or to join or start a new Discussion

24 Comments
Article Rating     Not Rated Yet

Hearts 0 - 3 Celtic

Game of 2 halves really yesterday.

1st was what we'd came to expect from this team for most of last season and most of this.

Lacking any urgency, bereft of quality, sideways passing all in all I expected much better for a game of that magnitude we simply didn't look at the races and at half time I could see extra time and pens as a possibility.

Second half however with the 2 changes and McGregor dropping deeper we got into our stride and start looking again like the team of 2 season ago. Sometimes losing players to injury is a blessing and Ntcham going off was a blessing, he often slows the game down to his speed whereas McGregor in a deeper role always wants to move the ball quickly, his link up play with Christie/Rogic was brilliant.

Ratings

Bain (6) - Didn't have anything to do, hope he doesn't get bombed out for the final.

Lustig (8) - He gives us 5/6 performances a season where you remember why he was so loved at one point, this was one of them, passing was brilliant, he was up and down the line all day, defensively sound.

Ajer (8) - To come back in to a big game like that and perform as well as he did was fantastic, got caught on the ball a few times at the start but that's expected after so long out.

Benkovic (8) - Straight out of the Stubbs and VVD passing school , pinging balls on to toes all day long, looks a top talent.

Tierney (8.5) - ~Him and Sinclair were causing carnage second half down the left hand side, tbh he was probably the only player who looked like creating anything in the first half for us. What a boy.

Ntcham (3) & Eboue (3) - Didn't have any effect on the game and picking up injuries probably helped us.

Rogic (8) - 2 sides of Rogic, 1st half touch was off, ran into traffic everytime he got the ball, wanted to long on the ball. 2nd half it was the exact opposite. Such a silky player.

Forrest (7) - First half we was doubled up on and ineffective, 2nd half he started coming centrally to get on the ball and was the beneficiary of the tempo being upped by the introduction of Christie and McGregor to the middle of the park.

McGregor (7.5) - Was awful in the first half again like most he produced the opposite of what he produced in the first half, he even put a few decent corners in which was surprising.

Edouard (6) - Bit of a meh performance, should've had a hat trick but for some great defending but at times his touch was as poor as I can remember. We need a reliable back up striker.


Sinclair was fantastic, looked like the Sinclair of old, great bottle for the penalty and should've himself had a hat trick.

Christie finally announcing himself as a Celtic player, after putting in a terrific shift on Thursday he was probably unfortunate not to start, I think a 3 of him Rogic and McGregor could certainly work for home league games

Hendry - man of the match

Rodgers got the substitutions spot on they changed the course of the game, still disappointed in the lack of urgency again from the start. Not sure if the Naismith injury changed the game as much as Stewart was trying to make out but it certainly made our job easier

comment by NNH (U10730)

posted on 29/10/18

Ivan, no DUFC article after another win for the tangerine army?

posted on 29/10/18

comment by NNH (U10730)
posted 48 seconds ago
Ivan, no DUFC article after another win for the tangerine army?
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Arab Abroad had already posted a report on the game on the United board so didn't bother.

The resurgence continues

posted on 29/10/18

Difference first half and second half with Edouard is probably that he was switching with sinclair and drifting out wide to find space.

Decent article Ghod.

posted on 29/10/18

Comment Deleted by Site Moderator

comment by JFK (U8919)

posted on 29/10/18

Arab Abroad had already posted a report on the game on the United board
========

on the what board?

posted on 29/10/18

comment by JFK - Trebles for the Rebels (U8919)
posted 1 minute ago
Arab Abroad had already posted a report on the game on the United board
========

on the what board?
----------------------------------------------------------------------

You're a bully

comment by NNH (U10730)

posted on 29/10/18


posted on 29/10/18

Ntcham is a dud, offers feck all.

comment by Sjb1888 (U5188)

posted on 29/10/18

Ntcham will be back running the show soon enough, he's a quality player, probably our best outwith KT.

posted on 29/10/18

Disagree on Rogic

Not your Description but rating. Awful first half great second half cannot get an 8

Much like Edouard who has poor first half and great second half he only got a 6

Sign in if you want to comment
RATE THIS ARTICLE
Rate Breakdown
5
0 Votes
4
0 Votes
3
0 Votes
2
0 Votes
1
0 Votes

Average Rating: 0 from 0 votes

ARTICLE STATS
Day
Article RankingNot Ranked
Article ViewsNot Available
Average Time(mins)Not Available
Total Time(mins)Not Available
Month
Article RankingNot Ranked
Article ViewsNot Available
Average Time(mins)Not Available
Total Time(mins)Not Available