoBF.
It’s defo in the good books… think I’ll end up giving the series an overall 8/10.
posted on 27/9/23
comment by StringerBell (U11749)
posted 3 minutes ago
I’m conflicted on my rating… the SW fan in me wants to boost the rating to 7.5.
As I said, the SW stuff is like a warm blanket… but then, I mean Sabine & Ezra.. I dunno…
But it’s safe to say, this show is miles better than Mando 3 and Kenobi and BoBF.
It’s defo in the good books… think I’ll end up giving the series an overall 8/10.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
8 is far to high for me..... to me that means its very very good, close to being amazing (9) which it isnt for me.
its decent for me so far, granted Im coming at this from a position of not watching CW/Rebels
posted on 27/9/23
Solid 4/10
posted on 27/9/23
comment by D'Jeezus Mackaroni (U1137)
posted 6 minutes ago
Solid 4/10
----------------------------------------------------------------------
get out of it you….
posted on 27/9/23
comment by Hengy (U9129)
posted 4 hours, 55 minutes ago
Mando 3 wasn’t average
----------------------------------------------------------------------
It certainly wasn't good. An easy 5 or 6/10.
posted on 27/9/23
can they do an anakin series while hes still young enough?
posted on 27/9/23
comment by Taki Minamino (U20650)
posted 27 minutes ago
can they do an anakin series while hes still young enough?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I would love an Anakin CW series.
posted on 27/9/23
comment by whodunnit (U22710)
posted 1 hour ago
comment by StringerBell (U11749)
posted 3 minutes ago
I’m conflicted on my rating… the SW fan in me wants to boost the rating to 7.5.
As I said, the SW stuff is like a warm blanket… but then, I mean Sabine & Ezra.. I dunno…
But it’s safe to say, this show is miles better than Mando 3 and Kenobi and BoBF.
It’s defo in the good books… think I’ll end up giving the series an overall 8/10.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
8 is far to high for me..... to me that means its very very good, close to being amazing (9) which it isnt for me.
its decent for me so far, granted Im coming at this from a position of not watching CW/Rebels
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I agree, it's not an 8 for me.
I think a 7 seems accurate.
posted on 27/9/23
comment by The Guvnor XI -Iron sharpens Iron- (U12889)
posted 4 minutes ago
comment by whodunnit (U22710)
posted 1 hour ago
comment by StringerBell (U11749)
posted 3 minutes ago
I’m conflicted on my rating… the SW fan in me wants to boost the rating to 7.5.
As I said, the SW stuff is like a warm blanket… but then, I mean Sabine & Ezra.. I dunno…
But it’s safe to say, this show is miles better than Mando 3 and Kenobi and BoBF.
It’s defo in the good books… think I’ll end up giving the series an overall 8/10.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
8 is far to high for me..... to me that means its very very good, close to being amazing (9) which it isnt for me.
its decent for me so far, granted Im coming at this from a position of not watching CW/Rebels
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I agree, it's not an 8 for me.
I think a 7 seems accurate.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I have to give it a 6 I think.... granted that would prob increase if I was up to date with the background material.
its above average but filling in the gaps means I need to drop it a point.
I would imagine there is a lot more answers for you guys and nostalgia being addressed from CW and Rebels.
posted on 27/9/23
comment by whodunnit (U22710)
posted 19 minutes ago
comment by The Guvnor XI -Iron sharpens Iron- (U12889)
posted 4 minutes ago
comment by whodunnit (U22710)
posted 1 hour ago
comment by StringerBell (U11749)
posted 3 minutes ago
I’m conflicted on my rating… the SW fan in me wants to boost the rating to 7.5.
As I said, the SW stuff is like a warm blanket… but then, I mean Sabine & Ezra.. I dunno…
But it’s safe to say, this show is miles better than Mando 3 and Kenobi and BoBF.
It’s defo in the good books… think I’ll end up giving the series an overall 8/10.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
8 is far to high for me..... to me that means its very very good, close to being amazing (9) which it isnt for me.
its decent for me so far, granted Im coming at this from a position of not watching CW/Rebels
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I agree, it's not an 8 for me.
I think a 7 seems accurate.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I have to give it a 6 I think.... granted that would prob increase if I was up to date with the background material.
its above average but filling in the gaps means I need to drop it a point.
I would imagine there is a lot more answers for you guys and nostalgia being addressed from CW and Rebels.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
The Anakin episode alone boosts the season and the other CW and Rebels references.
However, they've done things in the show that feel different to the animated shows, which makes it less compelling at certain points.
posted on 27/9/23
My current live action ranking:
1. Mando season 2
2. Andor
3. Mando season 1
4. Mando season 3
5. Book of Boba
6. Obi Wan
posted on 27/9/23
comment by The Guvnor XI -Iron sharpens Iron- (U12889)
posted 48 minutes ago
My current live action ranking:
1. Mando season 2
2. Andor
3. Mando season 1
4. Mando season 3
5. Book of Boba
6. Obi Wan
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Can't disagree with this much. What makes it worse is both Mando 3 and Ahsoka are just filler. And as above Ahsoka can be confusing filler, like I can understand if this was gonna to be introducing the characters but they didn't, and it's straight up you need to have seen Rebels, and CW will help. I am not gonna lie, it's the most Star Warsy I would say out of all the live action, the feeling, the music, the spaceship stuff and even the light sabres are the best since ep3 (no where near as good, but the best we've had in 20 years!)
Page 498 of 600
499 | 500 | 501 | 502 | 503