or to join or start a new Discussion

29 Comments
Article Rating 5 Stars

The Natural Silhouette

Objectively looking at Llorente's goal - i can't believe there's so much debate around whether it should or shouldn't be allowed.

Under IFAB rule there's a part about players having a "natural silhouette" which to say if the players arm is away fron this then its a handball.

Llorente had his arm tucked into his body and unless where going to tie footballers hands and have them run like T-Rex for 90 mins it will always occur.

For me disallowing that goal would be like a defender protecting his crotch on a free kick, the ball hitting it and calling a penalty.

If that goal was conceded by Spurs, sure you'd be annoyed and call for handball (as you would for anything to go your way) but at the end of the day you have to accept it.

posted on 18/4/19

comment by Ace (U18814)
posted 2 minutes ago
comment by Desperate Dier (U6468)
posted 16 minutes ago
comment by NotSoMagicJuande (U1913)
posted 1 minute ago
I don't even really seeing it hitting his arm at all, it was just off his hip. No debate about it standing, for me.

The City offside disallowed goal though, I cannot believe we got away with that. Not a single spurs player called for it. Ridiculously harsh.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Images show he was clearly offside and not fractionally his whole body.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Didn’t even occur to me that there was an offside. I thought Eriksens pass back had gone directly to Aguero. It all happened so fast. I was slumped on the sofa with my head in my hands, having to listen to that mug commentator cheerleading for City. Even when he said VAR review in progress I didn’t get my head out of my hands because I just don’t expect things like that to work in our favour. The facking euphoria of it not being given - it was more like a stunned shock. I didn’t even celebrate, just got up and paced round the room praying we could see out the last two minutes!
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Exactly the same

Didn't even cheer.

posted on 18/4/19

100% a legit goal.

Off the biggest donkey on the pitch. Funnily enough my old man said when he came on, he scores the winner

posted on 18/4/19

comment by HB Fash (U21935)
posted 25 seconds ago
100% a legit goal.

Off the biggest donkey on the pitch. Funnily enough my old man said when he came on, he scores the winner
----------------------------------------------------------------------
He played well to be honest

comment by (U18814)

posted on 18/4/19

Comment Deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 18/4/19

comment by Ace (U18814)
posted 11 minutes ago
comment by HB Fash (U21935)
posted 4 minutes ago
100% a legit goal.

Off the biggest donkey on the pitch. Funnily enough my old man said when he came on, he scores the winner
----------------------------------------------------------------------

That’s harsh mate Llorente isn’t a donkey at all.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Maybe so but i don't rate him, he looks very awkward and he was out of gas by 80mins after coming on as a sub.

I'd say his time at this level is up, but what a moment to take with him

comment by (U18814)

posted on 18/4/19

Comment Deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 18/4/19

There is no debate, despite the gutted media trying to make out It was handball, it wasn't.

His arm was in a natural position
He did not move his arm towards the ball
It was completely unintentional

posted on 18/4/19

comment by The Spanish Italians (U21595)
posted 1 hour, 45 minutes ago
Llorente had his arm tucked into his body and unless where going to tie footballers hands and have them run like T-Rex for 90 mins it will always occur.

-----------

Sterling does


----------------------------------------------------------------------
sterling runs like he's carrying a purse.

comment by Analog (U17200)

posted on 18/4/19

Llorente is a poor footballer tbh but credit where credit's due, he does pop up with goals when we need him to

posted on 18/4/19

comment by NotSoMagicJuande (U1913)
posted 1 hour, 55 minutes ago
I don't even really seeing it hitting his arm at all, it was just off his hip. No debate about it standing, for me.

The City offside disallowed goal though, I cannot believe we got away with that. Not a single spurs player called for it. Ridiculously harsh.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I actually agree with both points here to the tee. It never hit his hand/elbow, but his thigh, then hit the defender's hand. But did you all notice that most of our defenders (first goal against us) had their hands behind their backs? Probably due to the penalty last week. This VAR is actually changing our game radically, and yes it went in our favor at the end, but I am not sure I like it one iota.

And yup, I agree too that oh well you get unfair decisions for and against, but that wasn't offside when their goal was disallowed. It was an absolute classic of a Spursy moment (the amount of games won in the last 90+ minutes of the game for many teams this season has been numerous).

But oh well, we won, and well that's football, and I won't complain. But we was definitely lucky like never before.

Sign in if you want to comment
RATE THIS ARTICLE
Rate Breakdown
5
0 Votes
4
0 Votes
3
0 Votes
2
0 Votes
1
0 Votes

Average Rating: 5 from 3 votes

ARTICLE STATS
Day
Article RankingNot Ranked
Article ViewsNot Available
Average Time(mins)Not Available
Total Time(mins)Not Available
Month
Article RankingNot Ranked
Article ViewsNot Available
Average Time(mins)Not Available
Total Time(mins)Not Available