or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 71 comments are related to an article called:

My Transfer Targets Shortlist

Page 1 of 3

posted on 25/5/21

Attacking players: I was on board with the Sancho signing but I really do think this needs more of a depth signing, rather than a starter position given other needs

Sancho: £80m

Kane: £120m. Not happening unless the price is reduced dramatically.

Danny Ings: £20m. Can’t see it but it’s a budget friendly deal if it ever materializes.

Jack Grealish. £75m. Not leaving IMO but he’d be my first choice signing in this list.

Dele Alli: £15m-25m. Potentially a great Buy-Low situation. If Dele can find his form again, he’ll be a bargain.

Matheus Pereira: £30m. One of the most impactful players among the relegation teams. Extremely agile, great eye for the pass, and a great set piece taker. Think Mata with more athleticism.

Jonathan David: £30m. Lille’s hardworking CF, similar to Cavani. Could be someone to look at in the future but his value is only going to go up from here on out IMO.

Jonathan Ikone: £45m Lille’s RW who replaced Nicolas Pepe on the right flank. An inverted winger, he may be a fit in the counter attacking, high pressing formation Ole sets up.

Moussa Diaby/Leon Bailey: £45m apiece. Pacy wingers similar to Ikone. Could be a systems’ players so risk there

posted on 25/5/21

Chancel Mbemba
________

I'll be so upset if we don't sign this guy that I'll Chancel my Mbembaship.

posted on 25/5/21

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 25/5/21

Duje Caleta-Car:
--------------
This...this is the man to drive us forward

posted on 25/5/21

Ben White
Ebrima Darboe
Jadon Sancho

posted on 25/5/21

Excellent article 5 stars, well researched.
I will leave others less ignorant than me to pass judgement on the players, because there is a good junk I've never heard of.

posted on 25/5/21

Good article, I don't really watch foreign football so be interested in seeing what others think of those suggestions.

posted on 25/5/21

Great to have some info on the lesser know talents out there. 5 stars from me mate.

posted on 25/5/21

Great list of suggestions, would be happy with any of those if we signed them. Awful collection of players mostly from farmers leagues if we don't sign them. I have never seen any of them play.

posted on 25/5/21

Ben White for under 30m seems incredibly ambitious. They knocked back 25m last summer from Leeds and now he's in the England squad, proven in the Premier League and you're Manchester United. You paid 80m for Maguire. Double your estimate ​to get the deal done i reckon.

Grealish is the one that in my opinion that comes into United takes them on a level.

White, Rice, Grealish.

200m no change.

posted on 25/5/21

The main talking point that stands out for me in this article would be if from your list of attackers, we really need a RW (Sancho, for example?) or if we should focus on getting Kane who there have been more solid links to?

posted on 25/5/21

White, Rice, Grealish.

200m no change.
------------------------------------------------------------

Not enough money in the piggy bank

comment by Phenom (U20037)

posted on 25/5/21

apparently Soumare was a banker to join Leicester, but he'd be moving to a club without CL next season if he did so

posted on 25/5/21

comment by HB Fash - "like a pack of cards" (U21935)
posted 1 minute ago
Ben White for under 30m seems incredibly ambitious. They knocked back 25m last summer from Leeds and now he's in the England squad, proven in the Premier League and you're Manchester United. You paid 80m for Maguire. Double your estimate ​to get the deal done i reckon.

Grealish is the one that in my opinion that comes into United takes them on a level.

White, Rice, Grealish.

200m no change.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I had majority of the article written out last week. I forgot to submit it. White making the provisional squad will definitely kick up his price tag for sure, I agree.

Potter leaving BHA should make this an interesting proposition.

posted on 25/5/21

comment by HB Fash - "like a pack of cards" (U21935)
posted 1 minute ago
Ben White for under 30m seems incredibly ambitious. They knocked back 25m last summer from Leeds and now he's in the England squad, proven in the Premier League and you're Manchester United. You paid 80m for Maguire. Double your estimate ​to get the deal done i reckon.

Grealish is the one that in my opinion that comes into United takes them on a level.

White, Rice, Grealish.

200m no change.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Henderson
AWB White Maguire Shaw
Rice McT
Greenwood Lingard Grealish
Rashford

Brexit FC

posted on 25/5/21

Some of you may laugh off of the players I'd mention up there but you're essentially getting a player before the likes of Dortmund/Leicester/etc and cutting out the inflated prices you would need to pay if these players turn out to be good.

I had a lot of difficulty figuring out the valuation on the players without price tags because on one hand, I was factoring in COVID and on the other, I didn't want to factor in COVID.

posted on 25/5/21

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 25/5/21

Also, I factored out the valuation on these players with the clubs financials in mind too. Racic, for example, is playing for a Valencia club that has an owner gone rogue and refuse to pay top dollars for players.

posted on 25/5/21

comment by Freedom FC (Diamond Hands) (U7214)
posted 1 minute ago
Some of you may laugh off of the players I'd mention up there but you're essentially getting a player before the likes of Dortmund/Leicester/etc and cutting out the inflated prices you would need to pay if these players turn out to be good.

I had a lot of difficulty figuring out the valuation on the players without price tags because on one hand, I was factoring in COVID and on the other, I didn't want to factor in COVID.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
This is the frustrating thing with our scouts in recent times when you see players go to clubs like Leicester for low fees and within a short space of time they have someone at the level of Ndidi that we're crying out for.

Whether we'd have been able to get him at the same cost, or if the price goes up when we become interested I don't know, or perhaps they're more able to take a gamble on these types of players than we are where the manager is sacked if they don't make top 4.

posted on 25/5/21

comment by -bloodred- (U1222)
posted 15 minutes ago
Duje Caleta-Car:
--------------
This...this is the man to drive us forward
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I actually like his game. He's to OM what Harry is to us. Liverpool was close to bringing him in January but Caleta-Car decided he wanted to stay in France.

https://www.goal.com/en-us/news/marseille-caleta-car-turned-down-liverpool-offer-january/14pd1r5hz38np1rub2re6bicuc

posted on 25/5/21

comment by Michael. (U1170)
posted 3 minutes ago
comment by Freedom FC (Diamond Hands) (U7214)
posted 1 minute ago
Some of you may laugh off of the players I'd mention up there but you're essentially getting a player before the likes of Dortmund/Leicester/etc and cutting out the inflated prices you would need to pay if these players turn out to be good.

I had a lot of difficulty figuring out the valuation on the players without price tags because on one hand, I was factoring in COVID and on the other, I didn't want to factor in COVID.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
This is the frustrating thing with our scouts in recent times when you see players go to clubs like Leicester for low fees and within a short space of time they have someone at the level of Ndidi that we're crying out for.

Whether we'd have been able to get him at the same cost, or if the price goes up when we become interested I don't know, or perhaps they're more able to take a gamble on these types of players than we are where the manager is sacked if they don't make top 4.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I'm looking forward to circling back on this article to see how many of these players succeeded in the next club they go to.

A lot of the names stemmed from researching players linked to the clubs big on developing young players (Dortmund, Red Bull, etc)

posted on 25/5/21

comment by Barf Vader (U15867)
posted 16 minutes ago
White, Rice, Grealish.

200m no change.
------------------------------------------------------------

Not enough money in the piggy bank
----------------------------------------------------------------------
If you look at the last earnings call, we have around £80m in cash reserve with a £140m in revolving door credit. I'd say we have around £150m to spend before the debt level creeps upwards again

comment by Pun (U21588)

posted on 25/5/21

Excellent article, deserved 5 stars. Clearly a lot of work gone into it. And some nice puns above.

comment by Neo (U9135)

posted on 25/5/21

Duje Caleta-Car: £20m-30m. Recently turned down a move to Liverpool

-----

course he did mate

posted on 25/5/21

comment by Michael. (U1170)
posted 22 minutes ago
The main talking point that stands out for me in this article would be if from your list of attackers, we really need a RW (Sancho, for example?) or if we should focus on getting Kane who there have been more solid links to?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
The reason why I think this should/will be a depth signing is because I think Ole wants to gamble on Amad and Pellistri to fill the void. I'm not sure if I agree with this move but that's how I see it.

Amad has been pretty promising and Pellistri has been getting a decent run of games for Alaves and had his best moments against Atletico. Bringing in a 21 year old Sancho means you're writing off the two of them having a career at Old Trafford, with Amad costing an excess of £30m.

A more budget attacker in his prime will more likely be the move United makes this summer.

Page 1 of 3

Sign in if you want to comment