Rashford or Lukaku.

Oh, I like Lingard, just play him in his best role... AMF

Rashford. At least he offers movement and pace, which opens up space for others. Lukaku is a gargoyle.

Rashford at least brings out more in those around him. His movement gives the midfield somebody to look up for, he cna make runs in behind or in the channels and he can actually control a football.

Im unsure what's happened to lukaku, even at his best he limits us but his basic footballing instincts seem to have disappeared.

I never rated Lukaku as a complete striker but some things he used to do really well - basically when he was running on to a ball in front of him. wtf has happened to him?

Rashford. When both aren't scoring, he brings more to the team.

Rashford give the attack a much better dimension. Problem is his finishing isn’t up to scratch. But fight now neither is Lukaku’s and he’s too fat to run.

Not remotely close to being a realistic issue.

Lukaku is an ideal striker/centre forward for an epl club with genuine aspirations of success

Rashford isn't. At best he's a 60 minute substitute.

The real issue/choice should be about lukaku and/or another MUFC quality striker. He can't carry weak midfield selection through an entire season on hs own.

Rashford.

Neither are an ideal option but Lukaku offers the team absolutely nothing at the moment.

Or Chicharito?
He's on a hat trick today

Looks like both today.